Hillards takeover

Algorithmic Indexing

387 documents 1,432 pages

Letter to Mergers Secretariat G James from Travers Smith Braithwaite   page 3 of 10   previous   next

Scan of page 3 of Letter to Mergers Secretariat G James from Travers Smith Braithwaite

Below is what the machine read from this scan, three times over. They are kept separate rather than merged: where they disagree, the disagreement is itself worth seeing, and a single tidy transcription would hide it.

The left column is raw output. The right is the same text after the repairs that make it searchable — joining letter-spaced words, mending split ones.

Text already in the scan

    s    0 3



    ; / t h i s s e c t o r    h o l d i n g b e t w e e n     t h e m      a p p r o x i m a t e l y    5 0 %      o f t h e r e t a i l
        g roce ry      ma r ket .       T he     next         la rgest      co mpa n ies                (exc l ud i ng   t he    Co-op
        s t o r e s )  a r e  s i g n i fi c a n t l y  s m a l l e r   ( 3 %     a n d    l e s s     i n    n a t i o n a l  m a r k e t
        s h a r e   t e r m s )     a n d    t h e r e a r e o n l y    a l   i  m i t e d n u m b e r     o f      s u c h
        companies              of   which    Hillards        is        one .     As these          smaller                     companies
        disappea r            then  not     on ly     wi l l           p resent   competition            be     reduced              but
        potential      competition     also                  will  be       lessened.     The              chance           that       any
        o n e  o f     t h e s e    c o m p a n i e s  m i g h t g r o w     t o    a     s i z e  w h e r e    i t c o u l d
        e f f e c t i v e l y  c h a l l e n g e t h e  m a j o r       c o m p a n i e s       a l s o  c e a s e s    t o  e x i s t .
        Thus,         the  proposed merger                   should         be    seen     as      part      of     a   longer        term
        m o v e m e n t  t o w a r d s     t h e     e l i m i n a t i o n  o f   s m a l l e r    g r o c e r y    c h a i n s  w i t h
        the     consequent       strengthening                    of    the       position           of  the       5    major
        companies              in that          sector.      Such       a                 strengthening  would          have
    ^ serious                         consequences both for        the      remaining                                independent companies
        a n d     f o r   t h e i r s u p p l i e r s .

        At     a local         level     also,       as  a    result           of the     proposed           merger                there
        will    be      a     number     of     towns            where      the   combined             group         will    exercise
        considerable            local            market         power.      The     management               of      Hillards
        consider            it almost     certain             that    as     a    result     of        overlap          between
        Individual             stores     a number of                 Hillards        or   Tesco           stores         will       close
        and          that     Tesco     will also              close       certain        further        Hillards          stores
        because        these       do     not    match           the    normal        requirements           of         Tesco        for
        its     stores .       Hillards     itself              does    not       intend     to        dose             those       stores
        falling        in      the  latter     category.     In             addition      there              are     a            number
        of     stores which in the opinion of Hillards management will
    ^   probably       be   closed     if     the     merger                takes         place.           Details         of
        closures          considered                    respectively       definite and            probable               are set       out
        in         Annex    a.    The                 consequences of       certain of     these                     closures  on
        the        local    market     level     are set           out       in   Annex     B .

        The     third         area  of     concern   is                that  if   the  merger            takes          place  it       is
        likely     to     lead     to     a  loss     of     547            jobs  amongst    the                     headquarters
        staff      of     Hillards .                 Hillards believes              that it  is            highly
        likely         that    those                functions carried            on   by its           head         office   will       in



A n n e x C t o t h i s l e t t e r . F u r t h e r m o r e , H i l l a r d s e s t i m a t e t h a t



                                                                      2
s03



; / thissectorholdingbetweenthemapproximately50 % oftheretail
grocery market . T he next largest co mpa n ies (excl ud i ng t he Co-op
stores ) aresigni fi cantlysmaller ( 3 % andlessinnationalmarket
shareterms ) andthereareonlyalimitednumberofsuch
companies of which Hillards is one . As these smaller companies
disappear then not on ly wi llp resent competition be reduced but
potential competition also will be lessened. The chance that any
oneofthesecompaniesmightgrowtoasizewhereitcould
effectivelychallengethemajorcompaniesalsoceasestoexist .
Thus, the proposed merger should be seen as part of a longer term
movementtowardstheeliminationofsmallergrocerychainswith
the consequent strengthening of the position of the 5 major
companies in that sector. Such a strengthening would have
^ serious consequences both for the remaining independent companies
andfortheirsuppliers .

At a local level also, as a result of the proposed merger there
will be a number of towns where the combined group will exercise
considerable local market power. The management of Hillards
consider it almost certain that as a result of overlap between
Individual stores a number of Hillards or Tesco stores will close
and that Tesco will also close certain further Hillards stores
because these do not match the normal requirements of Tesco for
its stores . Hillards itself does not intend to dose those stores
falling in the latter category. In addition there are a number
of stores which in the opinion of Hillards management will
^ probably be closed if the merger takes place. Details of
closures considered respectively definite and probable are set out
in Annex a. The consequences of certain of these closures on
the local market level are set out in Annex B .

The third area of concern is that if the merger takes place it is
likely to lead to a loss of 547jobs amongst the headquarters
staff of Hillards . Hillards believes that it is highly
likely that those functions carried on by its head office will in



AnnexCtothisletter . Furthermore , Hillardsestimatethat



2

Read by machine

    bi)




    this  sector    holding  between   them     approximately  50%   of   the retail
    grocery  market.     The  next      largest  companies   (excluding   the  Co-op
    stores)  are    significantly       smaller  3% and   less in   national    market
    share terms)     and there   are only    a   limited  number  of   such
    companies    of  which  Hillards   is    one.   As  these  smaller    companies
    disappear    then not   only will    present    competition   be   reduced   but
    potential    competition   also  will    be    lessened.   The  chance    that any
    one  of  these   companies   might   grow   to  a  size  where  it   could
    effectively     challenge  the   major   companies    also  ceases    to  axist.
    Thus,   the  proposed   merger   should    be  seen  as  part of   a  longer  term
    movement    towards  the     elimination   of  smaller   grocery   chains  with
the consequent strengthening of the position of the 5 major
companies in that sector. Such a strengthening would have
    serious   consequences    both   for  the   remaining    independant     companies
    and  for  their   suppliers.


       At a      local   level      also,     as  a result     of  the  proposed    merger   there
        will be a number of towns where the combined group will exercise
       considerable            local    market    power.     The   management    of Hillards
 |     consider       it      almost    certain     that  as   a  result  of  overlap    between
 |     individual        stores       a  number     of  Hillards   or   Tesco    stores         close
 |                                                                                       will
 |
       and  that      Tesco        will  also     close  certain   further    Hillards     stores
       because      these   do       not   match    the  normal    requirements     of  Tesco  for
       its  stores.             Hillards   itself   does    not   intend  to  close    those   stores
       falling      in   the  latter        category.       In   addition   there   are  a number
      of       stores  which      in    the     Opinion  of  Hillards    management     will
      probably        be      closed    if  the   merger    takes  place.     Details    of
        closures considered respectively definite and probable are set out
      in   Annex      A.  The       consequences       of   certain   of  these   closures    on
      the  local       market       level     are   set  out   in  Annex  B.

      The       third  area      of  concern     is that     if   the merger     takes  place  it  is
      likely     to    lead      to  a   loss of    547   jobs    amongst    the headquarters
      staff      of   Hillards.         Hillards    believes       that  it  is  highly
      likely     that     those      functions      carried     on by   its  head  office    will  in
                 We              ad
                       meet          oe  hice he               bee    POP

      ee  eee               Sey                         i                     are  SFY  Wee  a ai
      Annex         to   this letter.         Furthermore,         Hillards  estimate     that
bi)




this sector holding between them approximately50% of the retail
grocery market. The next largest companies (excluding the Co-op
stores) are significantly smaller 3% and less in national market
share terms) and there are only a limited number of such
companies of which Hillards is one. As these smaller companies
disappear then not only will present competition be reduced but
potential competition also will be lessened. The chance that any
one of these companies might grow to a size where it could
effectively challenge the major companies also ceases to axist.
Thus, the proposed merger should be seen as part of a longer term
movement towards the elimination of smaller grocery chains with
the consequent strengthening of the position of the 5 major
companies in that sector. Such a strengthening would have
serious consequences both for the remaining independant companies
and for their suppliers.


At a local level also, as a result of the proposed merger there
will be a number of towns where the combined group will exercise
considerable local market power. The management of Hillards
| consider it almost certain that as a result of overlap between
| individual stores a number of Hillards or Tesco stores close
| will
|
and that Tesco will also close certain further Hillards stores
because these do not match the normal requirements of Tesco for
its stores. Hillards itself does not intend to close those stores
falling in the latter category. In addition there are a number
of stores which in the Opinion of Hillards management will
probably be closed if the merger takes place. Details of
closures considered respectively definite and probable are set out
in Annex A. The consequences of certain of these closures on
the local market level are set out in Annex B.

The third area of concern is that if the merger takes place it is
likely to lead to a loss of 547jobs amongst the headquarters
staff of Hillards. Hillards believes that it is highly
likely that those functions carried on by its head office will in
We ad
meet oe hice he bee POP

ee eee Sey i are SFY Wee a ai
Annex to this letter. Furthermore, Hillards estimate that

Read by machine, contrast corrected highest quality of the three

    bi)




    this  sector    holding  between   them     approximately  50%   of   the retail
    grocery  market.     The  next      largest  companies   (excluding   the  Co-op
    stores)  are    significantly       smaller  3% and   less in   national    market
    share terms)     and there   are only    a   limited  number  of   such
    companies    of  which  Hillards   is    one.   As  these  smaller    companies
    disappear    then not   only will    present    competition   be   reduced   but
    potential    competition   also  will    be    lessened.   The  chance    that any
    one  of  these   companies   might   grow   to  a  size  where  it   could
    effectively     challenge  the   major   companies    also  ceases    to  axist.
    Thus,   the  proposed   merger   should    be  seen  as  part of   a  longer  term
    movement    towards  the     elimination   of  smaller   grocery   chains  with
the consequent strengthening of the position of the 5 major
companies in that sector. Such a strengthening would have
    serious   consequences    both   for  the   remaining    independant     companies
    and  for  their   suppliers.


       At  a     local   level   also,     as  a result       of  the proposed     merger   there
       will      be a  number     of   towns   where   the     combined   group    will   exercise
       considerable         local    market    power.      The    management   of  Hillards
 |     consider       it   almost    certain     that  as     a  result  of  overlap    between
 |     individual        stores    a   number    of  Hillards     or  Tesco  stores           close
 |                                                                                      will
 |
       and   that     Tesco     will   also    close  certain     further    Hillards     stores
       because      these   do     not  match    the  normal      requirements     of  Tesco for
       its   stores.          Hillards  itself   does      not   intend  to  close    those  stores
       falling      in   the latter      category.         In   addition  there    are  a number
      of      stores  which    in    the     Opinion  of   Hillards     management     will
      probably       be    closed    if  the  merger       takes  place.     Details    of
        closures considered respectively definite and probable are set out
      in   Annex     A.   The    consequences       of     certain   of  these     closures  on
      the  local      market     level   are     set  out     in  Annex  B.

      The      third  area   of   concern     is that      if    the merger  takes     place it  is
      likely     to   lead   to   a    loss of   547   jobs      amongst the headquarters
        staff of Hillards. Hillards believes that it is highly
      likely     that    those    functions      carried       on by  its  head    office  will  in
                 We   mae    tad  oe        he                bee 2

      ee  eee                                        ii                     are        Whe   ro
        Annex © to this letter. Furthermore, Hillards estimate that
bi)




this sector holding between them approximately50% of the retail
grocery market. The next largest companies (excluding the Co-op
stores) are significantly smaller 3% and less in national market
share terms) and there are only a limited number of such
companies of which Hillards is one. As these smaller companies
disappear then not only will present competition be reduced but
potential competition also will be lessened. The chance that any
one of these companies might grow to a size where it could
effectively challenge the major companies also ceases to axist.
Thus, the proposed merger should be seen as part of a longer term
movement towards the elimination of smaller grocery chains with
the consequent strengthening of the position of the 5 major
companies in that sector. Such a strengthening would have
serious consequences both for the remaining independant companies
and for their suppliers.


At a local level also, as a result of the proposed merger there
will be a number of towns where the combined group will exercise
considerable local market power. The management of Hillards
| consider it almost certain that as a result of overlap between
| individual stores a number of Hillards or Tesco stores close
| will
|
and that Tesco will also close certain further Hillards stores
because these do not match the normal requirements of Tesco for
its stores. Hillards itself does not intend to close those stores
falling in the latter category. In addition there are a number
of stores which in the Opinion of Hillards management will
probably be closed if the merger takes place. Details of
closures considered respectively definite and probable are set out
in Annex A. The consequences of certain of these closures on
the local market level are set out in Annex B.

The third area of concern is that if the merger takes place it is
likely to lead to a loss of 547jobs amongst the headquarters
staff of Hillards. Hillards believes that it is highly
likely that those functions carried on by its head office will in
We mae tad oe he bee 2

ee eee ii are Whe ro
Annex © to this letter. Furthermore, Hillards estimate that