Hillards takeover

Algorithmic Indexing

387 documents 1,432 pages

Letter and infomration to Shareholders 08/05/1987   page 2 of 3   previous   next

Scan of page 2 of Letter and infomration to Shareholders 08/05/1987

Below is what the machine read from this scan, three times over. They are kept separate rather than merged: where they disagree, the disagreement is itself worth seeing, and a single tidy transcription would hide it.

The left column is raw output. The right is the same text after the repairs that make it searchable — joining letter-spaced words, mending split ones.

Text already in the scan

        K E E P                 Y O U R     I N V E S T M E N T     I N                                      S U C C E S S                                                                                      T H E                  F A C T      A N D         T H E                        F I C T I O N

Tesco has attempted to frighten you into accepting its inadequate offer by claiming                                                                                                                                                            Hillards is a successful company. Tesco has need, but no real reason, to attack it.
that   your shares will fall        substantially     if     the offer fails.                            Hillards                           has outperformed                                                                                   It has sought to construct its case on innuendo regarding Hillards' performance and
Tesco   as an                      investment by 35     per     cent            since    1977, as the        chart    below        shows.                 We                      future.   Let us                           compare   the claims     and the     facts.
believe    we can continue to       generate                                excellent                                                                                             M a r k e t S h a r e ;   A     Te s c o C l a i m   A n s w e r e d      Hillards  has     a  "shrinking     market            share"
returns    on  your                           investment  in this successful                  £1 9 2 2                                                                                                                                                      ★ Over    two     years      Hillards             has       maintained
company      in     the         future.     Here's why:                                                               £1 4 2 0                                                                                                                                  i t s m a r k e t       s h a r e  i n t h e  Yo r k s h i r e T V
                                                                                                                                      Th e Va l u e  o f                                                                                                        region-Tesco's has fallen                     by over       10 per
W e        H a v e              M a d e    S u b s t a n t i a l      I n v e s t m e n t s                  £ i o o               i  n v e s t e d                                                                                                             cent,              as illustrated  in    the  chart to the    left
★ Since       1980-£72              million     spent     on                    fixed                                                 Ten    Years   Ago                                                                                                    ★ Hillards continues         to                      expand beyond its
       assets,     14           new stores     and     a     61   per            cent                                                                                                                                                                           h i s t o r i c  Yo r k s h i r e  b a s e
       i n c r e a s e      i n s a l e s    a r e a                                                                                                                                                                                                        Hillards  is suffering       from "falling            volume"
★ Rapid        advances             made     in                          productivity                                                                                                                                                                       ★ I n 1 9 8 6 / 8 7   l  i k e f o r     l i k e  v o l u m e s  a r e
★     A greater             range     of     higher     margin                 goods,        H                                                                                        M a r     8 5         M a r 8 7          M a r   8 5 M a r     8 7        expected     to      rise     nearly     3    per   cent       and
                                                                                                 i   l l a r d s      T e s c o                                                       H i l l a r d s                                  Te s c o
       continually                   being    extended                                     Source:   See  Appendix                              Source:                               See     Appendix                                                          overall                          volumes are expected to rise over
★ Own label                        grocery          sales    have doubled          in                                                                                                                                                                           10 per cent
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            ★ Recently     refurbished stores                 are          showing
       three  years                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             volume     gains
Our               Growth    is               Accelerating                                                                              A N      O F E E R     T O B E R E F U S E D                                                                         Hillards  is   "under pressure from competitor
★ f              986/87:    profits     before     tax     are              estimated                    Tesco is not offering adequate value for a company with the accelerating growth of                                                                 openings"
                                                                                                         H i l l a r d s:                                                                                                                                   ★ Nothing     new-we         have                 lived success
       to be £10.3 million-up 21 per cent                                                                                                                                                                                                                       fully with     this    for     years
★ 1987/88:                  profits     before            tax  are           forecast                    ★ Tesco thought that its original offer was                                                   generous-but nearly 97 per cent of                   ★ Hillards'     store      openings               put   our com
       to be not less than £15.0 million-up 45                                                               Hillards shareholders, other than Tesco and its advisers, did not accept it
                                                                                                         ★ In response to our 45 per cent increase forecast in pre-tax profit for 1987/88,                                                                                               petitors, including Tesco, under pressure
       per          cent                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    ★ Despite     operating in     one                of    the       most
★ 1988/89:      t he               new             ce nt ra l  d ist r ib ut io n                        ★     Tesco has increased its cash offer by only 18 per cent                                                                                           competitive    environments                       in the        UK
       programme                is               expected  to  contribute      to                            Even         more     shareholders     than     before think Tesco's increased   and           final     offer            is                                              Hillards has increased sales and profits in
       pre-tax profits                              by around  £2.0      million;                            inadequate-and are staying with Hillards                                                                                                           each of the     last     six     years
       more   new                   stores    will     be     opened;        even                                                                                                                                                                                                     Hillards has "uncompetitive and inconsistent
       more   space                   will   be     devoted to             higher                                                                                                                                                                           pricing"                             and an "inadequate product range"
       margin     fresh         foods                                                                                                                                             ★ A recent                independent                    survey     in    two towns    showed        that     80     per    cent     of      the
★ 1989 and beyond: further new stores and refurbishments are planned, all                                                                                                                                                                            products surveyed in the Hillards' stores were cheaper than or the same price
       serviced by the new central distribution facility, together with continuing                                                                                                as the equivalent in the Tesco stores
       enhancement of the sales mix and margins                                                                                                                                                                                                      ★ And Hillards' products were on average between one and two per cent cheaper
                                                                                                                                                                                  t    h a n    Te s c o ' s
And    Ou r  Futu re            is  Secu re                                                                                                                                                                                                            ★ An independent survey of 11 grocery product groups showed that a Hillards
★ Tesco itself has endorsed the Hillards strategy                                                                                                                                 store had 46 per cent more lines than in a similar sized Tesco store
★ Hillards        has           all     the     ingredients     for     continuing                     strength-an                effective             site                      The Hillards strategy will "weaken Hillards'                                      financial     position"
       acquisition              policy,     a strong     capital     base,     an     effective              retailing              formula              and                      ★ Gearing     is              a modest               18  per     cent
       proven     management                                                                                                                                                      ★ The strategy is generating higher                                       profits                               and cash flow-providing a strong
                                                                                                                                                                                  platform                  for     our    future          growth
The Message-Shareholder Value                                                                                                                                                     The Hillards profit forecast of £15 million is "high risk-mortgaging the future"
★ Hillards        has           produced     outstanding     shareholder     value-a 35 per                                        cent               better                      ★ The forecast was prepared as part of our normal budgeting process
                                                                                                                                                                                  ★ It takes account of all                                known competitor openings
       performance than Tesco over ten years                                                                                                                                      ★ It     includes             no     unusual             expenditure            reductions-the         future               is    not      being
★ We are          confident         that     our     strategy     and     investments                     will     continue        to                enhance                      mortgaged.                    Indeed                 marketing,     promotional     and            advertising              expenditure       is
       s h a r e h o l d e r    v a l u e                                                                                                                                         budgeted to rise materially

                                    S T A Y      W I T H      H I L L A R D S                                                                                                                                   S T A Y                    W I T H                H I L L A R D S
KEEPYOURINVESTMENTINSUCCESSTHEFACTANDTHEFICTION

Tesco has attempted to frighten you into accepting its inadequate offer by claiming Hillards is a successful company. Tesco has need, but no real reason, to attack it.
that your shares will fall substantially if the offer fails. Hillards has outperformed It has sought to construct its case on innuendo regarding Hillards' performance and
Tesco as an investment by 35 per cent since1977, as the chart below shows. We future. Let us compare the claims and the facts.
believe we can continue to generate excellent MarketShare ; A Te scoClaimAnswered Hillards has a "shrinking market share"
returns on your investment in this successful£1922 ★ Over two years Hillards has maintained
company in the future. Here's why: £1 420itsmarketshareinthe Yo rkshireTV
Th e Va lueof region-Tesco's has fallen by over 10 per
WeHaveMadeSubstantialInvestments£iooinvested cent, as illustrated in the chart to the left
★Since1980-£72 million spent on fixed Ten Years Ago ★ Hillards continues to expand beyond its
assets, 14 new stores and a 61 per cent historic Yo rkshirebase
increaseinsalesarea Hillards is suffering from "falling volume"
★ Rapid advances made in productivity ★ In1986 / 87likeforlikevolumesare
★ A greater range of higher margin goods, HMar85Mar87Mar85Mar87 expected to rise nearly 3 per cent and
illardsTescoHillards Tesco
continually being extended Source: See Appendix Source: See Appendix overall volumes are expected to rise over
★ Own label grocery sales have doubled in 10 per cent
★ Recently refurbished stores are showing
three years volume gains
Our Growth is Accelerating ANOFEERTOBEREFUSED Hillards is "under pressure from competitor
★ f 986/87:profits before tax are estimated Tesco is not offering adequate value for a company with the accelerating growth of openings"
Hillard s: ★ Nothing new-we have lived success
to be £10.3 million-up 21 per cent fully with this for years
★1987/88:profits before tax are forecast ★ Tesco thought that its original offer was generous-but nearly 97 per cent of ★ Hillards' store openings put our com
to be not less than£15.0 million-up 45 Hillards shareholders, other than Tesco and its advisers, did not accept it
★ In response to our 45 per cent increase forecast in pre-tax profit for 1987/88, petitors, including Tesco, under pressure
per cent ★ Despite operating in one of the most
★ 1988/89: t he new ce nt ra l d ist r ib ut io n ★ Tesco has increased its cash offer by only 18 per cent competitive environments in the UK
programme is expected to contribute to Even more shareholders than before think Tesco's increased and final offer is Hillards has increased sales and profits in
pre-tax profits by around£2.0 million; inadequate-and are staying with Hillards each of the last six years
more new stores will be opened; even Hillards has "uncompetitive and inconsistent
more space will be devoted to higher pricing" and an "inadequate product range"
margin fresh foods ★ A recent independent survey in two towns showed that 80 per cent of the
★ 1989 and beyond: further new stores and refurbishments are planned, all products surveyed in the Hillards' stores were cheaper than or the same price
serviced by the new central distribution facility, together with continuing as the equivalent in the Tesco stores
enhancement of the sales mix and margins ★ And Hillards' products were on average between one and two per cent cheaper
than Tesco' s
And Ou r Future is Secure★ An independent survey of 11 grocery product groups showed that a Hillards
★ Tesco itself has endorsed the Hillards strategy store had 46 per cent more lines than in a similar sized Tesco store
★ Hillards has all the ingredients for continuing strength-an effective site The Hillards strategy will "weaken Hillards' financial position"
acquisition policy, a strong capital base, an effective retailing formula and ★ Gearing is a modest 18 per cent
proven management ★ The strategy is generating higher profits and cash flow-providing a strong
platform for our future growth
The Message-Shareholder Value The Hillards profit forecast of £15million is "high risk-mortgaging the future"
★ Hillards has produced outstanding shareholder value-a 35 per cent better ★ The forecast was prepared as part of our normal budgeting process
★ It takes account of all known competitor openings
performance than Tesco over ten years ★ It includes no unusual expenditure reductions-the future is not being
★ We are confident that our strategy and investments will continue to enhance mortgaged. Indeed marketing, promotional and advertising expenditure is
shareholdervalue budgeted to rise materially

STAYWITHHILLARDSSTAYWITHHILLARDS

Read by machine

            KEEP YOUR INVESTMENT                                                 IN SUCCESS                                                                                    THE FACT AND THE FICTION

Tesco has attempted     to     frighten       you                         into accepting its inadequate offer by claiming                               Hillards is   a    successful company.     Tesco has need, but     no     real       reason, to  attack it.
that      your  shares will     fall substantially if the offer fails.                          Hillards has outperformed                               It     has sought  to construct     its case  on               innuendo regarding Hillards’ performance and
Tesco       as an     investment by 35      per cent          since    1977,  as the chart below shows.                We                               future.     Let us compare    the claims and the facts.
believe     we can     continue    to generate            excellent           £1922                                                                         Market   Share: A Tesco Claim Answered        Hillards      has a  “shrinking     market
returns      on your                  investment in this successful                                                                                     %                                                   *      Over  two   years Hillards has        maintained
company       in     the   future. Here’s why:                                                £1420                                                     6_|                                                        its  market   share in     the  Yorkshire     TV
                                                                                                        The Value of                                                                                               region—Tesco’s has fallen by     over 10     per
We Have Made Substantial Investments                                                                    £100 Invested                                   5_|                                                        cent, as  illustrated in the chart   to the left
*         Since 1980—£72 million     spent         on         fixed                                     Ten Years Ago                                   3_]                                                 *      Hillards continues    to       expand beyond its
          assets,  14     new stores  and   a  61  per         cent                                                                                     2                                                          historic Yorkshire    base
          increase in     sales area    1                                                                                                                                                                 Hillards      is  suffering from        volume”’
    +     Rapid    advances     made    in             productivity                                                                                     0                                                   *      In   1986/87    like for like    volumes     are
          A greater     range               of higher margin goods,           Hillards        Tesco                                                                                                                expected   to rise   nearly     3 per cent   and
          continually being extended                      Source:                See Appendix                Source: See                                            Appendix                                       overall volumes    are expected   to   rise over
          Own label     grocery    sales have doubled in                                                                                                                                                            10  per cent
                                                                                                                                                                                                            *      Recently refurbished      stores  are    showing
          three years                                                                                                                                                                                              volume   gains
Our Growth is     Accelerating                                                                              AN OFFER TO BE REFUSED                                                                        Hillards      is “under  pressure     from     competitor
    *     1986/87: profits before     tax    are estimated                       Tesco is     not      offering  adequate    value for   a  Company   with the accelerating growth of                      *x      Nothing    new—we          have   lived
         to be £10.3 million—up     21         per    cent                       Hillards:                                                                                                                                                                 success-
*         1987/88:     profits  before  tax    are    forecast                   *        Tesco thought that its original     offer     was generous—but nearly 97             per cent of                         fully with  this for years
         to be     less than £15.0                                                        Hillards shareholders,     other   than Tesco and its     advisers,   did   not accept   it                     *             store             openings   put our   com-
                    not        million—up                    45                                                                                                                                                    petitors, including Tesco,     under    pressure
         per   cent                                                              *        In     response   to our 45     per cent increase forecast in pre-tax     profit for  1987/88,                  *        Despite   operating    in  one    of the    most
          1988/89:     the    new    central       distribution                           Tesco has increased its cash offer by     Only     18     per cent                                                       competitive     environments     in    the    UK
         programme     is    expected   to  contribute       to                  *        Even   more       shareholders than       before  think     Tesco’s increased and final offer is                              Hillards has increased sales and profits in
         pre-tax     profits  by around     £2.0       million;                           inadequate—and              are    staying with Hillards                                                                  each of the last six     years
         more new stores     will     be   opened;         even                                                                                                                                           Hillards has              “uncompetitive and inconsistent
         more     space    will be     devoted   to      higher                                                                                                                                           pricing” and     an
         margin fresh     foods                                                                                                                                 A                                                       “inadequate product                  range”
          1989 and     beyond:     further     new                                                                                                      *           recent     independent     survey in  two towns     showed that          80    per cent  of the
                                                      stores     and   refurbishments            are   planned,       all                                       products surveyed in the Hillards’ stores               were cheaper than       or the   same price
         serviced     by   the  new     central  distribution     facility,      together        with          continuing                                       as   the equivalent in the Tesco     stores
         enhancement of     the sales mix       and margins                                                                                             *       And Hillards’ products     were on     average         between one  and   two   per  cent   cheaper
                                                                                                                                                                than Tesco’s
And Our Future is Secure                                                                                                                                *       An independent     survey     of 11    grocery      product  groups     showed that     a  Hillards
*        Tesco itself has endorsed     the      Hillards     strategy                                                                                           store had 46     per   cent more     lines than     in  a similar sized Tesco     store
*        Hillards     has  all  the     ingredients   for     continuing         strength—an           effective     site                               The Hillards       strategy    will “weaken    Hillards’ financial position”’
         acquisition     policy,   a    strong  capital     base,     an effective     retailing       formula        and                               *       Gearing is     a modest     18  per   cent
         proven     management                                                                                                                          *       The   strategy     is generating     higher     profits   and cash  flow—providing     a     strong
                                                                                                                                                                platform for     our   future growth
The      Message—Shareholder Value                                                                                                                      The Hillards       profit forecast of £15 million           is “high risk—mortgaging the
*             has     produced     outstanding            shareholder         value—a         35    per  cent      better                               *       The forecast     was   prepared     as part     of  our normal budgeting     process
         performance than Tesco     over        ten   years                                                                                             *       It   takes account    of all known     competitor openings
*        We    are     confident that   our  strategy  and investments will                    continue  to       enhance                               *       It   includes    no   unusual     expenditure          reductions—the    future     is   not  being
                                                                                                                                                                mortgaged.     Indeed   marketing,     promotional      and     advertising     expenditure      is
         shareholder value                                                                                                                                      budgeted       to rise materially
              STAY WITH HILLARDS                                                                                                                                               STAY WITH HILLARDS
KEEP YOUR INVESTMENT IN SUCCESS THE FACT AND THE FICTION

Tesco has attempted to frighten you into accepting its inadequate offer by claiming Hillards is a successful company. Tesco has need, but no real reason, to attack it.
that your shares will fall substantially if the offer fails. Hillards has outperformed It has sought to construct its case on innuendo regarding Hillards' performance and
Tesco as an investment by 35 per cent since1977, as the chart below shows. We future. Let us compare the claims and the facts.
believe we can continue to generate excellent£1922 Market Share: A Tesco Claim Answered Hillards has a "shrinking market
returns on your investment in this successful % * Over two years Hillards has maintained
company in the future. Here's why: £1420 6_| its market share in the Yorkshire TV
The Value of region-Tesco's has fallen by over 10 per
We Have Made Substantial Investments£100 Invested5_| cent, as illustrated in the chart to the left
*Since1980-£72 million spent on fixed Ten Years Ago 3_]*Hillards continues to expand beyond its
assets, 14 new stores and a 61 per cent 2 historic Yorkshire base
increase in sales area 1 Hillards is suffering from volume"'
+ Rapid advances made in productivity 0 * In 1986/87like for like volumes are
A greater range of higher margin goods, Hillards Tesco expected to rise nearly 3 per cent and
continually being extended Source: See Appendix Source: See Appendix overall volumes are expected to rise over
Own label grocery sales have doubled in 10 per cent
* Recently refurbished stores are showing
three years volume gains
Our Growth is Accelerating AN OFFER TO BE REFUSED Hillards is "under pressure from competitor
*1986/87:profits before tax are estimated Tesco is not offering adequate value for a Company with the accelerating growth of *x Nothing new-we have lived
to be £10.3 million-up 21 per cent Hillards: success-
*1987/88:profits before tax are forecast * Tesco thought that its original offer was generous-but nearly 97 per cent of fully with this for years
to be less than£15.0 Hillards shareholders, other than Tesco and its advisers, did not accept it * store openings put our com-
not million-up 45 petitors, including Tesco, under pressure
per cent * In response to our 45 per cent increase forecast in pre-tax profit for 1987/88,*Despite operating in one of the most
1988/89: the new central distribution Tesco has increased its cash offer by Only 18 per cent competitive environments in the UK
programme is expected to contribute to * Even more shareholders than before think Tesco's increased and final offer is Hillards has increased sales and profits in
pre-tax profits by around£2.0 million; inadequate-and are staying with Hillards each of the last six years
more new stores will be opened; even Hillards has "uncompetitive and inconsistent
more space will be devoted to higher pricing" and an
margin fresh foods A "inadequate product range"
1989 and beyond: further new * recent independent survey in two towns showed that 80 per cent of the
stores and refurbishments are planned, all products surveyed in the Hillards' stores were cheaper than or the same price
serviced by the new central distribution facility, together with continuing as the equivalent in the Tesco stores
enhancement of the sales mix and margins * And Hillards' products were on average between one and two per cent cheaper
than Tesco's
And Our Future is Secure * An independent survey of 11 grocery product groups showed that a Hillards
* Tesco itself has endorsed the Hillards strategy store had 46 per cent more lines than in a similar sized Tesco store
* Hillards has all the ingredients for continuing strength-an effective site The Hillards strategy will "weaken Hillards' financial position"'
acquisition policy, a strong capital base, an effective retailing formula and * Gearing is a modest 18 per cent
proven management * The strategy is generating higher profits and cash flow-providing a strong
platform for our future growth
The Message-Shareholder Value The Hillards profit forecast of £15million is "high risk-mortgaging the
* has produced outstanding shareholder value-a 35 per cent better * The forecast was prepared as part of our normal budgeting process
performance than Tesco over ten years * It takes account of all known competitor openings
* We are confident that our strategy and investments will continue to enhance * It includes no unusual expenditure reductions-the future is not being
mortgaged. Indeed marketing, promotional and advertising expenditure is
shareholder value budgeted to rise materially
STAY WITH HILLARDS STAY WITH HILLARDS

Read by machine, contrast corrected highest quality of the three

            KEEP YOUR INVESTMENT                                                 IN SUCCESS                                                                                    THE FACT AND THE FICTION

Tesco has attempted     to     frighten       you                         into accepting its inadequate offer by claiming                               Hillards is   a    successful company.     Tesco has need, but           no   real   reason,   to  attack it.
that      your  shares will     fall substantially if the offer fails.                          Hillards has outperformed                               It     has sought  to construct     its case  on                 innuendo regarding Hillards’ performance and
Tesco       as an     investment by 35      per cent          since    1977,  as the chart below shows.                We                               future.     Let us compare    the claims and the facts.
believe     we can     continue    to generate            excellent           £1922                                                                         Market   Share: A Tesco Claim Answered        Hillards      has    a     “shrinking market share”
returns      on your                  investment in this successful                                                                                     %                                                   *      Over     two     years Hillards has     maintained
company       in     the   future. Here’s why:                                                £1420                                                     6_|                                                        its  market     share  in    the  Yorkshire     TV
                                                                                                        The Value of                                                                                               region—Tesco’s has fallen by     over  10      per
We Have Made Substantial Investments                                                                    £100 Invested                                   5_|                                                        cent,    as illustrated in the chart   to the left
*         Since 1980—£72 million     spent      on            fixed                                     Ten Years Ago                                   45                                                  *      Hillards continues      to       expand beyond its
          assets,  14     new stores  and   a  61 per          cent                                                                                     34                                                         historic Yorkshire      base
          increase in     sales area                                                                                                                    2                                                 Hillards      is
1                                                                                                                                                                                                                       suffering from         volume’”’
    +     Rapid    advances     made    in             productivity                                                                                     0                      Mar        87                *      In   1986/87     like  for like    volumes     are
          A greater     range               of higher margin goods,           Hillards        Tesco                                                                 Hillards        Tesco                          expected      to   rise nearly    3 per cent   and
          continually being extended                      Source:                                                                                                                                                       ll       1          expected
                                                                                 See Appendix                Source: See                                            Appendix                                       overall   volumes are        to          rise over
          Own label     grocery    sales have doubled in                                                                                                                                                           10   per  cent
                                                                                                                                                                                                            *      Recently refurbished        stores  are    showing
          three years                                                                                                                                                                                              volume gains
Our Growth is     Accelerating                                                                              AN OFFER TO BE REFUSED                                                                        Hillards      is   “under   pressure    from     competitor
    *     1986/87: profits before     tax    are estimated                       Tesco is     not      offering  adequate    value for   a  Company   with the accelerating growth of                      *x      Nothing      new—we          have   lived
         to be £10.3 million—up     21         per    cent                       Hillards:                                                                                                                                                                   success-
*         1987/88:     profits  before  tax    are    forecast                   *        Tesco thought that its original     offer     was generous—but nearly 97             per cent of                         fully with     this for years
         to be     less than £15.0                                                        Hillards shareholders,     other   than Tesco and its     advisers,   did   not accept   it                     *                      store      openings   put our   com-
                    not        million—up                    45                                                                                                                                                    petitors, including Tesco,     under      pressure
         per   cent                                                              *        In     response   to our 45     per cent increase forecast in pre-tax     profit for  1987/88,                  *        Despite     operating    in  one    of the    most
          1988/89:     the    new    central       distribution                           Tesco has increased its cash offer by     Only     18     per cent                                                       competitive     environments     in     the     UK
         programme     is    expected   to  contribute       to                  *        Even   more       shareholders than       before  think     Tesco’s increased and final offer is                         Hillards has increased sales and profits in
         pre-tax     profits  by around     £2.0       million;                           inadequate—and              are    staying with Hillards                                                                  each of the last six       years
         more new stores     will     be   opened;         even                                                                                                                                           Hillards has                “uncompetitive and inconsistent
         more     space    will be     devoted   to      higher                                                                                                                                           pricing” and         an
         margin fresh     foods                                                                                                                                 A                                                                “inadequate product
          1989 and     beyond:     further     new                                                                                                      *           recent     independent     survey in  two towns          showed that     80     per cent   of the
                                                      stores     and   refurbishments            are   planned,       all                                       products surveyed in the Hillards’ stores               were   cheaper than       or the   same price
         serviced     by   the  new     central  distribution     facility,      together        with          continuing                                       as   the equivalent in the Tesco     stores
         enhancement of     the sales mix       and margins                                                                                             *       And Hillards’ products     were on     average         between     one and  two   per  cent   cheaper
                                                                                                                                                                than Tesco’s
And Our Future is Secure                                                                                                                                *       An independent     survey     of 11    grocery      product    groups     showed that     a  Hillards
*        Tesco itself has endorsed     the      Hillards     strategy                                                                                           store had 46     per   cent more     lines than     in  a   similar sized Tesco     store
*        Hillards     has  all  the     ingredients   for     continuing         strength—an           effective     site                               The Hillards       strategy    will “weaken    Hillards’ financial position”’
         acquisition     policy,   a    strong  capital     base,     an effective     retailing       formula        and                               *       Gearing is     a modest     18  per   cent
         proven     management                                                                                                                          *       The   strategy     is generating     higher     profits and cash     flow—providing     a      strong
                                                                                                                                                                platform for     our   future growth
The      Message—Shareholder Value                                                                                                                      The Hillards       profit forecast of £15 million           is “high risk—mortgaging the
*        Hillards     has  produced     outstanding       shareholder         value—a         35    per  cent      better                               *       The forecast     was   prepared     as part     of  our normal budgeting       process
         performance than Tesco     over        ten   years                                                                                             *           takes  account    of all known     competitor openings
*        We    are     confident that   our  strategy and investments will                     continue  to       enhance                               *       It   includes    no   unusual     expenditure          reductions—the      future     is   not  being
                                                                                                                                                                mortgaged.     Indeed   marketing,     promotional             and    advertising    expenditure   is
         shareholder value                                                                                                                                      budgeted       to rise materially
              STAY WITH HILLARDS                                                                                                                                               STAY WITH HILLARDS
KEEP YOUR INVESTMENT IN SUCCESS THE FACT AND THE FICTION

Tesco has attempted to frighten you into accepting its inadequate offer by claiming Hillards is a successful company. Tesco has need, but no real reason, to attack it.
that your shares will fall substantially if the offer fails. Hillards has outperformed It has sought to construct its case on innuendo regarding Hillards' performance and
Tesco as an investment by 35 per cent since1977, as the chart below shows. We future. Let us compare the claims and the facts.
believe we can continue to generate excellent£1922 Market Share: A Tesco Claim Answered Hillards has a "shrinking market share"
returns on your investment in this successful % * Over two years Hillards has maintained
company in the future. Here's why: £1420 6_| its market share in the Yorkshire TV
The Value of region-Tesco's has fallen by over 10 per
We Have Made Substantial Investments£100 Invested5_| cent, as illustrated in the chart to the left
*Since1980-£72 million spent on fixed Ten Years Ago 45 * Hillards continues to expand beyond its
assets, 14 new stores and a 61 per cent 34 historic Yorkshire base
increase in sales area 2 Hillards is
1 suffering from volume'"'
+ Rapid advances made in productivity 0 Mar 87 * In 1986/87like for like volumes are
A greater range of higher margin goods, Hillards Tesco Hillards Tesco expected to rise nearly 3 per cent and
continually being extended Source: ll 1 expected
See Appendix Source: See Appendix overall volumes are to rise over
Own label grocery sales have doubled in 10 per cent
* Recently refurbished stores are showing
three years volume gains
Our Growth is Accelerating AN OFFER TO BE REFUSED Hillards is "under pressure from competitor
*1986/87:profits before tax are estimated Tesco is not offering adequate value for a Company with the accelerating growth of *x Nothing new-we have lived
to be £10.3 million-up 21 per cent Hillards: success-
*1987/88:profits before tax are forecast * Tesco thought that its original offer was generous-but nearly 97 per cent of fully with this for years
to be less than£15.0 Hillards shareholders, other than Tesco and its advisers, did not accept it * store openings put our com-
not million-up 45 petitors, including Tesco, under pressure
per cent * In response to our 45 per cent increase forecast in pre-tax profit for 1987/88,*Despite operating in one of the most
1988/89: the new central distribution Tesco has increased its cash offer by Only 18 per cent competitive environments in the UK
programme is expected to contribute to * Even more shareholders than before think Tesco's increased and final offer is Hillards has increased sales and profits in
pre-tax profits by around£2.0 million; inadequate-and are staying with Hillards each of the last six years
more new stores will be opened; even Hillards has "uncompetitive and inconsistent
more space will be devoted to higher pricing" and an
margin fresh foods A "inadequate product
1989 and beyond: further new * recent independent survey in two towns showed that 80 per cent of the
stores and refurbishments are planned, all products surveyed in the Hillards' stores were cheaper than or the same price
serviced by the new central distribution facility, together with continuing as the equivalent in the Tesco stores
enhancement of the sales mix and margins * And Hillards' products were on average between one and two per cent cheaper
than Tesco's
And Our Future is Secure * An independent survey of 11 grocery product groups showed that a Hillards
* Tesco itself has endorsed the Hillards strategy store had 46 per cent more lines than in a similar sized Tesco store
* Hillards has all the ingredients for continuing strength-an effective site The Hillards strategy will "weaken Hillards' financial position"'
acquisition policy, a strong capital base, an effective retailing formula and * Gearing is a modest 18 per cent
proven management * The strategy is generating higher profits and cash flow-providing a strong
platform for our future growth
The Message-Shareholder Value The Hillards profit forecast of £15million is "high risk-mortgaging the
* Hillards has produced outstanding shareholder value-a 35 per cent better * The forecast was prepared as part of our normal budgeting process
performance than Tesco over ten years * takes account of all known competitor openings
* We are confident that our strategy and investments will continue to enhance * It includes no unusual expenditure reductions-the future is not being
mortgaged. Indeed marketing, promotional and advertising expenditure is
shareholder value budgeted to rise materially
STAY WITH HILLARDS STAY WITH HILLARDS