Letter to Gordon Young from County Limited page 2 of 4 previous next
Below is what the machine read from this scan, three times over. They are kept separate rather than merged: where they disagree, the disagreement is itself worth seeing, and a single tidy transcription would hide it.
The left column is raw output. The right is the same text after the repairs that make it searchable — joining letter-spaced words, mending split ones.
Text already in the scan
C o u n t y
Couiuy Limited
West Riding House, 67 Albion Street, Leeds LSI 5AA
Fax: 0532 421571
Tdephonc: 05.12 44,1451
NWW/jp
J . G . R i d i n g s E s q . ,
P e a t M a r w i c k M c L i n t o c k ,
M a n o r B u i l d i n g s ,
2 M a n o r R o a d ,
B r a d f o r d B D l 4 H J . 2 1 A p r i l 1 9 8 7
D e a r S i r ,
H i l l a r d s p i c
It has been reported in the press that the Board of Hillards is
considering making a profit forecast for part or all of its
next financial year to the end of April 1988, notwithstanding
t h e c o n s i d e r a b l e d i f fi c u l t i e s a n d u n c e r t a i n t i e s i n h e r e n t i n
making any forecast for a period that has not commenced .
As a major shareholder, on behalf of Tesco, we have great
rese rvations about the wisdom of pub lishing a fo recast fo r
Hillards for the full 1987/8 financial year. As a guide to the
p- r o s pit isc t s o f t h e c o m p a n y u c h a f o r e c a s t w o u l d h a v e l i t t l e v a l u e
heavily affected by pricing policies and, in our view,
maintaining higher prices for short term profits would only
further damage the underlying business of Hillards. Moreover,
we cannot see how any realistic or reasonable assumptions on
vo lume can be made in the light of Hi l la rds' t rack reco rd .
Nevertheless, if the Board of Hillards does produce a forecast,
we wou ld like to d raw you r attention to ce rtain facts which
would be relevant to forming reasonable assumptions underlying
a n y s u c h f o r e c a s t .
The most important assumptions underlying a food retailers'
forecast are those relating to sales. In this context you should
b e a w a r e t h a t :
1 . A G B / Te l e v i s i o n C o n s u m e r A u d i t s t a t i s t i c s s h o w t h a t H i l l a r d s '
market share in Yorkshire TV region fell 20 per cent, to
6 .4 per cent, between the final quarter of 1985 and the
final quarter of 1986 . This level is now less that it was
before Hillards' last three store openings in the region.
The statistics show such a strong trend that we cannot
believe that they are subject to any significant degree of
s t a t i s t i c a l e r r o r .
c o n t i n u e d/, .,
Rejystered Office: Drapers Gardens, 12 Thrp^Jmorton Avenue, London EC2P 2ES Reg No 18V9316
& The NaeWef«(t IgnveatmcnC Bank GroupCounty Couiuy Limited West Riding House, 67 Albion Street, Leeds LSI 5AA Fax: 0532 421571 Tdephonc: 05.12 44,1451 NWW/jp J . G . RidingsEsq . , PeatMarwickMcLintock , ManorBuildings , 2ManorRoad , BradfordBDl4HJ . 21April1987 DearSir , Hillardspic It has been reported in the press that the Board of Hillards is considering making a profit forecast for part or all of its next financial year to the end of April1988, notwithstanding theconsiderabledif fi cultiesanduncertaintiesinherentin making any forecast for a period that has not commenced . As a major shareholder, on behalf of Tesco, we have great reservations about the wisdom of publishing a fo recast fo r Hillards for the full1987/8 financial year. As a guide to the p-ros pit isc tsofthecompanyuchaforecastwouldhavelittlevalue heavily affected by pricing policies and, in our view, maintaining higher prices for short term profits would only further damage the underlying business of Hillards. Moreover, we cannot see how any realistic or reasonable assumptions on volume can be made in the light of Hi l la rds' t rack record. Nevertheless, if the Board of Hillards does produce a forecast, we would like to d raw you r attention to certain facts which would be relevant to forming reasonable assumptions underlying anysuchforecast . The most important assumptions underlying a food retailers' forecast are those relating to sales. In this context you should beawarethat : 1 . AGB / Te levisionConsumerAuditstatisticsshowthatHillards ' market share in Yorkshire TV region fell 20 per cent, to 6 .4 per cent, between the final quarter of 1985 and the final quarter of 1986.This level is now less that it was before Hillards' last three store openings in the region. The statistics show such a strong trend that we cannot believe that they are subject to any significant degree of statisticalerror . continued/,., Rejystered Office: Drapers Gardens, 12 Thrp^Jmorton Avenue, London EC2P 2ES Reg No 18V9316 & The NaeWef«(t IgnveatmcnC Bank Group
Read by machine highest quality of the three
COUNTY
County Limited
West Riding House, 67 Albion Street, Leeds LS1 SAA
Fax: 0532 421571
Telephone: 0532 443451
NWW/jp
J.G. Ridings Esq.,
Peat Marwick McLintock,
Manor Buildings,
2 Manor Road,
Bradford BD1 4HJ. 21 April 1987
Dear Sir,
Hillards plc
It has been reported in the press that the Board of Hillards is
considering making a profit forecast for part or all of its
next financial year to the end of April 1988, notwithstanding
the considerable difficulties and uncertainties inherent in
making any forecast for a period that has not commenced.
As a major shareholder, on behalf of Tesco, we have
reservations about the wisdom of publishing a great
forecast for
Hillards for the full 1987/8 financial year. As a guide to the
Prospects of the company such a forecast would have little value
- it is heavily affected by pricing policies and, in our view,
maintaining higher prices for short term profits would
further only
damage the underlying business of Hillards. Moreover,
we cannot see how any realistic or reasonable assumptions on
volume can be made in the light of Hillards' track record.
Nevertheless, if the Board of Hillards does produce a forecast,
we would like to draw your attention to certain facts which
would be relevant to forming reasonable assumptions
any such forecast. underlying
The most important assumptions underlying a food retailers'
forecast are those relating to sales. In this context you should
be aware that:
1. AGB/Television Consumer Audit statistics show that Hillards'
market share in Yorkshire TV region fell 20 per cent. to
6.4 per cent. between the final quarter of 1985 and the
final quarter of 1986. This level is now less that it was
before Hillards' last three store openings in the
The statistics show such a strong region.
believe that they subject to trend that we cannot
statistical error. are any significant degree of
continued/...
Registered Office: Drapers Gardens, 12 Throgmorton Avenue, London EC2P 2ES Reg No 1899316
& The NatWest Investment Bank GroupCOUNTY County Limited West Riding House, 67 Albion Street, Leeds LS1 SAA Fax: 0532 421571 Telephone:0532443451 NWW/jp J.G. Ridings Esq., Peat Marwick McLintock, Manor Buildings, 2 Manor Road, Bradford BD1 4HJ. 21April1987 Dear Sir, Hillards plc It has been reported in the press that the Board of Hillards is considering making a profit forecast for part or all of its next financial year to the end of April1988, notwithstanding the considerable difficulties and uncertainties inherent in making any forecast for a period that has not commenced. As a major shareholder, on behalf of Tesco, we have reservations about the wisdom of publishing a great forecast for Hillards for the full1987/8 financial year. As a guide to the Prospects of the company such a forecast would have little value - it is heavily affected by pricing policies and, in our view, maintaining higher prices for short term profits would further only damage the underlying business of Hillards. Moreover, we cannot see how any realistic or reasonable assumptions on volume can be made in the light of Hillards' track record. Nevertheless, if the Board of Hillards does produce a forecast, we would like to draw your attention to certain facts which would be relevant to forming reasonable assumptions any such forecast. underlying The most important assumptions underlying a food retailers' forecast are those relating to sales. In this context you should be aware that: 1. AGB/Television Consumer Audit statistics show that Hillards' market share in Yorkshire TV region fell 20 per cent. to 6.4percent. between the final quarter of 1985 and the final quarter of 1986.This level is now less that it was before Hillards' last three store openings in the The statistics show such a strong region. believe that they subject to trend that we cannot statistical error. are any significant degree of continued/... Registered Office: Drapers Gardens, 12 Throgmorton Avenue, London EC2P 2ES Reg No 1899316 & The NatWest Investment Bank Group
Read by machine, contrast corrected
COUNTY
County Limited
West Riding House, 67 Albion Street, Leeds LS1 SAA
Fax: 0532 421571
Telephone: 0532 443451
NWW/jp
J.G. Ridings Esq.,
Peat Marwick McLintock,
Manor Buildings,
2 Manor Road,
Bradford BD1 4HJ. 21 April 1987
Dear Sir,
Hillards plc
It has been reported in the press that the Board of Hillards is
considering making a profit forecast for part or all of its
next financial year to the end of April 1988, notwithstanding
the considerable difficulties and uncertainties inherent in
making any forecast for a period that has not commenced.
As a major shareholder, on behalf of Tesco, we have
reservations about the wisdom of publishing a great
forecast for
Hillards for the full 1987/8 financial year. As a guide to the
Prospects of the company such a forecast would have little value
- it is heavily affected by pricing policies and, in our view,
maintaining higher prices for short term profits would
further only
damage the underlying business of Hillards. Moreover,
we cannot see how any realistic or reasonable assumptions on
volume can be made in the light of Hillards' track record.
Nevertheless, if the Board of Hillards does produce a forecast,
we would like to draw your attention to certain facts which
would be relevant to forming reasonable assumptions
any such forecast. underlying
The most important assumptions underlying a food retailers'
forecast are those relating to sales. In this context you should
be aware that:
1. AGB/Television Consumer Audit statistics show that Hillards'
market share in Yorkshire TV region fell 20 per cent. to
6.4 per cent. between the final quarter of 1985 and the
final quarter of 1986. This level is now less that it was
before Hillards' last three store openings in the
The statistics show such a strong region.
believe that they subject to trend that we cannot
statistical error. are any significant degree of
continued/...
Registered Office: Drapers Gardens, 12 Throgmorton Avenue, London EC2P 2ES Reg No 1899316
& The NatWest Investment Bank GroupCOUNTY County Limited West Riding House, 67 Albion Street, Leeds LS1 SAA Fax: 0532 421571 Telephone:0532443451 NWW/jp J.G. Ridings Esq., Peat Marwick McLintock, Manor Buildings, 2 Manor Road, Bradford BD1 4HJ. 21April1987 Dear Sir, Hillards plc It has been reported in the press that the Board of Hillards is considering making a profit forecast for part or all of its next financial year to the end of April1988, notwithstanding the considerable difficulties and uncertainties inherent in making any forecast for a period that has not commenced. As a major shareholder, on behalf of Tesco, we have reservations about the wisdom of publishing a great forecast for Hillards for the full1987/8 financial year. As a guide to the Prospects of the company such a forecast would have little value - it is heavily affected by pricing policies and, in our view, maintaining higher prices for short term profits would further only damage the underlying business of Hillards. Moreover, we cannot see how any realistic or reasonable assumptions on volume can be made in the light of Hillards' track record. Nevertheless, if the Board of Hillards does produce a forecast, we would like to draw your attention to certain facts which would be relevant to forming reasonable assumptions any such forecast. underlying The most important assumptions underlying a food retailers' forecast are those relating to sales. In this context you should be aware that: 1. AGB/Television Consumer Audit statistics show that Hillards' market share in Yorkshire TV region fell 20 per cent. to 6.4percent. between the final quarter of 1985 and the final quarter of 1986.This level is now less that it was before Hillards' last three store openings in the The statistics show such a strong region. believe that they subject to trend that we cannot statistical error. are any significant degree of continued/... Registered Office: Drapers Gardens, 12 Throgmorton Avenue, London EC2P 2ES Reg No 1899316 & The NatWest Investment Bank Group