Hillards takeover

Algorithmic Indexing

387 documents 1,432 pages

Tesco Offer for Hillards plc   page 6 of 15   previous   next

Scan of page 6 of Tesco Offer for Hillards plc

Below is what the machine read from this scan, three times over. They are kept separate rather than merged: where they disagree, the disagreement is itself worth seeing, and a single tidy transcription would hide it.

The left column is raw output. The right is the same text after the repairs that make it searchable — joining letter-spaced words, mending split ones.

Text already in the scan

T E S C O  P L C





3CI0p   Va l u e o f    o u r o f f e r                            309p           O     u         r   o     f     f     e     r
                             +           39';!
               +  60°o
200p                                     222p                                     You are being offered     the     opportunity to share in the   future
                  193p                                                            growth and        prosperity of   one of the most successful      food
                                                                                  retailers in  the United Kingdom.
lOOp                                                                              By accepting our share offer you will     not         be relinquishing your
                                                                                  investment   in   Hillards.  You  will be   exchanging it,   on very
                                                                                  favourable   terms, for     one   in  Tesco  and  Hillards   together.

           T w o         w e e k s     D a y           V a l u e       o f
           be f  o r e   o f  fe r b e f o r e   o ff e r  o u r   o f fe r       Our  offer   is "exceptionally     generous"
                                                                                  You are being offered the following for each of your            Hillards
                                                                                  Ordinary   shares:
"The Offer would appear to be                                                                      308.75p in Tesco shares
exceptionally generous .... "                                                                      o r
Scrimgeour Vickers,      Stockbrokers.       10th         March,        1987.                      290.55p     in     cash
                                                                                  The share offer represents a substantial increase of 39 per cent,
                                                                                  over the price the    day before the bid of 222p and of 60 per cent,
                                                                                  over the price of 193p just two weeks earlier.
                                                                                  Quite clearly the Tesco offer is, and is seen by independent
"It     would     take       some                              considerable       commentators to be, a very generous and full price for your
time       before        holders         of     Hillards                          shares. In the absence of our offer the share price might be
stock would see its share price at                                                significantly   lower.
anything near the Tesco bid price
on      trading       grounds."
                                                                                  Hillards' poor    share     price record
BZW, Stockbrokers,       10th     March,     1987.                                Your  Chairman    has   made much     of    Hillards' share  price
                                                                                  performance since 1972; the more relevant performance,
                                                                                  however, is over the five years before our offer was made. Since
                                                                                  1982 Hillards' share price has been left far behind by the Tesco
                                                                                  share price -£100 invested in 1982 in Tesco would, before our
"The offer clearly values Hillards at                                             offer, have been worth £799.59 but invested in Hillards would
a premium                to    the     sector."                                   have  been    worth only     £276.25.
Wood Mackenzie, Stockbrokers, 8th April, 1987                                     This is no quirk of the stock market. It reflects Tesco's excellent
                                                                                  trading performance in recent years and, more importantly, the
                                                                                  prospects of each company. The message is quite clear: you
                                                                                  would be     better off     with  Tesco.
Hillards'  share         price     relative     to               Tesco-5     years

                                                                                  High earnings multiple
                                                                                  Tesco's offer values Hillards at 26.3 times its earnings, on the basis
                                                                                  of Hillards' reported earnings per share of 11.73p. This
                                                                                  is more than any major food retailing company, including
                                                                                  ). Sainsbury and Tesco, the market leaders. It is also high when
                                                                                  compared with other recent mergers in the food retailing sector.
                                                                                  For example, it is a higher multiple than Argyll paid for Safeway, a
2 0     1 9 8 2  1 9 8 3     1 9 8 4     1 9 8 5     1 9 8 6     1 9 8 7          quality food retailer with a much stronger retail brand than Hillards.
                                                                                  This  is  an    exceptionally    high  value for Hillards
Source  Dalastream     (See    Appendix)
TESCOPLC





3CI0p Va lueofouroffer 309p Ouroffer
+ 39';!
+ 60°o
200p 222p You are being offered the opportunity to share in the future
193p growth and prosperity of one of the most successful food
retailers in the United Kingdom.
lOOp By accepting our share offer you will not be relinquishing your
investment in Hillards. You will be exchanging it, on very
favourable terms, for one in Tesco and Hillards together.

TwoweeksDayValueof
be foreof fe rbeforeo ff erourof fe r Our offer is "exceptionally generous"
You are being offered the following for each of your Hillards
Ordinary shares:
"The Offer would appear to be 308.75p in Tesco shares
exceptionally generous...." o r
Scrimgeour Vickers, Stockbrokers. 10th March,1987. 290.55p in cash
The share offer represents a substantial increase of 39 per cent,
over the price the day before the bid of 222p and of 60 per cent,
over the price of 193p just two weeks earlier.
Quite clearly the Tesco offer is, and is seen by independent
"It would take some considerable commentators to be, a very generous and full price for your
time before holders of Hillards shares. In the absence of our offer the share price might be
stock would see its share price at significantly lower.
anything near the Tesco bid price
on trading grounds."
Hillards' poor share price record
BZW, Stockbrokers, 10th March,1987. Your Chairman has made much of Hillards' share price
performance since1972; the more relevant performance,
however, is over the five years before our offer was made. Since
1982Hillards' share price has been left far behind by the Tesco
share price-£100 invested in 1982 in Tesco would, before our
"The offer clearly values Hillards at offer, have been worth£799.59 but invested in Hillards would
a premium to the sector." have been worth only£276.25.
Wood Mackenzie, Stockbrokers, 8th April,1987 This is no quirk of the stock market. It reflects Tesco's excellent
trading performance in recent years and, more importantly, the
prospects of each company. The message is quite clear: you
would be better off with Tesco.
Hillards' share price relative to Tesco-5 years

High earnings multiple
Tesco's offer values Hillards at 26.3times its earnings, on the basis
of Hillards' reported earnings per share of 11.73p. This
is more than any major food retailing company, including
). Sainsbury and Tesco, the market leaders. It is also high when
compared with other recent mergers in the food retailing sector.
For example, it is a higher multiple than Argyll paid for Safeway, a
20198219831984198519861987quality food retailer with a much stronger retail brand than Hillards.
This is an exceptionally high value for Hillards
Source Dalastream (See Appendix)

Read by machine highest quality of the three

    TESCO PLC




          300p     Value of     our offer                             Our offer

                                             +39%
          200p           +60%                                         You are   being offered the     opportunity    to share    in the future
                                                                      growth and prosperity of    one    of the   most successful food
                                                                      retailers in the United Kingdom.
          100p                                                        By accepting    our share offer you    will not be    relinquishing your
                                                                      investment in Hillards. You will be exchanging it,         on very
                                                                      favourable terms, for   one in  Tesco and Hillards together.

             0
                         Two weeks       Day            Value of
                         before offer    before offer   our offer     Our offer is ‘‘exceptionally generous”
                                                                      You are   being offered the following for      each of     your Hillards
                                                                      Ordinary shares:
          “The Offer would                   appear    to be                                308.75p in Tesco shares
          exceptionally      generous...                                                              or
    Scrimgeour Vickers, Stockbrokers,        10th March,     1987.                              290.55p in cash
        The share offer represents a substantial increase of 39 per cent.
        over the price the day before the bid of 222p and of 60 per cent.
        over the price of 193p just two weeks earlier.
        Quite clearly the Tesco offer is, and is seen by independent
          “It would take  some               considerable             commentators to     be, a very  generous    and full    price for   your
          time before holders of Hillards                             shares. In   the absence of our    offer the   share  price     might be
          stock would        see         its  share    price at       significantly lower.
          anything       near     the Tesco bid           price
          on     trading     grounds.”
                                                                      Hillards’ poor  share price record
    BZW, Stockbrokers,       10th March,     1987.                    Your Chairman has made     much of Hillards’     share price
                                                                      performance since    1972; the    more  relevant     performance,
        however, is over the five years before our offer was made. Since
                                                                      1982 Hillards’  share   price has been left  far      behind by the Tesco
                                                                                    — £100 invested  in  1982 in Tesco     would, before    our
                                                                      share price
          “The     offer          clearly    values Hillards    at    offer, have been worth £799.59 but        invested    in   Hillards would
          a premium to                the                             have been worth     only £276.25.
        This is no quirk of the stock market. It reflects Tesco’s excellent
    Wood Mackenzie,          Stockbrokers, 8th     April, 1987.       trading performance     in recent  years  and,   more    importantly, the
                                                                      prospects    of each company.     The  message   is   quite clear:  you
                                                                      would be better     off with Tesco.
Hillards’     share          price     relative  to Tesco—5     years

          100 al                                                      High earnings   multiple
           804     \\                                                 Tesco’s offer   values Hillards at 26.3  times   its earnings,    on the basis
              ‘                                                       of Hillards’ reported earnings     per share of  11.73p.     This
             a           hw     ath                                   is more   than  any  major food retailing   company,       including
                                             ar                       J. Sainsbury and Tesco, the market leaders.          It is also high when
              4                                                       compared with other recent
            40                                                                                      mergers       in the   food retailing  sector.
                                                                      For    example, it is a higher multiple than   Argyll   paid  for Safeway,  a
                         1983    |  1984     1985 1986  1987|         quality   food retailer with  a much   stronger  retail    brand than Hillards.
    cs                                                                This is   an exceptionally high value for Hillards.
       Source:     Datastream (See     Appendix)
TESCO PLC




300p Value of our offer Our offer

+39%
200p +60% You are being offered the opportunity to share in the future
growth and prosperity of one of the most successful food
retailers in the United Kingdom.
100p By accepting our share offer you will not be relinquishing your
investment in Hillards. You will be exchanging it, on very
favourable terms, for one in Tesco and Hillards together.

0
Two weeks Day Value of
before offer before offer our offer Our offer is ''exceptionally generous"
You are being offered the following for each of your Hillards
Ordinary shares:
"The Offer would appear to be 308.75p in Tesco shares
exceptionally generous... or
Scrimgeour Vickers, Stockbrokers, 10th March,1987. 290.55p in cash
The share offer represents a substantial increase of 39 per cent.
over the price the day before the bid of 222p and of 60 per cent.
over the price of 193p just two weeks earlier.
Quite clearly the Tesco offer is, and is seen by independent
"It would take some considerable commentators to be, a very generous and full price for your
time before holders of Hillards shares. In the absence of our offer the share price might be
stock would see its share price at significantly lower.
anything near the Tesco bid price
on trading grounds."
Hillards' poor share price record
BZW, Stockbrokers, 10th March,1987. Your Chairman has made much of Hillards' share price
performance since1972; the more relevant performance,
however, is over the five years before our offer was made. Since
1982Hillards' share price has been left far behind by the Tesco
-£100invested in 1982 in Tesco would, before our
share price
"The offer clearly values Hillards at offer, have been worth£799.59 but invested in Hillards would
a premium to the have been worth only£276.25.
This is no quirk of the stock market. It reflects Tesco's excellent
Wood Mackenzie, Stockbrokers, 8th April,1987. trading performance in recent years and, more importantly, the
prospects of each company. The message is quite clear: you
would be better off with Tesco.
Hillards' share price relative to Tesco-5 years

100 al High earnings multiple
804\\Tesco's offer values Hillards at 26.3times its earnings, on the basis
' of Hillards' reported earnings per share of 11.73p. This
a hw ath is more than any major food retailing company, including
ar J. Sainsbury and Tesco, the market leaders. It is also high when
4 compared with other recent
40 mergers in the food retailing sector.
For example, it is a higher multiple than Argyll paid for Safeway, a
1983 | 1984 1985 19861987|quality food retailer with a much stronger retail brand than Hillards.
cs This is an exceptionally high value for Hillards.
Source: Datastream (See Appendix)

Read by machine, contrast corrected

TESCO PLC




          300p    Value of     our offer                             Our offer

                                            +39%
       200p             +60%                                         You  are  being offered the opportunity        to share in the future
                                                                     growth and prosperity of one     of the     most successful food
                                                                     retailers in the United Kingdom.
       100p                                                          By accepting   our share offer you     will not be    relinquishing your
                                                                     investment in Hillards. You will be exchanging it,     on  very
                                                                     favourable terms, for   one in  Tesco and Hillards together.

             0
                        Two weeks       Day            Value of
                        before offer    before offer   our offer     Our offer is  ‘‘exceptionally generous”
                                                                     You  are  being offered the following for each       of your  Hillards
                                                                     Ordinary shares:
       “The Offer would                     appear    to be                                308.75p in Tesco shares
       exceptionally        generous...     .”                                                       or
Scrimgeour Vickers, Stockbrokers,           10th March,     1987.                              290.55p in cash
    The share offer represents a substantial increase of 39 per cent.
                                                                     over  the price the day before the     bid of  222p and    of 60   per cent.
                                                                     over  the price of 193p just two   weeks earlier.
                                                                     Quite clearly  the Tesco offer is, and is   seen     by independent
       “It    would take some               considerable             commentators to    be,  a very  generous    and full    price for your
       time   before holders of Hillards                             shares. In   the absence of our    offer the share    price might   be
       stock would          see         its  share price   at        significantly lower.
       anything         near     the Tesco bid           price
       on     trading       grounds.”
                                                                     Hillards’ poor share price record
BZW, Stockbrokers,          10th March,     1987.                    Your Chairman has made     much of Hillards’     share price
                                                                     performance since    1972; the    more  relevant     performance,
    however, is over the five years before our offer was made. Since
                                                                     1982 Hillards’ share    price has been left  far      behind by the Tesco
                                                                     share price invested in 1982 in             Tesco    would, before    our
       “The       offer     clearly     values Hillards     at       offer,  have been worth £799.59 but      invested     in Hillards would
       a premium to         the sector.’                             have been worth     only £276.25.
                                                                     This is no   quirk of the stock market.  It reflects    Tesco’s excellent
Wood Mackenzie,             Stockbrokers, 8th     April, 1987.       trading performance in recent     years  and,    more    importantly, the
                                                                     prospects    of each company.   The    message   is   quite clear: you
                                                                     would be better    off with Tesco.
Hillards’         share     price     relative  to Tesco—5     years

       100                                                           High earnings  multiple
           804    \\                                                 Tesco’s offer  values Hillards  at 26.3 times    its earnings, on  the basis
                   ‘                                                 of Hillards’ reported earnings     per share of  11.73p.    This
             a          hw     wath                                  is more   than any   major food retailing   company,     including
                                            ar                       J. Sainsbury and Tesco, the market leaders.          It is also high when
           4                                                         compared with other recent    mergers
            40                                                                                                   in the   food retailing  sector.
                                                                     For  example, it   is a higher multiple than   Argyll   paid for Safeway,   a
                  1982. 1983    |  1984     1985 1986  1987|         quality   food retailer with  a much   stronger  retail    brand than Hillards.
ie.                                                                  This is   an exceptionally high value for Hillards.
       Source:    Datastream (See     Appendix)
TESCO PLC




300p Value of our offer Our offer

+39%
200p +60% You are being offered the opportunity to share in the future
growth and prosperity of one of the most successful food
retailers in the United Kingdom.
100p By accepting our share offer you will not be relinquishing your
investment in Hillards. You will be exchanging it, on very
favourable terms, for one in Tesco and Hillards together.

0
Two weeks Day Value of
before offer before offer our offer Our offer is ''exceptionally generous"
You are being offered the following for each of your Hillards
Ordinary shares:
"The Offer would appear to be 308.75p in Tesco shares
exceptionally generous... ." or
Scrimgeour Vickers, Stockbrokers, 10th March,1987. 290.55p in cash
The share offer represents a substantial increase of 39 per cent.
over the price the day before the bid of 222p and of 60 per cent.
over the price of 193p just two weeks earlier.
Quite clearly the Tesco offer is, and is seen by independent
"It would take some considerable commentators to be, a very generous and full price for your
time before holders of Hillards shares. In the absence of our offer the share price might be
stock would see its share price at significantly lower.
anything near the Tesco bid price
on trading grounds."
Hillards' poor share price record
BZW, Stockbrokers, 10th March,1987. Your Chairman has made much of Hillards' share price
performance since1972; the more relevant performance,
however, is over the five years before our offer was made. Since
1982Hillards' share price has been left far behind by the Tesco
share price invested in 1982 in Tesco would, before our
"The offer clearly values Hillards at offer, have been worth£799.59 but invested in Hillards would
a premium to the sector.' have been worth only£276.25.
This is no quirk of the stock market. It reflects Tesco's excellent
Wood Mackenzie, Stockbrokers, 8th April,1987. trading performance in recent years and, more importantly, the
prospects of each company. The message is quite clear: you
would be better off with Tesco.
Hillards' share price relative to Tesco-5 years

100High earnings multiple
804\\Tesco's offer values Hillards at 26.3times its earnings, on the basis
' of Hillards' reported earnings per share of 11.73p. This
a hw wath is more than any major food retailing company, including
ar J. Sainsbury and Tesco, the market leaders. It is also high when
4 compared with other recent mergers
40 in the food retailing sector.
For example, it is a higher multiple than Argyll paid for Safeway, a
1982. 1983 | 1984 1985 19861987|quality food retailer with a much stronger retail brand than Hillards.
ie. This is an exceptionally high value for Hillards.
Source: Datastream (See Appendix)