Letter and information from Ian MacLaurin Chairman of Tesco to shareholders of Hilards page 4 of 6 previous next
Below is what the machine read from this scan, three times over. They are kept separate rather than merged: where they disagree, the disagreement is itself worth seeing, and a single tidy transcription would hide it.
The left column is raw output. The right is the same text after the repairs that make it searchable — joining letter-spaced words, mending split ones.
Text already in the scan
JAMES CAPEL, Stockbrokers
28th April, 1987
. . . . Hillards' forecast of 87/88 pre-tax profits of £15m represents an increase in profits of 30 per cent,
even stripping out the benefit of the rights issue cash. With the profit share expected to virtually double,
this implies an even more rapid increase in operating profits. However looking at the recent record
and the intensification in competitive store openings in the future, this rate of growth would be hard
t o s u s t a i n .
The increased terms certainly represent a far offer for Hillards, particularly bearing in mind some of the
longer term uncertainties, while there would be significant downside for Hillards' shares if the bid were not
to succeed. The outlook for Tesco looks good, with the prospect that, if the bid is successful, forecasts
for 87/88 eps could even rise slightly, and the shares should perform well
BARCLAYS DE ZOETE WEDD, Stockbrokers
27th April, 1987
.... There is nothing startling about the initiatives Hillards is undertaking. Indeed, they amount to the kinds
of developments any competent food retailer would be expected to pursue, and if anything, Hillards has
been rather slower than its competitors to react to the changes occurring in the industry. Since 1985, its
share of the Yorkshire market has at best been static, and that of the national market in decline, despite
opening six large superstores. Its poor sales performance is evidenced by the 3.4 per cent, decline in volume
in like for like stores in the year to April 1986 and the nil increase in the seven months to November 1986.
We understand sales have shown a 3 per cent, volume increase in like stores in the year to April '87,
implying a strong second half performance.
We would certainly expect these developments to have a positive impact on both sales and margins over
the next two to three years. However, the forecast for 87/8 profits and the optimistic scenario painted
about future prospects takes a lot on trust. In particular, it assumes that the retail formula they are evolving
will prove more effective than the one it replaces; that the volume gains they have achieved in the second
half of 86/7 can be sustained; and that the trading environment does not become more difficult than it
is at present despite the increasing encroachment of other multiples In sum, there are considerable
uncertainties inherent in a continuing investment in Hillards to be weighed against the certainty of a
generous offer from Tesco, which very fully values the business. Should the bid fail, we would expect
Hillards to trade, at best, on a prospective multiple of 15 which implies a 25 per cent, downside from
the current price level
. . . . Tesco's increased offer is a generous one which very fully values the Hillards business. We believe
that an investment in the enlarged Tesco group will prove more rewarding over the next two to three
years than a holding in an independent Hillards, as Tesco is better equipped to thrive in the Increasingly
competitive retail environment, given the strength of both its retail formula and its financial resources
which will enable it to undertake the major programme of store development which is necessary for
future growth.
RECOMMENDAT ION : ACCEPT TESCO OFFERJAMES CAPEL, Stockbrokers 28th April,1987 . . . . Hillards' forecast of 87/88 pre-tax profits of £15m represents an increase in profits of 30 per cent, even stripping out the benefit of the rights issue cash. With the profit share expected to virtually double, this implies an even more rapid increase in operating profits. However looking at the recent record and the intensification in competitive store openings in the future, this rate of growth would be hard tosustain . The increased terms certainly represent a far offer for Hillards, particularly bearing in mind some of the longer term uncertainties, while there would be significant downside for Hillards' shares if the bid were not to succeed. The outlook for Tesco looks good, with the prospect that, if the bid is successful, forecasts for 87/88 eps could even rise slightly, and the shares should perform well BARCLAYS DE ZOETE WEDD, Stockbrokers 27th April,1987 ....There is nothing startling about the initiatives Hillards is undertaking. Indeed, they amount to the kinds of developments any competent food retailer would be expected to pursue, and if anything, Hillards has been rather slower than its competitors to react to the changes occurring in the industry. Since1985, its share of the Yorkshire market has at best been static, and that of the national market in decline, despite opening six large superstores. Its poor sales performance is evidenced by the 3.4percent, decline in volume in like for like stores in the year to April1986 and the nil increase in the seven months to November1986. We understand sales have shown a 3 per cent, volume increase in like stores in the year to April'87, implying a strong second half performance. We would certainly expect these developments to have a positive impact on both sales and margins over the next two to three years. However, the forecast for 87/8profits and the optimistic scenario painted about future prospects takes a lot on trust. In particular, it assumes that the retail formula they are evolving will prove more effective than the one it replaces; that the volume gains they have achieved in the second half of 86/7 can be sustained; and that the trading environment does not become more difficult than it is at present despite the increasing encroachment of other multiples In sum, there are considerable uncertainties inherent in a continuing investment in Hillards to be weighed against the certainty of a generous offer from Tesco, which very fully values the business. Should the bid fail, we would expect Hillards to trade, at best, on a prospective multiple of 15 which implies a 25 per cent, downside from the current price level . . . . Tesco's increased offer is a generous one which very fully values the Hillards business. We believe that an investment in the enlarged Tesco group will prove more rewarding over the next two to three years than a holding in an independent Hillards, as Tesco is better equipped to thrive in the Increasingly competitive retail environment, given the strength of both its retail formula and its financial resources which will enable it to undertake the major programme of store development which is necessary for future growth. RECOMMENDATION: ACCEPT TESCO OFFER
Read by machine highest quality of the three
JAMES CAPEL, Stockbrokers
28th April, 1987
forecast of 87/88 pre-tax profits of £15m represents an increase in profits of 30 per cent.
even stripping out the benefit of the rights issue cash. With the profit share expected to virtually double,
this implies an even more rapid increase in operating profits. However looking at the recent record
and the intensification in competitive store openings in the future, this rate of growth would be hard
to sustain.
The increased terms certainly represent a fair offer for Hillards, particularly bearing in mind some of the
longer term uncertainties, while there would be significant downside for Hillards’ shares if the bid were not
to succeed. The outlook for Tesco looks good, with the prospect that, if the bid is successful, forecasts
for 87/88 eps could even rise slightly, and the shares should perform well. .
...
BARCLAYS DE ZOETE WEDD, Stockbrokers
27th April, 1987
.... There is nothing startling about the initiatives Hillards is undertaking. Indeed, they amount to the kinds
of developments any competent food retailer would be expected to pursue, and if anything, Hillards has
been rather slower than its competitors to react to the changes occurring in the industry. Since 1985, its
share of the Yorkshire market has at best been static, and that of the national market in decline, despite
opening six large superstores. Its poor sales performance is evidenced by the 3.4 per cent. decline in volume
in like for like stores in the year to April 1986 and the nil increase in the seven months to November 1986.
We understand sales have shown a 3 per cent. volume increase in like stores in the year to April ‘87,
implying a strong second half performance.
We would certainly expect these developments to have a positive impact on both sales and margins over
the next two to three years. However, the forecast for 87/8 profits and the optimistic scenario painted
about future prospects takes a lot on trust. In particular, it assumes that the retail formula they are evolving
will prove more effective than the one it replaces; that the volume gains they have achieved in the second
half of 86/7 can be sustained; and that the trading environment does not become more difficult than it
is at present despite the increasing encroachment of other multiples. . . . . In sum, there are considerable
uncertainties inherent in a continuing investment in Hillards to be weighed against the certainty of a
generous offer from Tesco, which very fully values the business. Should the bid fail, we would expect
Hillards to trade, at best, on a prospective multiple of 15 which implies a 25 per cent. downside from
the current price level.....
.... Tesco’s increased offer is a generous one which very fully values the Hillards business. We believe
that an investment in the enlarged Tesco group will prove more rewarding over the next two to three
years than a holding in an independent Hillards, as Tesco is better equipped to thrive in the increasingly
competitive retail environment, given the strength of both its retail formula and its financial resources
which will enable it to undertake the major programme of store development which is necessary for
future growth.
RECOMMENDATION : ACCEPT TESCO OFFERJAMES CAPEL, Stockbrokers 28th April,1987 forecast of 87/88 pre-tax profits of £15m represents an increase in profits of 30 per cent. even stripping out the benefit of the rights issue cash. With the profit share expected to virtually double, this implies an even more rapid increase in operating profits. However looking at the recent record and the intensification in competitive store openings in the future, this rate of growth would be hard to sustain. The increased terms certainly represent a fair offer for Hillards, particularly bearing in mind some of the longer term uncertainties, while there would be significant downside for Hillards' shares if the bid were not to succeed. The outlook for Tesco looks good, with the prospect that, if the bid is successful, forecasts for 87/88 eps could even rise slightly, and the shares should perform well. . ... BARCLAYS DE ZOETE WEDD, Stockbrokers 27th April,1987 ....There is nothing startling about the initiatives Hillards is undertaking. Indeed, they amount to the kinds of developments any competent food retailer would be expected to pursue, and if anything, Hillards has been rather slower than its competitors to react to the changes occurring in the industry. Since1985, its share of the Yorkshire market has at best been static, and that of the national market in decline, despite opening six large superstores. Its poor sales performance is evidenced by the 3.4percent. decline in volume in like for like stores in the year to April1986 and the nil increase in the seven months to November1986. We understand sales have shown a 3 per cent. volume increase in like stores in the year to April'87, implying a strong second half performance. We would certainly expect these developments to have a positive impact on both sales and margins over the next two to three years. However, the forecast for 87/8profits and the optimistic scenario painted about future prospects takes a lot on trust. In particular, it assumes that the retail formula they are evolving will prove more effective than the one it replaces; that the volume gains they have achieved in the second half of 86/7 can be sustained; and that the trading environment does not become more difficult than it is at present despite the increasing encroachment of other multiples. . . . . In sum, there are considerable uncertainties inherent in a continuing investment in Hillards to be weighed against the certainty of a generous offer from Tesco, which very fully values the business. Should the bid fail, we would expect Hillards to trade, at best, on a prospective multiple of 15 which implies a 25 per cent. downside from the current price level..... ....Tesco's increased offer is a generous one which very fully values the Hillards business. We believe that an investment in the enlarged Tesco group will prove more rewarding over the next two to three years than a holding in an independent Hillards, as Tesco is better equipped to thrive in the increasingly competitive retail environment, given the strength of both its retail formula and its financial resources which will enable it to undertake the major programme of store development which is necessary for future growth. RECOMMENDATION : ACCEPT TESCO OFFER
Read by machine, contrast corrected
JAMES CAPEL, Stockbrokers
28th April, 1987
....Hillards’ forecast of 87/88 pre-tax profits of £15m represents an increase in profits of 30 per cent.
even stripping out the benefit of the rights issue cash. With the profit share expected to virtually double,
this implies an even more rapid increase in operating profits. However looking at the recent record
and the intensification in competitive store openings in the future, this rate of growth would be hard
to sustain.
The increased terms certainly represent a fair offer for Hillards, particularly bearing in mind some of the
longer term uncertainties, while there would be significant downside for Hillards’ shares if the bid were not
to succeed. The outlook for Tesco looks good, with the prospect that, if the bid is successful, forecasts
for 87/88 eps could even rise slightly, and the shares should perform well. .
...
BARCLAYS DE ZOETE WEDD, Stockbrokers
27th April, 1987
.... There is nothing startling about the initiatives Hillards is undertaking. Indeed, they amount to the kinds
of developments any competent food retailer would be expected to pursue, and if anything, Hillards has
been rather slower than its competitors to react to the changes occurring in the industry. Since 1985, its
share of the Yorkshire market has at best been static, and that of the national market in decline, despite
opening six large superstores. Its poor sales performance is evidenced by the 3.4 per cent. decline in volume
in like for like stores in the year to April 1986 and the nil increase in the seven months to November 1986.
We understand sales have shown a 3 per cent. volume increase in like stores in the year to April
implying a strong second half performance.
We would certainly expect these developments to have a positive impact on both sales and margins over
the next two to three years. However, the forecast for 87/8 profits and the optimistic scenario painted
about future prospects takes a lot on trust. In particular, it assumes that the retail formula they are evolving
will prove more effective than the one it replaces; that the volume gains they have achieved in the second
half of 86/7 can be sustained; and that the trading environment does not become more difficult than it
is at present despite the increasing encroachment of other multiples. . . . . In sum, there are considerable
uncertainties inherent in a continuing investment in Hillards to be weighed against the certainty of a
generous offer from Tesco, which very fully values the business. Should the bid fail, we would expect
Hillards to trade, at best, on a prospective multiple of 15 which implies a 25 per cent. downside from
the current price level.....
.... Tesco’s increased offer is a generous one which very fully values the Hillards business. We believe
that an investment in the enlarged Tesco group will prove more rewarding over the next two to three
years than a holding in an independent Hillards, as Tesco is better equipped to thrive in the increasingly
competitive retail environment, given the strength of both its retail formula and its financial resources
which will enable it to undertake the major programme of store development which is necessary for
future growth.
RECOMMENDATION : ACCEPT TESCO OFFERJAMES CAPEL, Stockbrokers 28th April,1987 ....Hillards' forecast of 87/88 pre-tax profits of £15m represents an increase in profits of 30 per cent. even stripping out the benefit of the rights issue cash. With the profit share expected to virtually double, this implies an even more rapid increase in operating profits. However looking at the recent record and the intensification in competitive store openings in the future, this rate of growth would be hard to sustain. The increased terms certainly represent a fair offer for Hillards, particularly bearing in mind some of the longer term uncertainties, while there would be significant downside for Hillards' shares if the bid were not to succeed. The outlook for Tesco looks good, with the prospect that, if the bid is successful, forecasts for 87/88 eps could even rise slightly, and the shares should perform well. . ... BARCLAYS DE ZOETE WEDD, Stockbrokers 27th April,1987 ....There is nothing startling about the initiatives Hillards is undertaking. Indeed, they amount to the kinds of developments any competent food retailer would be expected to pursue, and if anything, Hillards has been rather slower than its competitors to react to the changes occurring in the industry. Since1985, its share of the Yorkshire market has at best been static, and that of the national market in decline, despite opening six large superstores. Its poor sales performance is evidenced by the 3.4percent. decline in volume in like for like stores in the year to April1986 and the nil increase in the seven months to November1986. We understand sales have shown a 3 per cent. volume increase in like stores in the year to April implying a strong second half performance. We would certainly expect these developments to have a positive impact on both sales and margins over the next two to three years. However, the forecast for 87/8profits and the optimistic scenario painted about future prospects takes a lot on trust. In particular, it assumes that the retail formula they are evolving will prove more effective than the one it replaces; that the volume gains they have achieved in the second half of 86/7 can be sustained; and that the trading environment does not become more difficult than it is at present despite the increasing encroachment of other multiples. . . . . In sum, there are considerable uncertainties inherent in a continuing investment in Hillards to be weighed against the certainty of a generous offer from Tesco, which very fully values the business. Should the bid fail, we would expect Hillards to trade, at best, on a prospective multiple of 15 which implies a 25 per cent. downside from the current price level..... ....Tesco's increased offer is a generous one which very fully values the Hillards business. We believe that an investment in the enlarged Tesco group will prove more rewarding over the next two to three years than a holding in an independent Hillards, as Tesco is better equipped to thrive in the increasingly competitive retail environment, given the strength of both its retail formula and its financial resources which will enable it to undertake the major programme of store development which is necessary for future growth. RECOMMENDATION : ACCEPT TESCO OFFER