Hillards takeover

Algorithmic Indexing

387 documents 1,432 pages

Letter to Shareholders 29/04/1987   page 2 of 2   previous

Scan of page 2 of Letter to Shareholders 29/04/1987

Below is what the machine read from this scan, three times over. They are kept separate rather than merged: where they disagree, the disagreement is itself worth seeing, and a single tidy transcription would hide it.

The left column is raw output. The right is the same text after the repairs that make it searchable — joining letter-spaced words, mending split ones.

Text already in the scan

                                    H i i i a r d s / T e s c o :       r o i n t s             f o r       L h e       P r e s s
                                             o u e r     u i e e k      e n d i n g        S u n d a y      3 r d  M a v

    H l l l a r d s             i   s        i n    a    s t r o n g  g r o u i t h  p h a s e
    *               £ 1 5  m i l l i o n         p r o f i t         f o r e c a s t   f o r                1 9 8 7 / 8 8
    *               1 9 8 8 / 8 9            - £ 2           m i l l i o n      f   r o m         c e n t r a l    d i s t r i     b u t i o n
                                          n e w                     s t o r e s     o p e n i n g
                                 -  e x p a n s i o n                   o f         s a l e s       a r e a      d e u o t e d         t o       h i g h e r
                                                 m a r g i n                  g o o d s

    T h e   Te s c o  o f f e r                          i    s   m e a n   :        i t     d o e s     n o t     r e c o g n i s e     t h e       t r u e
    u a l u e  o f                  H l l l a r d s '           i n d e p e n d e n c e
    *               H l l l     a r d s         h a s  f         o r e c a s t   a     4 5         % p r o fi t     in c r e a s e            -    y e t  t h e
    "                    c a s h            o f f e r      h a s    b e e n      I n c r e a s e d        o n l y   1 8 %
                    T C C C C i ' O          C       h e i r   0    h o    I d   S     r     S  v J Z l l    b ?    b h l -    t o
                         gluing                        Tesco   cheap     access                 to       a   market         they                 haue
                         f a i l      e d      I n .   (    S e e        n o t e )

    Te s c o                 h a u e               c l e a r l y    u n d e r p i t c h e d         t h e       o f f e r   -      a n d      i  t  i s   t o o
    l            a t e   t o     r a i s e       I t         a g a i n .

                                                                 p- i r t r * i n^     l i p   m i l r h  Q f n r  1^      - i n   f h p     m n r k p f  -
                         w e l l      u n d e r          1      m i l l i o n       s h a r e s        o n   t h e      d a y      o f    t h e
                         I n c r e a s e d               o f f e r .     T h i s          i s  u e r y      p o o r .
                         T h e r e             I s  i      n s t i t u t i o n a l     r e l u c t a n c e       t o     a b a n d o n           a
                         management                            that has             performed               well        ouer           the         years  and
                         h a s             c r e a t e d       1 6       y e a r s   o f      s h a r e h o l d e r      u a l u e
                         t h e      f a m i l y          :     t h e r e     i  s    n o      r e a s o n      t o  s u p p o s e             t h e   l e v e l
                         w f  h a s                  • :          h w f - ' O r " * !
                         £ 1 0 0          i  n v e s t e d          I n  H l l l a r d s       t e n     y e a r s      a g o        w a s       w o r t h
                         £1922                 just         before             the     bid      -       as   against            only          £1420          at
                         T e s c o .

    M o t . P '     M a r k i o f           R h a r e    -      T e s c o ' s       Y o r k s h i r e       f a i l u r e

    Tesco                    has                        quoted  figures             for      Yorkshire           market           shares             which
    are                 selectlue                          and    misleading.                  If   one          takes         a  two                 year
    ulew                   -    longer           than               the     Tesco                      timespan      -   one      will           see      that:
    *               Te s c o ' s                 m a r k e t    s h a r e       h a s        f a l l e n       f r o m   3 . 2 %         t o     2 . 9 %
                 *  H i l l(ao  rud ser   '     1 0 %    d e c l i n e )
                                               m a r k e t          s h a r e        h a s        r      e m a i n e d      s t a b l e       -
                        c o n s i s t a n t              w i t h       i t s    e m p h a s i s     o n             m a x i m i s i n g
                         p r o fi t a b i l i t y              w h i l s t      a l s o       e x p a n d i n g      b e y o n d             Yo r k s h i r e ,

                 S o u r c e :        t h e    s a m e         A G B     d a t a       t h a t    Te s c o       h a s b e e n         q u o t i n g






    i i  i w /       N H /   S y / / A       A
2 8 t h          A p r i l   1 9 8 7
Hiiiards / Tesco : rointsforLhePress
oueruieekendingSunday3rdMav

Hlllardsisinastronggrouithphase
* £15millionprofitforecastfor1987 / 8 8
* 1988 / 8 9 - £2millionfromcentraldistribution
newstoresopening
- expansionofsalesareadeuotedtohigher
margingoods

The Te scoofferismean : itdoesnotrecognisethetrue
ualueofHlllards ' independence
* Hlllardshasforecasta45 % pro fi t in crease - yetthe
" cashofferhasbeenIncreasedonly18 %
TCCCCi ' OCheir0hoIdSrSvJZllb ? bhl - t o
gluing Tesco cheap access to a market they haue
failedIn . ( Seenote )

Te scohaueclearlyunderpitchedtheoffer - anditistoo
latetoraiseItagain .

p- irtr * i n^ lipmilrhQfnr 1^ - infhpmnrkpf -
wellunder1millionsharesonthedayofthe
Increasedoffer . Thisisuerypoor .
ThereIsinstitutionalreluctancetoabandona
management that has performed well ouer the years and
hascreated16yearsofshareholderualue
thefamily : thereisnoreasontosupposethelevel
wfhas • : hwf - ' O r " * !
£100investedInHlllardstenyearsagowasworth
£1922just before the bid - as against only£1420 at
Tesco .

Mot . P ' MarkiofRhare - Tesco ' sYorkshirefailure

Tesco has quoted figures for Yorkshire market shares which
are selectlue and misleading. If one takes a two year
ulew - longer than the Tesco timespan - one will see that:
*Tesco ' smarketsharehasfallenfrom3 . 2 % to2 . 9 %
* Hil l(ao rud ser ' 1 0 % decline )
marketsharehasremainedstable -
consistantwithitsemphasisonmaximising
pro fi tabilitywhilstalsoexpandingbeyond Yorkshire,

Source : thesameAGBdatathat Te scohasbeenquoting






iiiw / N H / S y / / A A
28thApril1987

Read by machine highest quality of the three

                   Hilliards/Tesco:             Points  for   the     Press
                        over    week      ending     Sunday   3rd     May

 1.   Hillards     is   ina        strong   growth      phase
      *     £15    million         profit   forecast     for       1987/88
      ad    1988/89         £2          million  from        central distribution
                     ~      new        stores    opening
                     -      expansion           of   sales      area devoted   to  higher
                            margin           goods

 2.   The  Tesco     offer      is     mean :    it    does  not     recognise  the true
      value of     Hillards'           independence

      *     Hillards     has        forecast       a   45%   profit   increase    ~ yet  the
            cash     offer      has    been     increased     only    18%
            Tesco                   oe    Taare  wid    Inn   bras  Anes  tn
                                                     —
            giving      Tesco      cheap    access      to  a     market  they  have
            failed      in.     (See      note)

 3,   Tesco have        clearly        underpitched       the offer     -  and  it  is  too
      late  to     raise it        again.

      *                 ana     mnt    miebing     unm  mich  ctack    in  the  market   —
            well     under      1   million      shares    on  the    day  of  the
            increased       offer.            This   is  very  poor.
      ad    There       is           institutional   reluctance     to   abandon    a
     management that has performed well over the years and
            has    created         15            of    shareholder     value
            the                        years
 x                 family       :  there    is     no reason       to suppose   the  level
 c                      eer ht         change
            wt                         Ora       a
            £100     invested          in Hillards      ten   years    ago  was    worth
     just before the bid =~ ay against only £21420 at
     Tesco.


 Note:    Markat Share   -  Tasco's         Yorkshire       failure
e      Tesco   has   quoted        figures  for   Yorkshire      market    shares   which
       are   selective   and       misleading.           If one  takes  a  two  year
       view  -  longer   than          the Tesco  timespan       - one  will    see that:

       *     Tesco's market            share  has    fallen     from 3.2%   to  2.9%
             (over   10%    dacline)
       *     Hillards'      market         share     has remained    stable  —-
     consistant with its emphasis on maximising
     profitability whilet aleo expanding beyond Yorkshire.

     Source: the same AGB data that Tesco has been quoting.






 28th  April 1967                                _- Ta        €€ ME
Hilliards/Tesco: Points for the Press
over week ending Sunday 3rd May

1. Hillards is ina strong growth phase
*£15million profit forecast for 1987/88
ad 1988/89£2million from central distribution
~ new stores opening
- expansion of sales area devoted to higher
margin goods

2. The Tesco offer is mean : it does not recognise the true
value of Hillards' independence

* Hillards has forecast a 45%profit increase ~ yet the
cash offer has been increased only18%
Tesco oe Taare wid Inn bras Anes tn
-
giving Tesco cheap access to a market they have
failed in. (See note)

3, Tesco have clearly underpitched the offer - and it is too
late to raise it again.

* ana mnt miebing unm mich ctack in the market -
well under 1 million shares on the day of the
increased offer. This is very poor.
ad There is institutional reluctance to abandon a
management that has performed well over the years and
has created 15 of shareholder value
the years
x family : there is no reason to suppose the level
c eer ht change
wt Ora a
£100invested in Hillards ten years ago was worth
just before the bid =~ ay against only£21420 at
Tesco.


Note: Markat Share - Tasco's Yorkshire failure
e Tesco has quoted figures for Yorkshire market shares which
are selective and misleading. If one takes a two year
view - longer than the Tesco timespan - one will see that:

* Tesco's market share has fallen from3.2% to 2.9%
(over10% dacline)
* Hillards' market share has remained stable --
consistant with its emphasis on maximising
profitability whilet aleo expanding beyond Yorkshire.

Source: the same AGB data that Tesco has been quoting.






28th April1967_- Ta €€ ME

Read by machine, contrast corrected

                   Hilliards/Tesco:             Points  for   the     Press
                        over    week      ending     Sunday   3rd     May

 1.   Hillards     is   ina        strong   growth      phase
      *     £15    million         profit   forecast     for       1987/88
      ad    1988/89         £2          million  from        central distribution
                     ~      new        stores    opening
                     -      expansion           of   sales      area devoted   to  higher
                            margin           goods

 2.   The  Tesco     offer      is     mean :    it    does  not     recognise  the true
      value of     Hillards'           independence

      *     Hillards     has        forecast       a   45%   profit   increase    ~ yet  the
            cash     offer      has    been     increased     only    18%
            Tesco                   oe    Taare  wid    Inn   bras  Anes  tn
                                                     —
            giving      Tesco      cheap    access      to  a     market  they  have
            failed      in.     (See      note)

 3,   Tesco have        clearly        underpitched       the offer     -  and  it  is  too
      late  to     raise it        again.

      *                 ana     mnt    miebing     unm  mich  ctack    in  the  market   —
            well     under      1   million      shares    on  the    day  of  the
            increased       offer.            This   is  very  poor.
      ad    There       is           institutional   reluctance     to   abandon    a
     management that has performed well over the years and
            has    created         15            of    shareholder     value
            the                        years
 x                 family       :  there    is     no reason       to suppose   the  level
 c                      eer ht         change
            wt                         Ora       a
            £100     invested          in Hillards      ten   years    ago  was    worth
     just before the bid =~ ay against only £21420 at
     Tesco.


 Note:    Markat Share   -  Tasco's         Yorkshire       failure
e      Tesco   has   quoted        figures  for   Yorkshire      market    shares   which
       are   selective   and       misleading.           If one  takes  a  two  year
       view  -  longer   than          the Tesco  timespan       - one  will    see that:

       *     Tesco's market            share  has    fallen     from 3.2%   to  2.9%
             (over   10%    dacline)
       *     Hillards'      market         share     has remained    stable  —-
     consistant with its emphasis on maximising
     profitability whilet aleo expanding beyond Yorkshire.

     Source: the same AGB data that Tesco has been quoting.






 28th  April 1967                                _- Ta        €€ ME
Hilliards/Tesco: Points for the Press
over week ending Sunday 3rd May

1. Hillards is ina strong growth phase
*£15million profit forecast for 1987/88
ad 1988/89£2million from central distribution
~ new stores opening
- expansion of sales area devoted to higher
margin goods

2. The Tesco offer is mean : it does not recognise the true
value of Hillards' independence

* Hillards has forecast a 45%profit increase ~ yet the
cash offer has been increased only18%
Tesco oe Taare wid Inn bras Anes tn
-
giving Tesco cheap access to a market they have
failed in. (See note)

3, Tesco have clearly underpitched the offer - and it is too
late to raise it again.

* ana mnt miebing unm mich ctack in the market -
well under 1 million shares on the day of the
increased offer. This is very poor.
ad There is institutional reluctance to abandon a
management that has performed well over the years and
has created 15 of shareholder value
the years
x family : there is no reason to suppose the level
c eer ht change
wt Ora a
£100invested in Hillards ten years ago was worth
just before the bid =~ ay against only£21420 at
Tesco.


Note: Markat Share - Tasco's Yorkshire failure
e Tesco has quoted figures for Yorkshire market shares which
are selective and misleading. If one takes a two year
view - longer than the Tesco timespan - one will see that:

* Tesco's market share has fallen from3.2% to 2.9%
(over10% dacline)
* Hillards' market share has remained stable --
consistant with its emphasis on maximising
profitability whilet aleo expanding beyond Yorkshire.

Source: the same AGB data that Tesco has been quoting.






28th April1967_- Ta €€ ME