Hillards takeover

Algorithmic Indexing

387 documents 1,432 pages

Reply letter from Peter Hartley to Michael Rothschild 12/05/1987   page 1 of 2   next

Scan of page 1 of Reply letter from Peter Hartley to Michael Rothschild 12/05/1987

Below is what the machine read from this scan, three times over. They are kept separate rather than merged: where they disagree, the disagreement is itself worth seeing, and a single tidy transcription would hide it.

The left column is raw output. The right is the same text after the repairs that make it searchable — joining letter-spaced words, mending split ones.

Text already in the scan

    PAiiH/SC    ■)2th May, 1987.


    M r .    M . J . d c     R .     R i c n a r d s o n ,
    R .M .    R c c i i s c i i i i d & . S o n s L i m i t e d ,
    P . O .   i i o x  ^ k ) .
    New       Court,
    S t .  S w i t i i i u ' j  L a r i f ; ,
    L o r. d o n    E C 9 P     A D U .




               Tr-ior.k          you     for    your      Irittnr     of    May 7th               concerniriq     fees           and     your                  uugqestod
    f e u .

      Ao you know I am und(?r soiup problem fioro as 1 oni of couroo meroly the
opokeoman for my board and I coulr! periiaps quote From Mil lards board minutro.

    25tfi      March,            1987
                "Tiae     chairman            reported            that         N.H.    Rothschild     &.          Sons       itad    suqnestod            a     fee
    equal to               0.2'i'n     of   the    iirice       if the      Tesco          bid      was       successful         and     0.80%            of         the
    offercrl               price if     the  bid         was       unsuccessful.           The               bntrd    were       of     the     unanimous
    tyjii'iior:     tb.ai:       the     sunfjeatcc;                 fees   were       too fiigii     ar.d        that      thicro          should be         no
    d i f f e r e n t i a l    a n ( '      t n e  c h e i r m n i i        w a s    n u t h o r i s o d       t o    a     m o t e r i a l l v   l  o w e r
    s e t t l e m e i i i: ."

    7 t h      A p r i l ,  1 9 d 7
                "TtiC;          directors       nciled          witn     concern        tjiat       despite       actro'~'ncnt               of   trie     contents         of
    t he       fi na l     d raft     of    t he   fi r rd:              defe nce  doc u me nt,             N .M .    Rot hsc i i i ld           had  fa i led       to
    include             a   qrap.ii      of tiie         company's          share          price            over      tiie   pcrind            since       1977.   It      was
    furtiier        noted            that   only         immediately               prior     to        tiio  press                   conference   held          on
    Friday,         27th             March, 1987          tiad     ir-e     company        been                   informed     of  chanaes           to the        agreed
    text       on   page         19      nf  the      rincumnnt             which       hod       bfien made      by             Rothschild.               These   vrere
    completely                    against   the       company's             expressed               requirements,                and     the         niterntions           had
    been               made   v/ithout       the      company's             prior       knowledge             and            wore contrary           to what tiie
    coiTimittee              of           directors   had         agreed .             Noted      tiiat      the    fees     of    Rotlischilds           wore
    s t i l l     t  o     b e   fi     n a l i s e d . "

    2 9 t i i   A p r i l ,      1 9 8 7
                " T h e     c o s t s      i n c u r r e d  i n   t h e     p r e p a r a t i o n   o f    t h e  fi r s t   d e f e n c e       d o c u m e n t   v / e r o
    r e o o r t e d      b y     t h e   c h a i r m s n    a n d     i t   w a s  n o t e d      t h a t  t h e  f o e      o f  N . M . R o t i i s c fi i l d   w a s
    s t i l l        t o     b e         a g r e e d        "

                I    t i a v e   t o l d y o u    t h a t     I   h a v e   t a l k e d  t o      a    n u m b e r     o f   f r i e n d s  a n d    a c q u a i n t a n o e s
    w h o       h a v e  b e e n      i n   a     s i m i l a r   p o s i t i o n  t o  m y s e l f     i n   r e c e n t  t i m e s     i n c l u d i n q  o n e    v / p o
    has        been              involved   in    over          a     dozen        take     overs     in          the space      of          12   months!            it is
    quite             clear  from        tiiose                     conversations  which      I     hod       in    Mcorch          that    a        fiqure         well
    below five                    hundred    thousand             pounds           would     be     wfial          they      all        thought   tney             would  be
    ab le       to          ne r iot iate   w it h       t he i r   Ba n ks        i n  a    defe nce           of    a      £200    m i l l io n       offe r .   I     wo u ld
    add tiittt           aithough          a number nf             leading                                    OaoKs were involved none was            Rothschild.
PAiiH/SC ■)2th May, 1987.


M r . M . J . dcR . Ricnardson ,
R .M . Rcciisciiiid& . SonsLimited ,
P . O . iiox ^ k ) .
New Court,
S t . Switiiiu ' jLarif ; ,
L o r. donEC9PADU .




Tr-ior.k you for your Irittnr of May 7th concerniriq fees and your uugqestod
feu .

Ao you know I am und(?r soiup problem fioro as 1 oni of couroo meroly the
opokeoman for my board and I coulr! periiaps quote From Mil lards board minutro.

25tfi March,1987
"Tiae chairman reported that N.H. Rothschild &. Sons itad suqnestod a fee
equal to 0.2'i'n of the iirice if the Tesco bid was successful and 0.80% of the
offercrl price if the bid was unsuccessful. The bntrd were of the unanimous
tyjii'iior: tb.ai: the sunfjeatcc; fees were too fiigii ar.d that thicro should be no
differentialan ( ' tnecheirmniiwasnuthorisodtoamoteriallvlower
settlemeii i: ."

7thApril , 19d7
"TtiC; directors nciled witn concern tjiat despite actro'~'ncnt of trie contents of
t he fi na l d raft of t he fi r rd: defence doc u me nt, N .M . Rot hsc iii ld had fa i led to
include a qrap.ii of tiie company's share price over tiie pcrind since1977. It was
furtiier noted that only immediately prior to tiio press conference held on
Friday, 27th March,1987 tiad ir-e company been informed of chanaes to the agreed
text on page 19 nf the rincumnnt which hod bfien made by Rothschild. These vrere
completely against the company's expressed requirements, and the niterntions had
been made v/ithout the company's prior knowledge and wore contrary to what tiie
coiTimittee of directors had agreed . Noted tiiat the fees of Rotlischilds wore
stilltobe finalised. "

29tiiApril , 1987
" Thecostsincurredinthepreparationofthe fi rstdefencedocumentv / ero
reoortedbythechairmsnanditwasnotedthatthefoeofN . M . Rotiisc fi ildwas
stilltobeagreed "

ItiavetoldyouthatIhavetalkedtoanumberoffriendsandacquaintanoes
whohavebeeninasimilarpositiontomyselfinrecenttimesincludinqonev / p o
has been involved in over a dozen take overs in the space of 12 months! it is
quite clear from tiiose conversations which I hod in Mcorch that a fiqure well
below five hundred thousand pounds would be wfial they all thought tney would be
ab le to ne riot iate w it h t he i r Ba n ks ina defence of a £200mill io n offer. I wo u ld
add tiittt aithough a number nf leading OaoKs were involved none was Rothschild.

Read by machine

PALH/SC    42th May, 1987.


Mr.   M.J. de R.  Richardson,
N.M.   Rothschild & Sons Limited,
PsOs      Now   Boy
New   Court,
St.   Swithin's  Lane,
Landon EC4P   4DU.





      Thank       you     for   your    letter    of   May   7th concerning        fees   and  your    suggested
fee.

      As    you    know     I   am   under   some    problem     here  as  I    am   of  course     merely   the
spokesman       for  my    board      and  I     could perhaps      quote

25th  March,       1987
      "The      chairman        reported     that    N.M.      Rothschild  &    Sons    had  suggested     a     fee
equal to       0.25%   of     the    price   if   the  Techs     bia  wee               tall        0 SON
offered     price    if    the     bid  was      unsuccessful.     The     board     were   of the     unanimous
opinion     that    the                      fees    were  too   high and      that   there    should     be no
differential        and    the     chairman      was      authorised  to   seek   a   materially       lower
settlement.'i]

7th April,       71987
      "The      directors        noted    with    concern      that     despite   agreement    of   the   contents      of
the      final  draft      of   the   first      defence   document,     N.M.     Rothsehild      had    failed  to
include     a   graph      of   the   company's     share      price  over    the    period      since 1972.     It   was
  further   noted        that   only    immediately     prior     te  the     press   conference       held  on
Friday,     27th    March,         1987 had      the company     been      informed   of  changes      to the   agreed
text  on    page    15     of   the   document     which     had been    made     by  Rothschild.         These  were
completely            against    the  company's     expressed requirements,              and   the        alterations had
been  made      without       the       company's    prior   knowledge     and    were   contrary      to  what  the
committee       of         directors  had  agreed.     Noted     that    the    fees    of  Rothschilds         were
still to       be  finalised."

29th  April,       1987
          "Tne  costs      incurred     in   the     preparation     of  the    first    defence       document  were
reported       by  the     chairman     and    it    was  noted  that    the    fee   of  N.M.       Rothschild  was
still to       be  agreed,......"

      J   have     told    you     that  I   have    talked    to  a  number      of  friends     and       acquaintances
who    have    been   in    a   similar    position     to     myself  in  recent       times  including         one  who
has    been    involved       in   over  a   dozen     take    overs  in   the    space   of   12   months!       It  is
quite   clear      from    those      conversations     which      I  had    in   March   that    a figure       well
below   five          hundred   thousand     pounds     would    be  what  they      all  thought      they     would  be
able  to    negotiate           with  their      Banks   in  a defence     of   a  £200   million      offer.    1    would
add   that     although       a number     of                Banks   were  involved       none    was  Rothschild.
PALH/SC 42th May, 1987.


Mr. M.J. de R. Richardson,
N.M. Rothschild & Sons Limited,
PsOs Now Boy
New Court,
St. Swithin's Lane,
Landon EC4P 4DU.





Thank you for your letter of May 7th concerning fees and your suggested
fee.

As you know I am under some problem here as I am of course merely the
spokesman for my board and I could perhaps quote

25th March,1987
"The chairman reported that N.M. Rothschild & Sons had suggested a fee
equal to 0.25% of the price if the Techs bia wee tall 0 SON
offered price if the bid was unsuccessful. The board were of the unanimous
opinion that the fees were too high and that there should be no
differential and the chairman was authorised to seek a materially lower
settlement.'i]

7th April,71987
"The directors noted with concern that despite agreement of the contents of
the final draft of the first defence document, N.M. Rothsehild had failed to
include a graph of the company's share price over the period since1972. It was
further noted that only immediately prior te the press conference held on
Friday, 27th March,1987 had the company been informed of changes to the agreed
text on page 15 of the document which had been made by Rothschild. These were
completely against the company's expressed requirements, and the alterations had
been made without the company's prior knowledge and were contrary to what the
committee of directors had agreed. Noted that the fees of Rothschilds were
still to be finalised."

29th April,1987
"Tne costs incurred in the preparation of the first defence document were
reported by the chairman and it was noted that the fee of N.M. Rothschild was
still to be agreed,......"

J have told you that I have talked to a number of friends and acquaintances
who have been in a similar position to myself in recent times including one who
has been involved in over a dozen take overs in the space of 12 months! It is
quite clear from those conversations which I had in March that a figure well
below five hundred thousand pounds would be what they all thought they would be
able to negotiate with their Banks in a defence of a £200million offer. 1 would
add that although a number of Banks were involved none was Rothschild.

Read by machine, contrast corrected highest quality of the three

42th May, 19287.


Mr.  M.J. de R.  Richardson,
N.M.  Rothschild & Sons Limited,
P.O. Box  No.  165,
New  Court,”
St.  Swithin's  Lane,
Landon EC4P   4DU.





      Thank      you   for    your  letter     of   May  7th concerning       fees   and    your         suggested
fee.

      As   you    know   I    am   under   some   problem    here  as  I   am   of   course   merely       the
spokesman      for  my   board      and  I could    perhaps     quote    from   Hillards      board   minutes.

25th  March,      1987
      "The     chairman       reported     that   N.M.     Rothschild  &   Sons     had   suggested      a    fee
equal to      0.25%   of   the     price   if  the  Tesco    bid  was  successful         and 0.50%      af    the
offered    price    if   the    bid  was   unsuccessful.     The      board     were    of   the   unanimous
opinion    that    the   suggested        fees  were    too  high and    thet     there    should     be  no
                   and   the     chairman     was     authorised  to  seek    a   materially       lower
settlement."

7th April,       1987
      "The     directors      noted     with   concern     that    despite   agreement      of   the  contents       of
the     final  draft    of    the   first  defence     document,     N.M.    Rothschild        had    failed  to
include    a   graph    of    the   company's     share    price  over    the   period       since  1972.     It   was
  further  noted      that    only  immediately     prior     to  the  press      conference       held   on
Friday,    27th    March,      1987 had    the    company    been       informed  of   changes     to the    agreed
text  on   page    15   of    the   document    which    had been    made    by   Rothschild.          These  were
completely         against    the   company's     expressed           requirements,  and   the         alterations had
been  made     without     the       company's  prior    knowledge    and    were       contrary   to   what  the
committee      of        directors  had  agreed.     Noted   that    the   fees     of  Rothschilds          were
still to      be  finalised."

29th  April,      1987
         "Tne  casts    incurred      in   the  preparation     of   the   first     defence        document  were
reported      by  the   chairman    and     it  was  noted   that    the     fee  of   N.M.       Rothschild  was
stil] to      be  agreed......."

      I   have    told   you   that    I   have   talked    to a  number     of   friends     and        acquaintances
who   have    been   in  a    similar    pesition    to    myself  in  recent       times   including        cone  who
has   been    involved     in  over    a   dozen    take   overs  in  the    space     of  12  months!         It  is
quite   clear     from       those  conversations     which    I  had   in   March     that   a  fiqure       well
below   five     hundred      thousand     pounds   would    be  what  they      all   thought     they      would  be
able to    negotiate          with  their     Banks in   a  defence   of   a    £200   million     offer.     1    would
add   that    although     ae number     of   leacing    Banks   were       involved   none   was
42th May, 19287.


Mr. M.J. de R. Richardson,
N.M. Rothschild & Sons Limited,
P.O. Box No. 165,
New Court,"
St. Swithin's Lane,
Landon EC4P 4DU.





Thank you for your letter of May 7th concerning fees and your suggested
fee.

As you know I am under some problem here as I am of course merely the
spokesman for my board and I could perhaps quote from Hillards board minutes.

25th March,1987
"The chairman reported that N.M. Rothschild & Sons had suggested a fee
equal to 0.25% of the price if the Tesco bid was successful and 0.50% af the
offered price if the bid was unsuccessful. The board were of the unanimous
opinion that the suggested fees were too high and thet there should be no
and the chairman was authorised to seek a materially lower
settlement."

7th April,1987
"The directors noted with concern that despite agreement of the contents of
the final draft of the first defence document, N.M. Rothschild had failed to
include a graph of the company's share price over the period since1972. It was
further noted that only immediately prior to the press conference held on
Friday, 27th March,1987 had the company been informed of changes to the agreed
text on page 15 of the document which had been made by Rothschild. These were
completely against the company's expressed requirements, and the alterations had
been made without the company's prior knowledge and were contrary to what the
committee of directors had agreed. Noted that the fees of Rothschilds were
still to be finalised."

29th April,1987
"Tne casts incurred in the preparation of the first defence document were
reported by the chairman and it was noted that the fee of N.M. Rothschild was
stil] to be agreed......."

I have told you that I have talked to a number of friends and acquaintances
who have been in a similar pesition to myself in recent times including cone who
has been involved in over a dozen take overs in the space of 12 months! It is
quite clear from those conversations which I had in March that a fiqure well
below five hundred thousand pounds would be what they all thought they would be
able to negotiate with their Banks in a defence of a £200million offer. 1 would
add that although ae number of leacing Banks were involved none was