Hillards takeover

Algorithmic Indexing

387 documents 1,432 pages

Why Hillards should remain independent report   page 13 of 53   previous   next

Scan of page 13 of Why Hillards should remain independent report

Below is what the machine read from this scan, three times over. They are kept separate rather than merged: where they disagree, the disagreement is itself worth seeing, and a single tidy transcription would hide it.

The left column is raw output. The right is the same text after the repairs that make it searchable — joining letter-spaced words, mending split ones.

Text already in the scan

1 1:4 3    P .0 1 5



W HY T ESCQ'S O F F E R IS M ISCO NC F.TV F.D


Tesco has failed to expand effectively in Yorkshire. The offer is designed simply to
acquire market share and sales space at a discount price. Tesco has provided no evidence
whatsoever that it would be more effective at managing Hillards. It has given no
assurance that its offer for Hillards would not result in substantial redundancies where
Hillards' and Tesco's stores, distribution and clerical functions overlap.

Not only are Tesco's plan.$ vague, but their claims are misleading.
Tesco claims that 'Hillards long-term future is more secure with Tesco'. But, as this
document has demonstrated, the future at Hillards is secure. We have 101 years of
success as an independent regional retailer and have developed the strategy and made the
investments for this success to continue in the future.

Tesco also claims to be able to 'generate higher sales and profits in Hillards' stores.'
Tesco's performance, compared to that of Hillards, in the Yorkshire TV region, suggests
otherwise. Tesco does have an established presence in the region - an estimated 332,000
square sales area, equivalent to 57% of Hillards sales area in the same region.
Despite this, Tesco has under 45% of Hillards' market share in packaged groceries.


S A U S A a E A I N T H E     MARKSr SHARE OF PACKAOEO GROCHRgK
VO RKSH IS ETV RSXilON        IN THSVOmSMIRE-rV REGION

573.000 jqfl




333,000 M ft








Hlllar^

HifHarris UnaHUoBlp inif      Vfirtf ^.l U F P TV/AGW ^»i
Di§tribution


a    n u - a a o ^ o    a a a    a s a a u '    ^    r    a .    a . a n a - s . a a u > a .
newer, larger and carry a wider range of products.

    14
1 1:4 3 P .0 1 5



W HY T ESCQ'S OFFER IS M ISCO NC F.TV F.D


Tesco has failed to expand effectively in Yorkshire. The offer is designed simply to
acquire market share and sales space at a discount price. Tesco has provided no evidence
whatsoever that it would be more effective at managing Hillards. It has given no
assurance that its offer for Hillards would not result in substantial redundancies where
Hillards' and Tesco's stores, distribution and clerical functions overlap.

Not only are Tesco's plan.$ vague, but their claims are misleading.
Tesco claims that 'Hillards long-term future is more secure with Tesco'. But, as this
document has demonstrated, the future at Hillards is secure. We have101 years of
success as an independent regional retailer and have developed the strategy and made the
investments for this success to continue in the future.

Tesco also claims to be able to 'generate higher sales and profits in Hillards' stores.'
Tesco's performance, compared to that of Hillards, in the Yorkshire TV region, suggests
otherwise. Tesco does have an established presence in the region - an estimated332,000
square sales area, equivalent to 57% of Hillards sales area in the same region.
Despite this, Tesco has under45% of Hillards' market share in packaged groceries.


SAUSAaEAINTHE MARKSr SHARE OF PACKAOEO GROCHRgK
VO RKSH IS ETV RSXilON IN THSVOmSMIRE-rV REGION

573.000 jqfl




333,000 M ft








Hlllar^

HifHarris UnaHUoBlp inif Vfirtf ^.l UFP TV/AGW ^»i
Di§tribution


anu - aao ^ oaaaasaau ' ^ r a . a . ana - s . aau > a .
newer, larger and carry a wider range of products.

14

Read by machine highest quality of the three

    11:43    P.@15  Ne
        HILLARDS plc J


    WHY TESCO’S OFFER IS MISCONCEIVED



 Tesco has failed to expand effectively in Yorkshire. The offer is designed simply to
acquire market share and sales space at a discount price. Tesco has provided no evidence
whatsoever that it would be more effective at managing Hillards, It has given no
    assurance that its  offer for Hillards would  not  result in substantial redundancies where
Hillards’ and Tesco’s stores, distribution and clerical functions overlap.
Not only are Tesco’s plans vague, but their claims are misleading.
    Tesco claims  that  ‘Hillards long-term future is  more   secure with Tesco’. But, as  this
    document has demonstrated,         the future at Hillards is secure. We have  101 years  of
    success as an independent regional retailer and have   developed the  strategy and made the
    investments   for this success to  continue in the future,

Tesco also claims to be able to ‘generate higher sales and profits in Hillards’ stores.’
Tesco’s performance, compared to that of Hillards, inthe Yorkshire TV region, suggests
    otherwise. Tesco does have an     established presence in the region ~ an estimated 332,000
        of
square £66t sales area, equivalent to 57% of Hillards sales area in the same region.
Despite this, Tesco has under 45% of Hillards’ market share in packaged groceries.


         SALES AREA    THE                       MARKET SHARE OF PACKAGED
         YORKSHIRE  TV REGION            |   |   INTHE  TV REGION     GROCERIES
                                         |
         573,000        sq ft
                                         |   |

                            Estimate     |
    '                       332,000 sq ft


                                               |                     2.0%

                                       |   |                       |
                                                                   t
        chee adh                                                  ps ee
    |    Hillards       Tesco              |           Hillards      Tesco
    |        Hillards   Institute of       i                         TY/AGR Survey
    |    Grocery Distribution              |


This is not surprising, In this highly competitive region Hillards stores are generally
newer, larger and carry a wider range of products.
11:43 P.@15 Ne
HILLARDS plc J


WHY TESCO'S OFFER IS MISCONCEIVED



Tesco has failed to expand effectively in Yorkshire. The offer is designed simply to
acquire market share and sales space at a discount price. Tesco has provided no evidence
whatsoever that it would be more effective at managing Hillards, It has given no
assurance that its offer for Hillards would not result in substantial redundancies where
Hillards' and Tesco's stores, distribution and clerical functions overlap.
Not only are Tesco's plans vague, but their claims are misleading.
Tesco claims that 'Hillards long-term future is more secure with Tesco'. But, as this
document has demonstrated, the future at Hillards is secure. We have101 years of
success as an independent regional retailer and have developed the strategy and made the
investments for this success to continue in the future,

Tesco also claims to be able to 'generate higher sales and profits in Hillards' stores.'
Tesco's performance, compared to that of Hillards, inthe Yorkshire TV region, suggests
otherwise. Tesco does have an established presence in the region ~ an estimated332,000
of
square £66t sales area, equivalent to 57% of Hillards sales area in the same region.
Despite this, Tesco has under45% of Hillards' market share in packaged groceries.


SALES AREA THE MARKET SHARE OF PACKAGED
YORKSHIRE TV REGION | | INTHE TV REGION GROCERIES
|
573,000 sq ft
| |

Estimate |
' 332,000 sq ft


| 2.0%

| | |
t
chee adh ps ee
| Hillards Tesco | Hillards Tesco
| Hillards Institute of i TY/AGR Survey
| Grocery Distribution |


This is not surprising, In this highly competitive region Hillards stores are generally
newer, larger and carry a wider range of products.

Read by machine, contrast corrected

    11:43    P.@15  Ne
        HILLARDS plc J


    WHY TESCO’S OFFER IS MISCONCEIVED



 Tesco has failed to expand effectively in Yorkshire. The offer is designed simply to
acquire market share and sales space at a discount price. Tesco has provided no evidence
whatsoever that it would be more effective at managing Hillards, It has given no
    assurance that its  offer for Hillards would  not  result in substantial redundancies where
Hillards’ and Tesco’s stores, distribution and clerical functions overlap.
Not only are Tesco’s plans vague, but their claims are misleading.
    Tesco claims  that  ‘Hillards long-term future is  more   secure with Tesco’. But, as  this
    document has demonstrated,         the future at Hillards is secure. We have  101 years  of
    success as an independent regional retailer and have   developed the  strategy and made the
    investments   for this success to  continue in the future,

Tesco also claims to be able to ‘generate higher sales and profits in Hillards’ stores.’
Tesco’s performance, compared to that of Hillards, inthe Yorkshire TV region, suggests
    otherwise. Tesco does have an     established presence in the region ~ an estimated 332,000
        of
square £66t sales area, equivalent to 57% of Hillards sales area in the same region.
Despite this, Tesco has under 45% of Hillards’ market share in packaged groceries.


         SALES AREA    THE                       MARKET SHARE OF PACKAGED
         YORKSHIRE  TV REGION            |   |   INTHE  TV REGION     GROCERIES
                                         |
         573,000        sq ft
                                         |   |

                            Estimate     |
    '                       332,000 sq ft


                                               |                     2.0%

                                       |   |                       |
                                                                   t
        chee adh                                                  ps ee
    |    Hillards       Tesco              |           Hillards      Tesco
    |        Hillards   Institute of       i                         TY/AGR Survey
    |    Grocery Distribution              |


This is not surprising, In this highly competitive region Hillards stores are generally
newer, larger and carry a wider range of products.
11:43 P.@15 Ne
HILLARDS plc J


WHY TESCO'S OFFER IS MISCONCEIVED



Tesco has failed to expand effectively in Yorkshire. The offer is designed simply to
acquire market share and sales space at a discount price. Tesco has provided no evidence
whatsoever that it would be more effective at managing Hillards, It has given no
assurance that its offer for Hillards would not result in substantial redundancies where
Hillards' and Tesco's stores, distribution and clerical functions overlap.
Not only are Tesco's plans vague, but their claims are misleading.
Tesco claims that 'Hillards long-term future is more secure with Tesco'. But, as this
document has demonstrated, the future at Hillards is secure. We have101 years of
success as an independent regional retailer and have developed the strategy and made the
investments for this success to continue in the future,

Tesco also claims to be able to 'generate higher sales and profits in Hillards' stores.'
Tesco's performance, compared to that of Hillards, inthe Yorkshire TV region, suggests
otherwise. Tesco does have an established presence in the region ~ an estimated332,000
of
square £66t sales area, equivalent to 57% of Hillards sales area in the same region.
Despite this, Tesco has under45% of Hillards' market share in packaged groceries.


SALES AREA THE MARKET SHARE OF PACKAGED
YORKSHIRE TV REGION | | INTHE TV REGION GROCERIES
|
573,000 sq ft
| |

Estimate |
' 332,000 sq ft


| 2.0%

| | |
t
chee adh ps ee
| Hillards Tesco | Hillards Tesco
| Hillards Institute of i TY/AGR Survey
| Grocery Distribution |


This is not surprising, In this highly competitive region Hillards stores are generally
newer, larger and carry a wider range of products.