Hillards takeover

Algorithmic Indexing

387 documents 1,432 pages

Letter to Peter Hartley from Michael Rothschild 07/05/1987   page 1 of 2   next

Scan of page 1 of Letter to Peter Hartley from Michael Rothschild 07/05/1987

Below is what the machine read from this scan, three times over. They are kept separate rather than merged: where they disagree, the disagreement is itself worth seeing, and a single tidy transcription would hide it.

The left column is raw output. The right is the same text after the repairs that make it searchable — joining letter-spaced words, mending split ones.

Text already in the scan

r   N       M    Rothschild     & Sons Limited     PO     Box      No     185
                                                   N e w       C o u r t
                                                   S t S w i t h i n ' s     L a n e
                                                   L o n d o n          E C 4 P 4 D U
                                                   (Registered          Office)
                                                   Telephone            01-280 5000
                                                   Fax 01 -929             1643
    o u r   r e fe r e n c e
                                                   T e l e x   8 8 8 0 3 1
    yo u r       refe re nce                       Dir e c t   L i n e :



            7 t h                                  M a y ,              1 9 8 7









    D e a r     P e t e r ,

                A f t e r o u r             d i s c u s s i o n s         t h i s           m o r n i n g ,    I t h o u g h t      I
    would       write      to              you                    concerning      the     fee            we    propose
    c ha rg i ng             fo r  defe nd i ng                 H i l la rds             f ro m        t he    two        offe rs
    m a d e            b y   Te s c o .        I n  o u r  e a r l i e r               d i s c u s s i o n           w h e n  I
    quoted               a   fee     of         Vz   per        cent          if     we successfully               defended
    Hi l la rds             and     H         pe r  cent            if         we    fai led,        you         said     that         you
    d i d        n o t      l i k e     t h e       c o n c e p t      o f       a     s u c c e s s           r e l a t e d  f e e .  I n
    order             to    meet           your        point,       I     would           propose                charging           %
    per     cent             flat      on       the      value            of       the       bid     whether       Hillards
    i       s s u c c e s s f u l l y       d e f e n d e d         o r     n o t       w h i c h ,  o n         t h e  v a l u e      o f
    t h e       s e c o n d        o f f e r     p r e s e n t l y        t o t a l l i n g   £ 2 0 9 m .           a m o u n t s      t o
    £ 7 8 4 . 0 0 0           e x c l u s i v e        o f      V A T .       O u t       o f     t h i s      f e e , w e      w i l l
    a b s o r b      t h e      c o s t s          a s s o c i a t e d        w i t h     t h e       t w o      o u t s i d e
    c o n s u l t a n t s       e m p l o y e d ,                n a m e l y     B i s s  L a n c a s t e r            a n d
    G o o d h a l l         A l e x a n d e r         O ' H a r e      &      C o .      L t d . ,

               I     k n o w        t h a t     y o u          b e l i e v e     t h a t  s u c h         a    f e e     t o  b e
    h i g h ,    b u t        I    c a n      a s s u r e       y o u      i  t   i  s   w e l l     b e l o w         t h e  l e v e l
    o f       f e e s     c u r r e n t l y         c h a r g e d      b y       b a n k s    w i t h          e x p e r t i s e
    c o m p a r a b l e          t o       o u r   o w n    f o r      t h e      d e f e n c e      o f       a c o m p a n y      o f
    H i l l a r d s '           s i z e    a n d  o f       t h e      d u r a t i o n .      W e         h a v e      m a d e      a
    m a j o r          c o n t r i b u t i o n    t o       t h e      d e f e n c e .        W e         h a v e       c r e a t e d
    t h e       s t r a t e g y     a n d          c o n t r o l l e d        t h e      o r g a n i s a t i o n     f o r      t h e
    d e f e n c e           o f     b o t h        o f f e r s  i    n c o r p o r a t i n g         t w o        p r o fi t
    f o r e c a s t s         a n d         t h r e e        d e t a i l e d      d e f e n c e       d o c u m e n t s .     T h i s
    i       s  q u i t e    a p a r t       f r o m    i n i t i a t i n g        a n d      d r a f t i n g   a          n u m b e r  o f
    p r e s s             r e l e a s e s   a n d      o t h e r     d o c u m e n t s        t o    s h a r e h o l d e r s .
    T h e          e n d    r e s u l t     h a s      b e e n      t h a t       H i l l a r d s    i    s n o w ,        I  t h i n k ,
    i       n a    f a r    s t r o n g e r        p o s i t i o n     t h a t       w o u l d                       b e e n h a v e
    expected                a    few        weeks           ago .










                                                   Registered Number 925279 England
rNM Rothschild & Sons Limited PO Box No 185
NewCourt
StSwithin ' sLane
LondonEC4P4DU
(Registered Office)
Telephone01-2805000
Fax 01 -929 1643
ourre fe rence
Telex888031
yo u r reference Dir ectLine :



7thMay , 1987









DearPeter ,

Afterourdiscussionsthismorning , IthoughtI
would write to you concerning the fee we propose
c ha rg i ng fo r defend i ng Hillards f ro m t he two offers
madeby Tesco. InourearlierdiscussionwhenI
quoted a fee of Vz per cent if we successfully defended
Hi l la rds and H pe r cent if we failed, you said that you
didnotliketheconceptofasuccessrelatedfee . I n
order to meet your point, I would propose charging %
per cent flat on the value of the bid whether Hillards
issuccessfullydefendedornotwhich , onthevalueof
thesecondofferpresentlytotalling£209m . amountsto
£784 . 000exclusiveofVAT . Outofthisfee , wewill
absorbthecostsassociatedwiththetwooutside
consultantsemployed , namelyBissLancasterand
GoodhallAlexanderO ' Hare&Co . Ltd . ,

Iknowthatyoubelievethatsuchafeetobe
high , butIcanassureyouitiswellbelowthelevel
offeescurrentlychargedbybankswithexpertise
comparabletoourownforthedefenceofacompanyof
Hillards ' sizeandoftheduration . Wehavemadea
majorcontributiontothedefence . Wehavecreated
thestrategyandcontrolledtheorganisationforthe
defenceofbothoffersincorporatingtwopro fi t
forecastsandthreedetaileddefencedocuments . This
isquiteapartfrominitiatinganddraftinganumberof
pressreleasesandotherdocumentstoshareholders .
TheendresulthasbeenthatHillardsisnow , Ithink ,
inafarstrongerpositionthatwouldbeenhave
expected a few weeks ago .










Registered Number925279 England

Read by machine highest quality of the three

    N M  Rothschild & Sons Limited     PO Box No 185
                                       New Court
                                       St Swithin’s Lane
                                       London EC4P 4DU

                                       (Registered Office)
                                       Telephone 01-280 5000
                                       Fax 01-929 1643
    our reference                      Telex 888031
    your reference                     Direct Line:



    7th                                May, 1987









    Dear  Peter,

          After     our  discussions           this   morning,    I thought     I
    would   write    to  you   concerning          the fee   we   propose
    charging    for  defending              Hillards  from   the  two   offers
    made  by   Tesco.       In   our         earlier  discussion    when    I
    quoted   a  fee  of    %  per  cent        if  we      successfully  defended
    Hillards    and      per   cent      if    we  failed,   you    said   that  you
    did  not   like  the     concept        of  a  success   related     fee.     In
    order  to   meet     your  point,       I   would  propose      charging    %
    per  cent   flat    on   the      value    of  the bid   whether     Hillards
    is  successfully defended               or  not   which,  on    the  value   of
    the  second     offer         presently    totalling     £209m.   amounts    to
    £784.000    exclusive      of  VAT.           Out  of   this  fee,   we  will
    absorb   the    costs           associated  with    the  two  outside
consultants employed, namely Biss Lancaster and
Goodhall Alexander O'Hare & Co. Ltd.,

          I  know    that    you  believe         that such    a  fee   to  be
    high,   but   I  can   assure       you    it  is  well  below    the   level
of fees currently charged by banks with expertise
    comparable to       our   own  for      the    defence   of   a company     of
    Hillards'      size  and   of  the      duration.        We   have   made   a
    major        contribution  to  the      defence.             have   created We
    the  strategy    and            controlled  the   organisation      for   the
    defence    of   both   offers             incorporating  two  profit
forecasts and three detailed defence documents. This
    is  quite   apart    from    initiating and           drafting    a  number    of
    press      releases  and   other   documents          to  shareholders.
    The  end     result  has   been  that         Hillards    is  now,   I  think,
    in  a far   stronger           position    that   would  have   been
    expected    a   few  weeks    ago.










                              Registered Number 925279 England
                         nee
N M Rothschild & Sons Limited PO Box No 185
New Court
St Swithin's Lane
London EC4P 4DU

(Registered Office)
Telephone01-2805000
Fax 01-929 1643
our reference Telex888031
your reference Direct Line:



7th May, 1987









Dear Peter,

After our discussions this morning, I thought I
would write to you concerning the fee we propose
charging for defending Hillards from the two offers
made by Tesco. In our earlier discussion when I
quoted a fee of % per cent if we successfully defended
Hillards and per cent if we failed, you said that you
did not like the concept of a success related fee. In
order to meet your point, I would propose charging %
per cent flat on the value of the bid whether Hillards
is successfully defended or not which, on the value of
the second offer presently totalling £209m. amounts to
£784.000exclusive of VAT. Out of this fee, we will
absorb the costs associated with the two outside
consultants employed, namely Biss Lancaster and
Goodhall Alexander O'Hare & Co. Ltd.,

I know that you believe that such a fee to be
high, but I can assure you it is well below the level
of fees currently charged by banks with expertise
comparable to our own for the defence of a company of
Hillards' size and of the duration. We have made a
major contribution to the defence. have created We
the strategy and controlled the organisation for the
defence of both offers incorporating two profit
forecasts and three detailed defence documents. This
is quite apart from initiating and drafting a number of
press releases and other documents to shareholders.
The end result has been that Hillards is now, I think,
in a far stronger position that would have been
expected a few weeks ago.










Registered Number925279 England
nee

Read by machine, contrast corrected

    N M  Rothschild & Sons Limited     PO Box No 185
                                       New Court
                                       St Swithin’s Lane
                                       London EC4P 4DU

                                       (Registered Office)
                                       Telephone 01-280 5000
                                       Fax 01-929 1643
    our reference                      Telex 888031
    your reference                     Direct Line:



    7th                                May, 1987









    Dear  Peter,

          After     our  discussions           this   morning,    I thought     I
    would   write    to  you   concerning          the fee   we   propose
    charging    for  defending              Hillards  from   the  two   offers
    made  by   Tesco.       In   our         earlier  discussion    when    I
    quoted   a  fee  of    %  per  cent        if  we      successfully  defended
    Hillards    and      per   cent      if    we  failed,   you    said   that  you
    did  not   like  the     concept        of  a  success   related     fee.     In
    order  to   meet     your  point,       I   would  propose      charging    %
    per  cent   flat    on   the      value    of  the bid   whether     Hillards
    is  successfully defended               or  not   which,  on    the  value   of
    the  second     offer         presently    totalling     £209m.   amounts    to
    £784.000    exclusive      of  VAT.           Out  of   this  fee,   we  will
    absorb   the    costs           associated  with    the  two  outside
consultants employed, namely Biss Lancaster and
Goodhall Alexander O'Hare & Co. Ltd.,

          I  know    that    you  believe         that such    a  fee   to  be
    high,   but   I  can   assure       you    it  is  well  below    the   level
of fees currently charged by banks with expertise
    comparable to       our   own  for      the    defence   of   a company     of
    Hillards'      size  and   of  the      duration.        We   have   made   a
    major        contribution  to  the      defence.             have   created We
    the  strategy    and            controlled  the   organisation      for   the
    defence    of   both   offers             incorporating  two  profit
forecasts and three detailed defence documents. This
    is  quite   apart    from    initiating and           drafting    a  number    of
    press      releases  and   other   documents          to  shareholders.
    The  end     result  has   been  that         Hillards    is  now,   I  think,
    in  a far   stronger           position    that   would  have   been
    expected    a   few  weeks    ago.










                              Registered Number 925279 England
                         nee
N M Rothschild & Sons Limited PO Box No 185
New Court
St Swithin's Lane
London EC4P 4DU

(Registered Office)
Telephone01-2805000
Fax 01-929 1643
our reference Telex888031
your reference Direct Line:



7th May, 1987









Dear Peter,

After our discussions this morning, I thought I
would write to you concerning the fee we propose
charging for defending Hillards from the two offers
made by Tesco. In our earlier discussion when I
quoted a fee of % per cent if we successfully defended
Hillards and per cent if we failed, you said that you
did not like the concept of a success related fee. In
order to meet your point, I would propose charging %
per cent flat on the value of the bid whether Hillards
is successfully defended or not which, on the value of
the second offer presently totalling £209m. amounts to
£784.000exclusive of VAT. Out of this fee, we will
absorb the costs associated with the two outside
consultants employed, namely Biss Lancaster and
Goodhall Alexander O'Hare & Co. Ltd.,

I know that you believe that such a fee to be
high, but I can assure you it is well below the level
of fees currently charged by banks with expertise
comparable to our own for the defence of a company of
Hillards' size and of the duration. We have made a
major contribution to the defence. have created We
the strategy and controlled the organisation for the
defence of both offers incorporating two profit
forecasts and three detailed defence documents. This
is quite apart from initiating and drafting a number of
press releases and other documents to shareholders.
The end result has been that Hillards is now, I think,
in a far stronger position that would have been
expected a few weeks ago.










Registered Number925279 England
nee