Hillards takeover

Algorithmic Indexing

387 documents 1,432 pages

Letter to Gordon Young from County Limited   page 3 of 4   previous   next

Scan of page 3 of Letter to Gordon Young from County Limited

Below is what the machine read from this scan, three times over. They are kept separate rather than merged: where they disagree, the disagreement is itself worth seeing, and a single tidy transcription would hide it.

The left column is raw output. The right is the same text after the repairs that make it searchable — joining letter-spaced words, mending split ones.

Text already in the scan

                                                                       C o u n t y

    P a g e       - 2 -
    J . G .     R i d i n g s      E s q . ,
    2 1   A p r i l       1 9 8 7

    2 .   I   n     H i l l a r d s '               e s t a b l i s h e d      s t o r e s    l i k e     f o r l   i   k e   ( i .  e .    n e t   o f
                o p e n i n g s / c l o s u r e s            a n d     i n fl a t i o n )       v o l u m e     h a s  d e c l i n e d        i  n
                e a c h     o f       t h e    l   a s t   t h r e e   y e a r s      a n d     w a s       o n l y     s t a t i c   i n   t h e
                fi r s t    h a l f       o f       t h e   c u r r e n t        fi n a n c i a l      y e a r .          S h a r e h o l d e r s
                o u g h t     t o     b e      g i v e n     a       b r e a k d o w n    o f     t h e   s a l e s    i  n c r e a s e
                i d e n t i f y i n g           l i k e - f o r - l i k e    s a l e s    a s s u m p t i o n s .
    3.       In            1985/6     Hillards'                     sales     per     square                foot,     the         most           telling
                m e a s u r e         o f      r e t a i l i n g    p e r f o r m a n c e       a n d           e f fi c i e n c y,   f e l l    f r o m
                t h e    p r e v i o u s          y e a r   a n d  w a s          s o m e     1 3    p e r     c e n t ,    l e s s   t h a n    t h a t
                f o r    M o r r i s o n s         -     a  s u c c e s s f u l       r e g i o n a l         c o m p e t i t o r .      T h i s ,
                together              with            the   market               share    and          volume       decline,                   point
                to     a    weak                    brand  unable          to               compete    effectively            with          new
                c o m p e t i t o r       o p e n i n g s .
    4.   Since           the                    beginning   of           1984    competitors              have                 opened            new 23
                s t o r e s           w i t h i n  a       fi v e     m i l e    r a d i u s     o f     H i l l a r d s '    s t o r e s .      I n
             addition,                some             43   planning             consents       have                  been             approved
             w it h i n      five            m i les         of          H i l la rds'    ex ist i ng           sto res                tota l l i ng
                i n    e x c e s s        o f        1 .5   m i l l i o n     s q u a r e     fe e t .      We      c a n ,   w i t h i n     a
             f e w      h o u r s         n o t i c e ,      s u p p l y     d e t a i l s      s u p p o r t i n g     t h e s e         s t a t i s t i c s ,
                i f r e q u i r e d .

 5 . W e b e l i e v e t h a t , i n t h e p a s t , H i l l a r d s h a s i n c r e a s e d
             p r i c e s     t o      m a i n t a i n        o r  i m p r o v e       m a r g i n s         a n d     i n c r e a s e    s h o r t -
             t e r m        p r o fi t a b i l i t y     a t    t h e        e x p e n s e      o f    s a l e s        v o l u m e   a n d
             longer          term                           profitability .          These      increases           appear                 to
             have           been          unsustainable and                         have        had         an              adverse   effect       on
             Hillards'                market         share                and     volume.       The assumptions                                 made
             o n     p r i c i n g        l     e v e l s   o n   a    p r o fi t     f o r e c a s t       w o u l d         t h e r e f o r e  b e
             particularly                    relevant               to                   shareholders     in    assessing                   the
             f o r e c a s t .

             W e     u n d e r s tand that                       in   1987/8                 Hillards     is    planning          to            open
             t h r e e         n e w    s t o r e s     a t      D o n c a s t e r ,        L e e d s   a n d      C a r l t o n     a n d    t o
       r e f u r b i s h f o u r e x i s t i n g s t o r e s . S t o r e o p e n i n g s a n d
             r e l a u n c h e        s   are      usually             accompanied                     by                aggressive   pricing
             p o l i c i e s       i  n         o r d e r   t o     s o l i c i t   n e w c u s t o m e r s .       F u r t h e r m o r e
             s a l e s         a r e    i     n e v i t a b l y     s i g n i fi c a n t l y         r e d u c e d  i   n      s t o r e s
             w h i l s t                        r e furbishment     takes         place.        The         assumption                on     sales
             i  n        1 9 8 7 / 8    i n    t h e s e        s t o r e s    i  s t h e r e f o r e       a l s o     o f      r e l e v a n c e .
    Other       information                         which    we       believe         should              be    referred          to        for    a
p ro pe r a p p rec iat io n of a lo ng te r m fo recast i nc l udes;
             (a)  the            amount                  of      property           profits
             (b)  the            effect                on   profit         of        any    change              in    treatment                of
                          o v e r r i d i n g             d i s c o u n t s
             (c)  any              reduction                 in         the    level        of     pension                           contribution
             (d)       any                      reduction   in        the     normal            level       of     maintainance                   or
                          a d v e r t i s i n g e x p e n d i t u r e .

                                                                                                                    c o n t i n u e d/ .
County

Page - 2 -
J . G . RidingsEsq . ,
21April1987

2 . InHillards ' establishedstoreslikeforlike ( i . e . netof
openings / closuresandin fl ation ) volumehasdeclinedin
eachofthelastthreeyearsandwasonlystaticinthe
fi rsthalfofthecurrent fi nancialyear . Shareholders
oughttobegivenabreakdownofthesalesincrease
identifyinglike - for - likesalesassumptions .
3. In 1985/6Hillards' sales per square foot, the most telling
measureofretailingperformanceandef fi cienc y, fellfrom
thepreviousyearandwassome13percent , lessthanthat
forMorrisons - asuccessfulregionalcompetitor . This ,
together with the market share and volume decline, point
to a weak brand unable to compete effectively with new
competitoropenings .
4. Since the beginning of 1984competitors have opened new 23
storeswithina fi vemileradiusofHillards ' stores . I n
addition, some 43 planning consents have been approved
within five m i les of Hillards' exist i ng stores totalling
inexcessof1 .5 millionsquare fe e t . We can , withina
fewhoursnotice , supplydetailssupportingthesestatistics ,
ifrequired .

5 . Webelievethat , inthepast , Hillardshasincreased
pricestomaintainorimprovemarginsandincreaseshort -
termpro fi tabilityattheexpenseofsalesvolumeand
longer term profitability . These increases appear to
have been unsustainable and have had an adverse effect on
Hillards' market share and volume. The assumptions made
onpricinglevelsonapro fi tforecastwouldthereforebe
particularly relevant to shareholders in assessing the
forecast .

Weunders tand that in 1987/8Hillards is planning to open
threenewstoresatDoncaster , LeedsandCarltonandto
refurbishfourexistingstores . Storeopeningsand
relaunches are usually accompanied by aggressive pricing
policiesinordertosolicitnewcustomers . Furthermore
salesareinevitablysigni fi cantlyreducedinstores
whilstre furbishment takes place. The assumption on sales
in1987 / 8inthesestoresisthereforealsoofrelevance .
Other information which we believe should be referred to for a
p ro pe rapp rec iat io n of a lo ng te r m fo recast i nc l udes;
(a) the amount of property profits
(b) the effect on profit of any change in treatment of
overridingdiscounts
(c) any reduction in the level of pension contribution
(d) any reduction in the normal level of maintainance or
advertisingexpenditure .

continue d/ .

Read by machine highest quality of the three

    COUNTY


    Page  -2-
    J.G.  Ridings    Esq.,
    21 April     1987

    2.    In   Hillards'     established      stores    like  for  like   (i.e.  net  of
          openings/closures         and   inflation)    volume    has declined    in
          each   of   the   last   three   years  and   was   only  static   in  the
  first             half  of  the   current   financial      year.      Shareholders
      ought to be given a breakdown of the sales increase
          identifying           like-for-like sales   assumptions.
          In   1985/6    Hillards'      sales per     square  foot,   the most    telling
      measure of retailing performance and efficiency, fell from
          the    previous     year  and   was some   13   per   cent. less   than   that
          for      Morrisons  -  a  successful       regional   competitor.      This,
          together      with  the   market    share  and   volume   decline,     point
          to   a weak    brand  unable     to compete    effectively     with   new
          competitor     openings.

          Since     the  beginning     of  1984  competitors     have opened    23  new
          stores    within   a  five     mile radius    of  Hillards'    stores.    In
          addition,      some  43   planning    consents    have   been
          within                                                         approved
                    five   miles    of  Hillards'    existing    stores      totalling
          in   excess    of 1.5   million     square  feet.     We  can,  within   a
          few    hours   notice,    supply   details    supporting    these   statistics,
   if          required.

      We believe that, in the past, Hillards has increased
          prices    to   maintain    or   improve  margins    and   increase    short-
          term        profitability  at  the  expense   of   sales   volume   and
      longer term profitability. These increases appear to
          have   been   unsustainable       and  have   had  an  adverse     effect  on
      Hillards' market share and volume. The assumptions made
          on   pricing   levels    on  a  profit   forecast     would therefore     be
          particularly         relevant  to  shareholders     in  assessing   the
          forecast.

      We understand that in 1987/8 Hillards is planning to open
          three   new   stores   at   Doncaster,    Leeds    and  Carlton    and  to
      refurbish four existing stores. Store openings and
          relaunches      are usually     accompanied    by     aggressive   pricing
          policies    in   order  to    solicit  new  customers.      Furthermore
      Sales are inevitably significantly reduced in stores
          whilst       refurbishment    takes place.     The    assumption   on   sales
          in 1987/8     in  these   stores    is therefore      also  of  relevance.
    Other  information      which   we  believe   should     be referred   to   for  a
proper appreciation of a long term forecast includes:
      (a) the amount of property profits
          (b)    the  effect    on  profit    of any  change    in   treatment    of
                 overriding     discounts
          (c)    any  reduction     in  the   level  of  pension        contribution
      (d) any reduction in the normal level of maintainance or
        advertising expenditure.

                                                                      continued/...
COUNTY


Page-2-
J.G. Ridings Esq.,
21April1987

2. In Hillards' established stores like for like (i.e. net of
openings/closures and inflation) volume has declined in
each of the last three years and was only static in the
first half of the current financial year. Shareholders
ought to be given a breakdown of the sales increase
identifying like-for-like sales assumptions.
In 1985/6Hillards' sales per square foot, the most telling
measure of retailing performance and efficiency, fell from
the previous year and was some 13 per cent. less than that
for Morrisons - a successful regional competitor. This,
together with the market share and volume decline, point
to a weak brand unable to compete effectively with new
competitor openings.

Since the beginning of 1984competitors have opened 23 new
stores within a five mile radius of Hillards' stores. In
addition, some 43 planning consents have been
within approved
five miles of Hillards' existing stores totalling
in excess of 1.5million square feet. We can, within a
few hours notice, supply details supporting these statistics,
if required.

We believe that, in the past, Hillards has increased
prices to maintain or improve margins and increase short-
term profitability at the expense of sales volume and
longer term profitability. These increases appear to
have been unsustainable and have had an adverse effect on
Hillards' market share and volume. The assumptions made
on pricing levels on a profit forecast would therefore be
particularly relevant to shareholders in assessing the
forecast.

We understand that in 1987/8Hillards is planning to open
three new stores at Doncaster, Leeds and Carlton and to
refurbish four existing stores. Store openings and
relaunches are usually accompanied by aggressive pricing
policies in order to solicit new customers. Furthermore
Sales are inevitably significantly reduced in stores
whilst refurbishment takes place. The assumption on sales
in 1987/8 in these stores is therefore also of relevance.
Other information which we believe should be referred to for a
proper appreciation of a long term forecast includes:
(a) the amount of property profits
(b) the effect on profit of any change in treatment of
overriding discounts
(c) any reduction in the level of pension contribution
(d) any reduction in the normal level of maintainance or
advertising expenditure.

continued/...

Read by machine, contrast corrected

    COUNTY


    Page  -2-
    J.G.  Ridings    Esq.,
    21 April     1987

    2.    In   Hillards'     established      stores    like  for  like   (i.e.  net  of
          openings/closures         and   inflation)    volume    has declined    in
          each   of   the   last   three   years  and   was   only  static   in  the
  first             half  of  the   current   financial      year.      Shareholders
      ought to be given a breakdown of the sales increase
          identifying           like-for-like sales   assumptions.
          In   1985/6    Hillards'      sales per     square  foot,   the most    telling
      measure of retailing performance and efficiency, fell from
          the    previous     year  and   was some   13   per   cent. less   than   that
          for      Morrisons  -  a  successful       regional   competitor.      This,
          together      with  the   market    share  and   volume   decline,     point
          to   a weak    brand  unable     to compete    effectively     with   new
          competitor     openings.

          Since     the  beginning     of  1984  competitors     have opened    23  new
          stores    within   a  five     mile radius    of  Hillards'    stores.    In
          addition,      some  43   planning    consents    have   been
          within                                                         approved
                    five   miles    of  Hillards'    existing    stores      totalling
          in   excess    of 1.5   million     square  feet.     We  can,  within   a
          few    hours   notice,    supply   details    supporting    these   statistics,
   if          required.

      We believe that, in the past, Hillards has increased
          prices    to   maintain    or   improve  margins    and   increase    short-
          term        profitability  at  the  expense   of   sales   volume   and
      longer term profitability. These increases appear to
          have   been   unsustainable       and  have   had  an  adverse     effect  on
      Hillards' market share and volume. The assumptions made
          on   pricing   levels    on  a  profit   forecast     would therefore     be
          particularly         relevant  to  shareholders     in  assessing   the
          forecast.

      We understand that in 1987/8 Hillards is planning to open
          three   new   stores   at   Doncaster,    Leeds    and  Carlton    and  to
      refurbish four existing stores. Store openings and
          relaunches      are usually     accompanied    by     aggressive   pricing
          policies    in   order  to    solicit  new  customers.      Furthermore
      Sales are inevitably significantly reduced in stores
          whilst       refurbishment    takes place.     The    assumption   on   sales
          in 1987/8     in  these   stores    is therefore      also  of  relevance.
    Other  information      which   we  believe   should     be referred   to   for  a
proper appreciation of a long term forecast includes:
      (a) the amount of property profits
          (b)    the  effect    on  profit    of any  change    in   treatment    of
                 overriding     discounts
          (c)    any  reduction     in  the   level  of  pension        contribution
      (d) any reduction in the normal level of maintainance or
        advertising expenditure.

                                                                      continued/...
COUNTY


Page-2-
J.G. Ridings Esq.,
21April1987

2. In Hillards' established stores like for like (i.e. net of
openings/closures and inflation) volume has declined in
each of the last three years and was only static in the
first half of the current financial year. Shareholders
ought to be given a breakdown of the sales increase
identifying like-for-like sales assumptions.
In 1985/6Hillards' sales per square foot, the most telling
measure of retailing performance and efficiency, fell from
the previous year and was some 13 per cent. less than that
for Morrisons - a successful regional competitor. This,
together with the market share and volume decline, point
to a weak brand unable to compete effectively with new
competitor openings.

Since the beginning of 1984competitors have opened 23 new
stores within a five mile radius of Hillards' stores. In
addition, some 43 planning consents have been
within approved
five miles of Hillards' existing stores totalling
in excess of 1.5million square feet. We can, within a
few hours notice, supply details supporting these statistics,
if required.

We believe that, in the past, Hillards has increased
prices to maintain or improve margins and increase short-
term profitability at the expense of sales volume and
longer term profitability. These increases appear to
have been unsustainable and have had an adverse effect on
Hillards' market share and volume. The assumptions made
on pricing levels on a profit forecast would therefore be
particularly relevant to shareholders in assessing the
forecast.

We understand that in 1987/8Hillards is planning to open
three new stores at Doncaster, Leeds and Carlton and to
refurbish four existing stores. Store openings and
relaunches are usually accompanied by aggressive pricing
policies in order to solicit new customers. Furthermore
Sales are inevitably significantly reduced in stores
whilst refurbishment takes place. The assumption on sales
in 1987/8 in these stores is therefore also of relevance.
Other information which we believe should be referred to for a
proper appreciation of a long term forecast includes:
(a) the amount of property profits
(b) the effect on profit of any change in treatment of
overriding discounts
(c) any reduction in the level of pension contribution
(d) any reduction in the normal level of maintainance or
advertising expenditure.

continued/...