Tesco Offer for Hillards plc page 9 of 15 previous next
Below is what the machine read from this scan, three times over. They are kept separate rather than merged: where they disagree, the disagreement is itself worth seeing, and a single tidy transcription would hide it.
The left column is raw output. The right is the same text after the repairs that make it searchable — joining letter-spaced words, mending split ones.
Text already in the scan
T E S C O P L C
Lack of sales Sales per square foot 1985/86
Hillards' sales performance compared with its major competitors £1 0
has been deteriorating as a result of failing market share and £8 55
volume. Sales per square foot, an important measure of retail £7 5S
performance, have stagnated and in 1985/6 actually fell. In
contrast, Tesco's sales per square foot have grown strongly. In £5
1985/6, Tesco achieved sales per square foot per week of £9.57,
some 26 per cent, higher than Hillards' figure of £7.59.
Furthermore, Tesco's sales per square foot in Yorkshire are higher
than Hillards' overall.
A worrying performance Hillards M o r r i s o n s T e s c o
This is a performance which gives cause for concern. Source: See Appendix
Hillards' trouble has been;
• the number of competitor openings ".... the Impact of new
• uncompetitive and inconsistent pricing competitors' openings makes It
• inadequate product range Imperative that Hillards discovers a
more profitable trading strategy
• poor merchandising skills quite urgently: retained profit and
• inadequate own label quality negative working capita are
We believe that Hillards will find it increasingly difficult to afford capable of financing less than one
the best sites and to generate adequate returns from them. n e w s t o r e . . . . "
Charterhouse Tilney, Stockbrokers, 24th February, 1987
Too little, too late
The weakness of Hillards' retail brand makes it difficult for it to
reap an adequate return from the investments it has already made,
and to finance the considerable investments which still have to be " . . . . w e w o u l d h a v e s o m e
made in the areas of central distribution, product development, doubts regarding the group's long
quality control, research, marketing and integrated computer term future as an Independent
technology. operator, particularly as 1987/8 Is
The cost of successfully developing a full range of quality own expected to bring a return of the
label products, involving laboratories, food technologists and high level of competitor openings
quality controllers is enormous. seen last year."
These essential investments, together with the refurbishment of Kleinwort Crieveson Securities, Stockbrokers,
existing stores and the opening of three new stores each year will 10th March, 1987.
inevitably weaken Hillards' financial position. The recent rights issue
is clear evidence of the strain on Hillards' balance sheet.
We expect the likely consequences of Hillards' strategy to be Sales per square foot I Hrllards
mounting debt, the jeopardising of its profitability, and £1 0 ' Tcsco
increasingly uncertain returns.
£H
The risks
In summary, we do not believe that Hillards will be able to compete £8
effectively on its own. In an increasingly competitive market it is
short-sighted to try to follow a high cost strategy with a weak £■1
brand. It puts at risk the value of shareholders' investment in the
company as well as the prospects of its employees. £7
Given the poor sales performance demonstrated above, and the
stream of competitor openings, the Hillards board will surely find 1 9 8 2 3 1 9 8 3 A 1 9 8 4 S 1 9 8 5 6
it impossible to give you any meaningful comfort on sales and
profits for next year, let alone for the longer term. Source See Appendix
7TESCOPLC Lack of sales Sales per square foot1985/86 Hillards' sales performance compared with its major competitors £1 0 has been deteriorating as a result of failing market share and £8 55 volume. Sales per square foot, an important measure of retail £7 5S performance, have stagnated and in 1985/6actually fell. In contrast, Tesco's sales per square foot have grown strongly. In £5 1985/6,Tesco achieved sales per square foot per week of £9.57, some 26 per cent, higher than Hillards' figure of £7.59. Furthermore, Tesco's sales per square foot in Yorkshire are higher than Hillards' overall. A worrying performance Hillards MorrisonsTesco This is a performance which gives cause for concern. Source: See Appendix Hillards' trouble has been; • the number of competitor openings".... the Impact of new • uncompetitive and inconsistent pricing competitors' openings makes It • inadequate product range Imperative that Hillards discovers a more profitable trading strategy • poor merchandising skills quite urgently: retained profit and • inadequate own label quality negative working capita are We believe that Hillards will find it increasingly difficult to afford capable of financing less than one the best sites and to generate adequate returns from them. newstore . . . . " Charterhouse Tilney, Stockbrokers, 24th February,1987 Too little, too late The weakness of Hillards' retail brand makes it difficult for it to reap an adequate return from the investments it has already made, and to finance the considerable investments which still have to be " . . . . wewouldhavesome made in the areas of central distribution, product development, doubts regarding the group's long quality control, research, marketing and integrated computer term future as an Independent technology. operator, particularly as 1987/8 Is The cost of successfully developing a full range of quality own expected to bring a return of the label products, involving laboratories, food technologists and high level of competitor openings quality controllers is enormous. seen last year." These essential investments, together with the refurbishment of Kleinwort Crieveson Securities, Stockbrokers, existing stores and the opening of three new stores each year will 10th March,1987. inevitably weaken Hillards' financial position. The recent rights issue is clear evidence of the strain on Hillards' balance sheet. We expect the likely consequences of Hillards' strategy to be Sales per square foot I Hrllards mounting debt, the jeopardising of its profitability, and £1 0 ' Tcsco increasingly uncertain returns. £H The risks In summary, we do not believe that Hillards will be able to compete £8 effectively on its own. In an increasingly competitive market it is short-sighted to try to follow a high cost strategy with a weak£■1 brand. It puts at risk the value of shareholders' investment in the company as well as the prospects of its employees. £7 Given the poor sales performance demonstrated above, and the stream of competitor openings, the Hillards board will surely find 198231983A1984S19856 it impossible to give you any meaningful comfort on sales and profits for next year, let alone for the longer term. Source See Appendix 7
Read by machine highest quality of the three
TESCO PLC
Lack of sales Sales per square foot 1985/86
Hillards’ sales performance compared with its major competitors £10
has been deteriorating as a result of falling market share and
volume. Sales per square foot, an important measure of retail
performance, have stagnated and in 1985/6 actually fell. In
contrast, Tesco’s sales per square foot have grown strongly. In
1985/6, Tesco achieved sales per square foot per week of £9.57, £5
some 26 per cent. higher than Hillards’ figure of £7.59.
Furthermore, Tesco’s sales per square foot in Yorkshire are higher.
than Hillards’ overall.
A worrying performance Hillards Morrisons Tesco
This is a performance which gives cause for concern. Source: See Appendix
Hillards’ trouble has been:
the number of competitor openings ‘ impact of new
uncompetitive and inconsistent pricing competitors’ openings makes it
inadequate product range imperative that Hillards discovers a
merchandising skills more profitable trading strategy
poor quite urgently: retained profit and
inadequate own label quality negative working capital are
We believe that Hillards will find it increasingly difficult to afford capable of financing less than one
the best sites and to generate adequate returns from them. new
Charterhouse Tilney, Stockbrokers, 24th February, 1987
Too little, too late
The weakness of Hillards’ retail brand makes it difficult for it to
reap an adequate return from the investments it has already made,
and to finance the considerable investments which still have to be some
made in the areas of central distribution, product development, .... we would have
doubts regarding the group’s long
quality control, research, marketing and integrated computer term future as an independent
technology. full of quality own operator, particularly as 1987/8 is
The cost of successfully developing a range expected to bring a return of the
label products, involving laboratories, food technologists and high level of competitor openings
quality controllers is enormous. seen last year.”
These essential investments, together with the refurbishment of Kleinwort Grieveson Securities, Stockbrokers,
existing stores and the opening of three new stores each year will 10th March, 1987.
inevitably weaken Hillards’ financial position. The recent rights issue
is clear evidence of the strain on Hillards’ balance sheet.
We expect the likely consequences of Hillards’ strategy to be ss Hillards
mounting debt, the jeopardising of its profitability, and £10 Sales per square foot SS Tesco
increasingly uncertain returns.
£8
The risks
In summary, we do not believe that Hillards will be able to compete £6
effectively on its own. In an increasingly competitive market it Is
short-sighted to try to follow a high cost strategy with a weak £4
brand. It puts at risk the value of shareholders’ investment in the
company as well as the prospects of its employees. £2
Given the poor sales performance demonstrated above, and the
stream of competitor openings, the Hillards board will surely find 0 1982/3 1983/4 1984/5 1985/6
it impossible to give you any meaningful comfort on sales and
profits for next year, let alone for the longer term. Source: See Appendix.TESCO PLC Lack of sales Sales per square foot1985/86 Hillards' sales performance compared with its major competitors£10 has been deteriorating as a result of falling market share and volume. Sales per square foot, an important measure of retail performance, have stagnated and in 1985/6actually fell. In contrast, Tesco's sales per square foot have grown strongly. In 1985/6,Tesco achieved sales per square foot per week of £9.57, £5 some 26 per cent. higher than Hillards' figure of £7.59. Furthermore, Tesco's sales per square foot in Yorkshire are higher. than Hillards' overall. A worrying performance Hillards Morrisons Tesco This is a performance which gives cause for concern. Source: See Appendix Hillards' trouble has been: the number of competitor openings ' impact of new uncompetitive and inconsistent pricing competitors' openings makes it inadequate product range imperative that Hillards discovers a merchandising skills more profitable trading strategy poor quite urgently: retained profit and inadequate own label quality negative working capital are We believe that Hillards will find it increasingly difficult to afford capable of financing less than one the best sites and to generate adequate returns from them. new Charterhouse Tilney, Stockbrokers, 24th February,1987 Too little, too late The weakness of Hillards' retail brand makes it difficult for it to reap an adequate return from the investments it has already made, and to finance the considerable investments which still have to be some made in the areas of central distribution, product development,.... we would have doubts regarding the group's long quality control, research, marketing and integrated computer term future as an independent technology. full of quality own operator, particularly as 1987/8 is The cost of successfully developing a range expected to bring a return of the label products, involving laboratories, food technologists and high level of competitor openings quality controllers is enormous. seen last year." These essential investments, together with the refurbishment of Kleinwort Grieveson Securities, Stockbrokers, existing stores and the opening of three new stores each year will 10th March,1987. inevitably weaken Hillards' financial position. The recent rights issue is clear evidence of the strain on Hillards' balance sheet. We expect the likely consequences of Hillards' strategy to be ss Hillards mounting debt, the jeopardising of its profitability, and £10Sales per square foot SS Tesco increasingly uncertain returns. £8 The risks In summary, we do not believe that Hillards will be able to compete £6 effectively on its own. In an increasingly competitive market it Is short-sighted to try to follow a high cost strategy with a weak £4 brand. It puts at risk the value of shareholders' investment in the company as well as the prospects of its employees. £2 Given the poor sales performance demonstrated above, and the stream of competitor openings, the Hillards board will surely find01982/3 1983/4 1984/5 1985/6 it impossible to give you any meaningful comfort on sales and profits for next year, let alone for the longer term. Source: See Appendix.
Read by machine, contrast corrected
TESCO PLC
Lack of sales Sales per square foot 1985/86
Hillards’ sales performance compared with its major competitors £10
has been deteriorating as a result of falling market share and
volume. Sales per square foot, an important measure of retail
performance, have stagnated and in 1985/6 actually fell. In
contrast, Tesco’s sales per square foot have grown strongly. In
1985/6, Tesco achieved sales per square foot per week of £9.57, £5
some 26 per cent. higher than Hillards’ figure of £7.59.
Furthermore, Tesco’s sales per square foot in Yorkshire are higher.
than Hillards’ overall.
A worrying performance Hillards Morrisons Tesco
This is a performance which gives cause for concern. Source: See Appendix
Hillards’ trouble has been:
the number of competitor openings \ impact of new
uncompetitive and inconsistent pricing competitors’ openings makes it
inadequate product range imperative that Hillards discovers a
merchandising skills more profitable trading strategy
poor quite urgently: retained profit and
inadequate own label quality negative working capital are
We believe that Hillards will find it increasingly difficult to afford capable of financing less than one
the best sites and to generate adequate returns from them. new
Charterhouse Tilney, Stockbrokers, 24th February, 1987
Too little, too late
The weakness of Hillards’ retail brand makes it difficult for it to
reap an adequate return from the investments it has already made,
and to finance the considerable investments which still have to be ww some
made in the areas of central distribution, product development, .... we would have
doubts regarding the group’s long
quality control, research, marketing and integrated computer term future as an independent
technology. full of quality own operator, particularly as 1987/8 is
The cost of successfully developing a range expected to bring a return of the
label products, involving laboratories, food technologists and high level of competitor openings
quality controllers is enormous. seen last year.”
These essential investments, together with the refurbishment of Kleinwort Grieveson Securities, Stockbrokers,
existing stores and the opening of three new stores each year will 10th March, 1987.
inevitably weaken Hillards’ financial position. The recent rights issue
is clear evidence of the strain on Hillards’ balance sheet.
We expect the likely consequences of Hillards’ strategy to be Sales per square foot ss Hillards
mounting debt, the jeopardising of its profitability, and £10 Tesco
increasingly uncertain returns.
£8
The risks
In summary, we do not believe that Hillards will be able to compete £6
effectively on its own. In an increasingly competitive market it Is
short-sighted to try to follow a high cost strategy with a weak f4
brand. It puts at risk the value of shareholders’ investment in the
company as well as the prospects of its employees. £2
Given the poor sales performance demonstrated above, and the
stream of competitor openings, the Hillards board will surely find 0 19823 1983/4 1984/5 1985/6
it impossible to give you any meaningful comfort on sales and
profits for next year, let alone for the longer term. Source: See Appendix.TESCO PLC Lack of sales Sales per square foot1985/86 Hillards' sales performance compared with its major competitors£10 has been deteriorating as a result of falling market share and volume. Sales per square foot, an important measure of retail performance, have stagnated and in 1985/6actually fell. In contrast, Tesco's sales per square foot have grown strongly. In 1985/6,Tesco achieved sales per square foot per week of £9.57, £5 some 26 per cent. higher than Hillards' figure of £7.59. Furthermore, Tesco's sales per square foot in Yorkshire are higher. than Hillards' overall. A worrying performance Hillards Morrisons Tesco This is a performance which gives cause for concern. Source: See Appendix Hillards' trouble has been: the number of competitor openings \ impact of new uncompetitive and inconsistent pricing competitors' openings makes it inadequate product range imperative that Hillards discovers a merchandising skills more profitable trading strategy poor quite urgently: retained profit and inadequate own label quality negative working capital are We believe that Hillards will find it increasingly difficult to afford capable of financing less than one the best sites and to generate adequate returns from them. new Charterhouse Tilney, Stockbrokers, 24th February,1987 Too little, too late The weakness of Hillards' retail brand makes it difficult for it to reap an adequate return from the investments it has already made, and to finance the considerable investments which still have to be ww some made in the areas of central distribution, product development,.... we would have doubts regarding the group's long quality control, research, marketing and integrated computer term future as an independent technology. full of quality own operator, particularly as 1987/8 is The cost of successfully developing a range expected to bring a return of the label products, involving laboratories, food technologists and high level of competitor openings quality controllers is enormous. seen last year." These essential investments, together with the refurbishment of Kleinwort Grieveson Securities, Stockbrokers, existing stores and the opening of three new stores each year will 10th March,1987. inevitably weaken Hillards' financial position. The recent rights issue is clear evidence of the strain on Hillards' balance sheet. We expect the likely consequences of Hillards' strategy to be Sales per square foot ss Hillards mounting debt, the jeopardising of its profitability, and £10Tesco increasingly uncertain returns. £8 The risks In summary, we do not believe that Hillards will be able to compete £6 effectively on its own. In an increasingly competitive market it Is short-sighted to try to follow a high cost strategy with a weak f4 brand. It puts at risk the value of shareholders' investment in the company as well as the prospects of its employees. £2 Given the poor sales performance demonstrated above, and the stream of competitor openings, the Hillards board will surely find019823 1983/4 1984/5 1985/6 it impossible to give you any meaningful comfort on sales and profits for next year, let alone for the longer term. Source: See Appendix.