Hillards takeover

Algorithmic Indexing

387 documents 1,432 pages

Reply letter from Peter Hartley to Michael Rothschild 12/05/1987   page 2 of 2   previous

Scan of page 2 of Reply letter from Peter Hartley to Michael Rothschild 12/05/1987

Below is what the machine read from this scan, three times over. They are kept separate rather than merged: where they disagree, the disagreement is itself worth seeing, and a single tidy transcription would hide it.

The left column is raw output. The right is the same text after the repairs that make it searchable — joining letter-spaced words, mending split ones.

Text already in the scan

                  The Bank has of course made a major contribution towards the defence and
    lias done all the things that you mention in the second naragraph of vour Ini-f-.'-
       Indeed wc would suggest that having had to pick us up at such short notice on '
    the day of tiio bid you hove had to cover a lot more ground than would k-po
       t h e           c a s e  h a d      u e      b e e n      a      c l i e n t        b e f o r e .                    "    '
      It does s'-em to me that some of my criticisms probably arose heoau-- nC fi
 rather poor opinion th.at some of your team formed of llillards at tiio i i
 mcjeting. Obviously much of the fault there must lie with the Mill-rric-'^J -
 not projoctino ourselves bgtter. Peritaps we nave tiie impression r7
 CuJleris or Bisi-.ops; it seems to mo cS pity that ovon now all'the
    b o o n            a b l e  t o  v i s i  t      a t  l     e a s t     o n o  H i l l  a r d s    s t o r e .      " " "
                  However tfioso     criticisms some of which I                           passed on    to you bee-o.-o      t    4.^
    you should be aware of tf^em and which perhaps I would not have m-otion'.H
    scmeone for wrtom 1 iiave not such a liioh regard, csre to soma dooroe 00^-°
    incideucal           to     the  main     point     whicli     rny           board    have         exorf'ssprl    ' i     --e
                                                            _ j are aware tf.at in our profit forecasts wo have a fioure of h>lf-
                  Y o u
    million pounds whicl. was the ostimate made by us of what the"'t
                L o n
       s h o u l d   b)f;f  . At  tiiat  stage     we     were     not                 aware  of the     astrnnnmionliw     costs
ctiarqed by the printers nor in fairness had wo any/<-'sHnatp^?r^ fL'c'"'^^ H'Jreg
    j                    i     ,     r     o r                                                                    f a / ^ e n o v e s .
     When tl.e first bid came I reallv had no idea of the pert v/hip'
of the team would play. As tino goes on T have seen more clearlv tV^^''^i
    c r u c i a l    r o l e  t t i o t C a z o n o v e h a v e i n  t h e   d eefence    and I  am sure     tiiot
    aware            of     tliat than    you!     Also,        not       unnaturally,   the     input     and^t^o
    H i l l     c r d s      h a s     b e e n        n     m a j o r      f a c t o r    i   n  t     h e  d e f e n c e .      '  o f
     Takinn into account all that I now know it would seem tl.at teta] 4
costs in the region of one million pounds aro my hoarrl and T ' ^"^'.'-"C"
to our sliareholoer'.; without having to put forv7ard finiireVwhid, -^'^-tify
really too high. To this end I believe that it would not !.e unrenpn.w
suggest to you that 1 obtain my hoard's approval to get a ninu'-o i- ■
book on Friiloy morning to the effect that the fees of RotiieciiiJd i^inutc
    agreed               at   no  less  t!inn     half    a     million     pounds.     Thi;:    will    cover
    you         made     yesterday about     the     possiluJity     of              gcttinn  notiunr     and rr,^'.
    l  i t t    le       r o o m     f     o r     m o v e m e n t .                       '      "      - '     c o v e     a
     In due course 1 would be more tliari liappy to go through, some of
 riticisms with you and Gordon (I must say that I do not favour - rs'^^'^
viscussion with the rest - T think it v/ould be quite unfair). l'\.-r ^^^7'
 0 talk tn you about doing further trusirieos tcocther on on onnninp7v~- i'-
      I know tiiat K.B. are keen for 113 to return to them after this busirms" '
 over but having crossed many bridoes witti your team and liavin.- gone some" inpn"
 VMay towards estabiishing good working relationships tliere must be a lot of m'< ' i-
 in goifig forward together to a new and exciting programme for HiiJardo -^"rit
 development in the future.
      I am trying to catch up witti some of the more routine aspects of busine^-p
 life this week but I shall make a point of being available in tiio office'on
 Friday morning between 10 and 11.30 or alternatively you may wish to telephone
       m e          a t     h o m e     o n   T h u r s d a y     e v e n i n g     o n     0 3 3 2     6 6 1 4 2 4 .       '         ^
The Bank has of course made a major contribution towards the defence and
lias done all the things that you mention in the second naragraph of vour Ini-f-.'-
Indeed wc would suggest that having had to pick us up at such short notice on '
the day of tiio bid you hove had to cover a lot more ground than would k-po
thecasehaduebeenaclientbefore . " '
It does s'-em to me that some of my criticisms probably arose heoau-- nC fi
rather poor opinion th.at some of your team formed of llillards at tiio i i
mcjeting. Obviously much of the fault there must lie with the Mill-rric-'^J -
not projoctino ourselves bgtter. Peritaps we nave tiie impression r7
CuJleris or Bisi-.ops; it seems to mo cS pity that ovon now all'the
boonabletovisitatleastonoHillardsstore . " " "
However tfioso criticisms some of which I passed on to you bee-o.-o t 4.^
you should be aware of tf^em and which perhaps I would not have m-otion'.H
scmeone for wrtom 1 iiave not such a liioh regard, csre to soma dooroe 00^-°
incideucal to the main point whicli rny board have exorf'ssprl ' i --e
_ j are aware tf.at in our profit forecasts wo have a fioure of h>lf-
You
million pounds whicl. was the ostimate made by us of what the"'t
Lon
should b)f;f . At tiiat stage we were not aware of the astrnnnmionliw costs
ctiarqed by the printers nor in fairness had wo any/<-'sHnatp^?r^ fL'c'"'^^ H'Jreg
j i , rorfa / ^ enoves .
When tl.e first bid came I reallv had no idea of the pert v/hip'
of the team would play. As tino goes on T have seen more clearlv tV^^''^i
crucialrolettiotCazonovehaveinthed eefence and I am sure tiiot
aware of tliat than you! Also, not unnaturally, the input and^t^o
Hillcrdshasbeennmajorfactorinthedefence . ' o f
Takinn into account all that I now know it would seem tl.at teta] 4
costs in the region of one million pounds aro my hoarrl and T ' ^"^'.'-"C"
to our sliareholoer'.; without having to put forv7ard finiireVwhid, -^'^-tify
really too high. To this end I believe that it would not!.e unrenpn.w
suggest to you that 1 obtain my hoard's approval to get a ninu'-o i- ■
book on Friiloy morning to the effect that the fees of RotiieciiiJd i^inutc
agreed at no less t!inn half a million pounds. Thi;: will cover
you made yesterday about the possiluJity of gcttinn notiunr and rr,^'.
little roomformovement . ' " - ' covea
In due course 1 would be more tliari liappy to go through, some of
riticisms with you and Gordon (I must say that I do not favour - rs'^^'^
viscussion with the rest - T think it v/ould be quite unfair). l'\.-r ^^^7'
0 talk tn you about doing further trusirieos tcocther on on onnninp7v~- i'-
I know tiiat K.B. are keen for 113 to return to them after this busirms" '
over but having crossed many bridoes witti your team and liavin.- gone some" inpn"
VMay towards estabiishing good working relationships tliere must be a lot of m'< ' i-
in goifig forward together to a new and exciting programme for HiiJardo -^"rit
development in the future.
I am trying to catch up witti some of the more routine aspects of busine^-p
life this week but I shall make a point of being available in tiio office'on
Friday morning between 10 and 11.30 or alternatively you may wish to telephone
meathomeonThursdayeveningon0332661424 . ' ^

Read by machine highest quality of the three

         The    Bank        has     of                course            made  a    major          contribution                   towards       the        defence          and
   has done     all        the  things                      that  you                   mention   in    the    second            paragraph               of    your      ietter.
   Indsed    we    would       suggest                      that  having              had       to    pick     us       up       at     such   short                notice     on
   the  day    of   the       bid      you      have                    had    to  cover          a   lot    more            ground       than        would           heve     bee
   the case     had        we  been       a     client                 before.

         It    does        seem     to me                   that  some            of     my     criticisms              probably            arose         because          of
   rather poor        opinion           that      some                    of          your  team      formed       of        Hillards                                           the
   meeting.        Obviously            much              of            the          fault  there         must     lie       with              at        the     initial        :
   net projecting             ourselves           better.                                Perhaps                   the                   the   Hillards             team       for
   Cullens     or   Bishops;            it                        to                        pity     we    gave                  impression              of    3  provincial
                                                seems                       me     a                 that    even            now    all     the       team
   heen  able      to      visit       at              least    one         Hillards              store.

         However           those       criticisms                            some  of       which       I  passed            on     to    you      because          T
   you  should      be           aware  of      them            and         which           perhaps        I   would             not   have                  mentioned     h     ;
   someone     for    whom      I      have              not    such            a  hich         regard,        are           to   some                                   is        |
   incidental       to      the     mein        point             which            my       board         have     expressed,                                    quite
         You    are        aware       that      in          our            profit          forecasts          we       have     a     figure            of       half
   million           pounds  which        was     the             estimate                  made       by  us      of        what    the                                 a
   should   be.          At       that  stage                we   were            not       aware     of        the                         total
   charged by       the                printers  nor            in          fairness had              we                astronomically                    hich
                                                                                                                any     estimate            in     for
     :   When      the         first        bid  came             I        really           had      no   ides     of        the     part     which            each
   of  the  team      would         play.         As            time;        goes           on    I  have      seen          more     Clearly             the
   erucial      role       that     Cazenove                                ge     ere                                                                            abs       Ute
                                                                     have   in     the       defence            and     I                     ++
                                       you!       Also,A                                                                     am   sure      that          no
   aware    of  that        than                                             not  unnaturally,                      the      input    and      the              ane      1S    More
   Hillards     has        been     a   major         L,                                                                     ‘                 ad         attitude          of }
factor                                                                       in       the      defence,

     Taking into account all that I now know it would seem
   costs    in  the        region       of           one    million               pounds                  what                             that       total       defence
                                                                                                     ere           my        board        and         I   could     justif
   to   our  shareholders               without                         having    to     put         forward                 figures  which           we     felt
   really    too    high.           To    this                end       I            believe   that       it would           not      be                    unreasonable  ta
   suggest     to   you      that       I  obtain                      my            board's   approval              to      qet   a  Minute             in    hig              =
   book on     Friday        morning           to             the      effect          that          the  fees     of        Rothschild                                   aa
   agreed    at   no     less         than     half             a      million         pounds.                     This      will    cover         the       point     oe
   you made     yesterday             about       the             possibility                   of              getting      nothing      and
   little             “                                                                                                                                        leave
             room        for  movement.                                                                                                                                   a

        In      due  course           1            would    be            more    than         happy      to         go      through      some                 bis
       jiscussion       with  you       and     Gordon (I                              must  say      that   I        do     not     favour           o  of         {
   9   talk    to       with  the       rest           -    I            think    it            would  be          quite     unfair),              T     would      also
                    you about                      doing    further               business             together              on   an    ongoing
         I     know     that    K.B.                 are    keen                         us          return          to      them    after             this for to
   over     but    having       crossed                      many      bridces         with           your          team     and     havina           gone          some  long
   way   towards        establishing                  good                          working                relationships     there         must       be     a  lat     oF      me
   in  going       forward                      together    to         a                 and   exciting new        programme              for      Hillards
   development            in  the       future.

         I     am   trying           to            catch    up            with    some         of     the          more      routine      aspects              of     businese
   life     this        week  but       I  shall               make          a    point         of     being                  available   in       the            office  on
   Friday            morning  between                 10    and 11.30                     or   alternatively                 you     may     wish            to
   me   at   home    on      Thursday                             evening   on    0532         661424.
The Bank has of course made a major contribution towards the defence and
has done all the things that you mention in the second paragraph of your ietter.
Indsed we would suggest that having had to pick us up at such short notice on
the day of the bid you have had to cover a lot more ground than would heve bee
the case had we been a client before.

It does seem to me that some of my criticisms probably arose because of
rather poor opinion that some of your team formed of Hillards the
meeting. Obviously much of the fault there must lie with at the initial :
net projecting ourselves better. Perhaps the the Hillards team for
Cullens or Bishops; it to pity we gave impression of 3 provincial
seems me a that even now all the team
heen able to visit at least one Hillards store.

However those criticisms some of which I passed on to you because T
you should be aware of them and which perhaps I would not have mentioned h ;
someone for whom I have not such a hich regard, are to some is |
incidental to the mein point which my board have expressed, quite
You are aware that in our profit forecasts we have a figure of half
million pounds which was the estimate made by us of what the a
should be.At that stage we were not aware of the total
charged by the printers nor in fairness had we astronomically hich
any estimate in for
: When the first bid came I really had no ides of the part which each
of the team would play. As time; goes on I have seen more Clearly the
erucial role that Cazenove ge ere abs Ute
have in the defence and I ++
you! Also,A am sure that no
aware of that than not unnaturally, the input and the ane 1S More
Hillards has been a major L, ' ad attitude of }
factor in the defence,

Taking into account all that I now know it would seem
costs in the region of one million pounds what that total defence
ere my board and I could justif
to our shareholders without having to put forward figures which we felt
really too high. To this end I believe that it would not be unreasonable ta
suggest to you that I obtain my board's approval to qet a Minute in hig =
book on Friday morning to the effect that the fees of Rothschild aa
agreed at no less than half a million pounds. This will cover the point oe
you made yesterday about the possibility of getting nothing and
little " leave
room for movement. a

In due course 1 would be more than happy to go through some bis
jiscussion with you and Gordon (I must say that I do not favour o of {
9 talk to with the rest - I think it would be quite unfair), T would also
you about doing further business together on an ongoing
I know that K.B. are keen us return to them after this for to
over but having crossed many bridces with your team and havina gone some long
way towards establishing good working relationships there must be a lat oF me
in going forward together to a and exciting new programme for Hillards
development in the future.

I am trying to catch up with some of the more routine aspects of businese
life this week but I shall make a point of being available in the office on
Friday morning between 10 and 11.30 or alternatively you may wish to
me at home on Thursday evening on 0532 661424.

Read by machine, contrast corrected

       The     Bank      has      of    course                                 made  a          major     contribution                                towards      the        defence           and
has done       all      the     things                 that            you           mention              in   the      second                  paragraph                of        your    letter,
Indsed      we  would           suggest                that            having               had       to     pick       us          up        at         such      short           notice       on     |
the    day    of the       bic      you           have                  had         to          cover     a  lot      more             ground            than          would                 heve bean
the case       had      we      been    a                       client  before.                                                                                                                 >

       It     does      sesm      to me                that            some              of     my    criticisms                    probably                  arose           because           of
rather poor             opinion      that              some                      of         your  team       formed         of                       Hillards      at    the                    the
meeting.           Obviously         much                                                                                                                                            initial
                                                       of               the                fault  there            must     lie          with                                            t
not           projecting   ourselves                   better.                                 Perhaps      we              the                           the      Hillards             team     for
Cullens       or           Bishops;  it           seems                to          me             pity              gave                      impression                 o     F   8    provincial
                                                                                           a                that      even             now      all           the      ;
been   able        to   visit       at    least                     one            Hillards               store.                                                    ceam             have       not
       However          those       criticisms                          some                  of  which        I    passed               on     to             you because              I
you    should       be   aware       of           them              and            which          perhaps           I   would                 not                                          thought
                                                                                                                                                                                        hig
                                I   have               not          such                                                                                      have mention              ed to
someone       for       whom                                                        a      hich       regard,           are            to       some
incidental                                                                                                                                                    dearee                 quite
                    to   the      main            point               which                my     board            have     expressed,                             ‘                   aad
       You     are      aware       that               in         our      profit                 forecasts             we          have        a    figure              of           half
million           pounds  which         was            the            estimete                    made        by    us      ef         what          the
should      be.       At       that  stage                   we       were               not      aware        of        the                                  total       igh.
charged     by       the  printers                     nor          in     fairness                  had       we                   astronomically
                                                                                                                         any        estimate                    in    for
     When          the        first  bid               came           I     really                had       no   idea       of           the       part           which each
of     the team         would     play.                As           time            goes          on      I  have       seen             more                                              ert
erucial         role    that      Cazenove                           have          in      the     defence               and        I                Clearly
                                                                                                                                         am     sure          that        no
aware of       that      than       you!               Also,                       not     unnaturally,                      the            input    and          the     Beets                 of
Hillards       has      been      a  major                   factor                 in         the  defence,

    Taking              inte    account                all            that               I now      know         it               would       seem             that
costs      in  the           region  of               one         million                  pounds           ere     what                                               total
to     our  shareholders             without                                    having     to     put       forward                  my                board  an       T  could          Justify
really      too                                                                                                                                      which             we      Felt
                    high.         To    this                 end        I                  believe  that         it               would       n C    Lh.                                 were
suggest      to     you   that       I   obtain;                       my          board's;         approval                  to       get      a    de         unreasonable                    to     =
book on       Friday      morning         to                 the       effect                  that         the     fees             of              minute                 in   our     minut
                                                                                                                                              Rothschild                                   ol     .e
                        less        than  half                      a  million‘                                                                                               IVE    t   arn
agreed      at    no                                                                           pounds.                      This         J                          have             ne
=   made                                                                                                                               will        cover              the      point       tk        °
               yesterday                      about    the            possibility                     ofaa                                                                       VEO            Chat
you                                               -          4                                                           getting       nothing                and
little      room      for    movement.                                                                                                                                 may                  i

     In         due     course     1                would         be   more                than     happy         to          go       through                some          of   my
criticisms           with    you     and               Gordon (I                             must  say       that     I           do     not       Favour              a
discussion           with    the     rest                         I            think       it          would  be                                                          round          table
                                                        -                                                                      quite     unfair),                                  at             +g
9 talk       to     you   about                     doing         further                  business           together                                               I   would          also     Ke
                                                                                                                                         on     an       ongeing              basis

      I       know      that    K.B.                  are         keen             for         us  to       return            to       them        after                  this   business       is
over       but     having                   crossed    many                                    with          your               team     and       havina              gone        some     long
way    towards          establishing                         good                         working                      relationships     there                 must    be      a   lot     af     merit
in  going          forward                       together         to   a           new         and  exciting            programme                        for
development            in    the     future.

      I      am     trying        to                catch         up   with                some     of       the            more       routine                aspects            of           busine SS
life       this      week    but     I                   shall      make           a       point      of      being                                available  in      the      of  fice     on
Friday            morning    between                   10         and 11.30                     or  alternatively                             you    may         wish          to    talus  phone
me     at   home on       Thursday                                evening          on      0532     661424,
The Bank has of course made a major contribution towards the defence and
has done all the things that you mention in the second paragraph of your letter,
Indsed we would suggest that having had to pick us up at such short notice on |
the day of the bic you have had to cover a lot more ground than would heve bean
the case had we been a client before. >

It does sesm to me that some of my criticisms probably arose because of
rather poor opinion that some of your team formed of Hillards at the the
meeting. Obviously much initial
of the fault there must lie with t
not projecting ourselves better. Perhaps we the the Hillards team for
Cullens or Bishops; it seems to me pity gave impression oF8 provincial
a that even now all the ;
been able to visit at least one Hillards store. ceam have not
However those criticisms some of which I passed on to you because I
you should be aware of them and which perhaps I would not thought
hig
I have not such have mention ed to
someone for whom a hich regard, are to some
incidental dearee quite
to the main point which my board have expressed, ' aad
You are aware that in our profit forecasts we have a figure of half
million pounds which was the estimete made by us ef what the
should be.At that stage we were not aware of the total igh.
charged by the printers nor in fairness had we astronomically
any estimate in for
When the first bid came I really had no idea of the part which each
of the team would play. As time goes on I have seen more ert
erucial role that Cazenove have in the defence and I Clearly
am sure that no
aware of that than you! Also, not unnaturally, the input and the Beets of
Hillards has been a major factor in the defence,

Taking inte account all that I now know it would seem that
costs in the region of one million pounds ere what total
to our shareholders without having to put forward my board an T could Justify
really too which we Felt
high. To this end I believe that it would n C Lh. were
suggest to you that I obtain; my board's; approval to get a de unreasonable to =
book on Friday morning to the effect that the fees of minute in our minut
Rothschild ol .e
less than half a million' IVE t arn
agreed at no pounds. This J have ne
= made will cover the point tk °
yesterday about the possibility ofaa VEO Chat
you - 4 getting nothing and
little room for movement. may i

In due course 1 would be more than happy to go through some of my
criticisms with you and Gordon (I must say that I do not Favour a
discussion with the rest I think it would be round table
- quite unfair), at +g
9 talk to you about doing further business together I would also Ke
on an ongeing basis

I know that K.B. are keen for us to return to them after this business is
over but having crossed many with your team and havina gone some long
way towards establishing good working relationships there must be a lot af merit
in going forward together to a new and exciting programme for
development in the future.

I am trying to catch up with some of the more routine aspects of busineSS
life this week but I shall make a point of being available in the office on
Friday morning between 10 and 11.30 or alternatively you may wish to talus phone
me at home on Thursday evening on 0532 661424,