Hillards takeover

Algorithmic Indexing

387 documents 1,432 pages

Note of a conversation with Barbara Muston on 11/05/1987   page 1 of 1

Scan of page 1 of Note of a conversation with Barbara Muston on 11/05/1987

Below is what the machine read from this scan, three times over. They are kept separate rather than merged: where they disagree, the disagreement is itself worth seeing, and a single tidy transcription would hide it.

The left column is raw output. The right is the same text after the repairs that make it searchable — joining letter-spaced words, mending split ones.

Text already in the scan

    M fi Y - 1 2 - ' 8 7 1 2 : 0 6 I D : N M R C O R P F I N    T E L N O : 0 1 - 6 2 6 0 7 9 9    t t 2 4 8 P 0 2







    F I L E N O T E

    c c :   M J d e R R
            P M S
            N i g e l W i g g i n s
            M a l c o l m T h o m s o n



                                                                               H i L L f t R D S

                                                     N o t e        o f    a                          c o n u e r s a t i o n    u j i t h
                                 B a r b a r a                M u s t o n _ o n _  M o n d a y / .                   l      l    t h   M a v .      1 9 8 7
            Barbara              Muston                       rang       on    the                           following           two                       matters:
        1.  The  Panel had                      accepted                    the       point        that                          we     made  the                                  preuious
            Friday,     namely                       that           David Reid of                  Tesco                                        should        be
            reprimanded              for                      making the                                     statement                          appearing        in     the       •
            Western              Mail,               concerning            the                     likely                        fall   in              the     share             price
            of   Hlllards            if                    the  bid            failed.         County                            Bank                   had     been                   told
            by   the              Panel    that                 David             Reid         had              to               be    very careful                         as           to
            w h a t   h e        s a i d   i    n             t h e      f u t u r e .
        2. Barbara                     Muston        was particularly                              concerned                                about                statements
            made by Peter Hartley which were quoted in the                                                                                                       Yorkshire
            Post     on          Saturday,                          yth                              May, as                                     comments     h e       m a d e       i   n
            the  BBC programme 'Look                                                North'         on 8th May.                                         Th               r e l a t e s     t o
            unsubstantiated levels of support Thr^orksh                                                                                                       s
            article mentioned continuing support from shp                                                                                                     f e i  P o s t
            had not written in and on the BBC programme r.                                                                                                    >      l   d e r s      w h o
                                                                                                                                                                . - r e  n c e        w a s
            made  to             institutions                             indicating                                    their    contln.                         s u p p o r t
            Barbara                     Muston                said     that         this               was   contrary                                         o t e          2    o f .
            Rule 20 of               the             Code           and        the                   Panel   took                                serloo'?     e  x c e p t i o n          t o
            the statements^ They requested that a pre., au,.v.
                                                                                                                                     press                                     announcement
                                                                clarifying             the         level                             of     support,
            includang                      the                leuel       of        titutional                       support.                         Muston
            further             u/ent on to                         say that if                                                        p^^er Hartley,     or                      anyone at
            H i l l a r d s      o r i     t s                advisers,             made           any                 further                  statements
                                                              a d v i s e r s ,
            a^ru^suSstant^a^ed^bJ^on?^^^^                                '
                                                                            ^       "^irrnations, then                                                the     Panel,              if
            asked     7®sco                     would                     b e       Prepaf^^^j                         extend                                    closin
                                                                                    P r e p a f . g ( j                e x t e n d                     t h e     c l o s i n
            d a t e                o f                        t h e       p a n e l                        T h     t   h a te           P a n e                      b e f o c r          y
                                                                         ■   c      o n c e r      n     i n g                   l e v e l s          o f     s u p          p c
                     f ®                             o                     n   i          l        e     v                  e                 o f                           p
     t h e y w o u l d h a v e t o b e cit^ared
        c l t ^ a r e d fthrough them first.
        the P a n e l are very concerned about this and we must
    ensure that                                     no further  statements                                                                              are made which are not
    capable         of     being                substantiated,                                 Panel                   did                           make     one                    further
    point.       and- that was             c  we               p                                              sa^J ® dropping           off     levels                  V
                                                                                                                   y i i r  i        u
                                                r o p           i n g                   O f f    O
    support    I we should  I                   also «                        announcef        that,>                o               o f      l O M O l S               I    f
    e                                      t f i         n                            U I P        i               ^ said               to_                       Barbara,      A     Muston
A . . _ i _
    the nature of the supporters' hut, 4,^                                                                this                                                                         given
                                                                                                   would note the point.

    N21/10/JftGy/kw/8120J
M fi Y - 1 2 - ' 8712 : 06ID : NMRCORPFINTELNO : 0 1 - 6260799tt248P02







FILENOTE

c c : MJdeRR
PMS
NigelWiggins
MalcolmThomson



HiLLftRDS

Noteofaconuersationujith
BarbaraMuston _ o n _ Monday / . llthMav . 1987
Barbara Muston rang on the following two matters:
1. The Panel had accepted the point that we made the preuious
Friday, namely that David Reid of Tesco should be
reprimanded for making the statement appearing in the •
Western Mail, concerning the likely fall in the share price
of Hlllards if the bid failed. County Bank had been told
by the Panel that David Reid had to be very careful as to
whathesaidinthefuture .
2. Barbara Muston was particularly concerned about statements
made by Peter Hartley which were quoted in the Yorkshire
Post on Saturday, yth May, as comments hemadein
the BBC programme 'Look North' on 8th May. Th relatesto
unsubstantiated levels of support Thr^orksh s
article mentioned continuing support from shp feiPost
had not written in and on the BBC programme r. > lderswho
. - rencewas
made to institutions indicating their contln. support
Barbara Muston said that this was contrary ote2of .
Rule 20 of the Code and the Panel took serloo'? exceptionto
the statements^ They requested that a pre., au,.v.
press announcement
clarifying the level of support,
includang the leuel of titutional support. Muston
further u/ent on to say that if p^^er Hartley, or anyone at
Hillardsorits advisers, made any further statements
advisers ,
a^ru^suSstant^a^ed^bJ^on?^^^^ '
^ "^irrnations, then the Panel, if
asked 7®sco would b e Prepaf^^^j extend closin
Prepaf . g ( jextendtheclosin
dateofthepanelThtha te Panebefocry
■ concerninglevelsofsuppc
f ® onileveofp
theywouldhavetobe cit^ared
clt ^ ared fthrough them first.
the Panel are very concerned about this and we must
ensure that no further statements are made which are not
capable of being substantiated, Panel did make one further
point. and- that was c we p sa^J ® dropping off levels V
yiiriu
ropingOffO
support I we should I also « announcef that,> ooflOMOlSIf
etfinUIPi ^ said to_ Barbara, A Muston
A . . _ i _
the nature of the supporters' hut, 4,^this given
would note the point.

N21/10/JftGy/kw/8120J

Read by machine highest quality of the three

——--.  MAY-12-'87 12:86  ID:  NMR CORP FIN  TEL NO:@1-626 9799    #248 Pa2






    FILE NOTE

    cc:   MIdeRR
          PHS
          Nigel Higgins
          Malcolm Thomson









        ee
        Barbara Muston rang on the following two matters:
        1. The Panel had accepted the point that we made the previous
        Friday, namely that David Reig of Tesco should be
        reprimanded for making the statement appearing in the
       “             Western      Mail,   concerning            the  likely      fall     in  the   share     |
                     of  Hillards     if    the bid         Failed.                                        price
                                                                          County      Bank    had   been  told
                     by  the     Panel  that    David       Reid     had     to  be   very    careful     as to
                     what     he  said  in  the   future,

                2.   Barbara      Muston   was  particularly              concerned          about  statements
                     made     by  Peter        Hartley  Which     were                in     the   Yorkshire
   +                 Post     on  Saturday,        9th  May,     as    well     as   comments      he made   in
                     the     BBC  programme                 Nortp:     on     8th    May.     This    relates to
                                                            Of                   The
                     unsubstantiated        levels                                    Yorkshire       Post
                     article      mentioned     continuing      support            from                      who
                     had    not  written in     and         On    the  pac    programme       rc’  erence    was
                     made     to  institutions        indicating          their
                     Barbara      Muston   said   that          this   was                          support.
                                                                           contrary          —   ote    2 of
           |         Rule     20  of  the  Code   and       the      Panel    took    serious     exception   to
           @
   a.                the   statements.        They                          that   a  press
                     be    sent   out  today    clarifYing      the        level      of   support,
        including the level of institutional support. Muston
  .                  further     went   on  to  say         that    if     peren   Hartley,      or   anyone  at
        Hillards or its advisers. made any further statements
                                                      ut                  Liat            Vaguc,      MES
        and unsubstantiated by COnFirmations, then the Panel, if
                     asked    by   Tesco,   would       be        Prepared    to   extend     the   closin”
  \                  date    of  the  bid.     The      Pane]     Went     on    to   say  that     befors
        further statements are made concerning levels of supper
                     they   would     have  to  be      cl@areg     through          them  first.
                     Clearly     the Panel     are very         concerned          about   this     and  we must
                ensure    that   no    further  statements      are        inade     which     are    not
                capable    of   being   substantiat®4.          the        panel     did   make     one  further
                point   and   that   was   if  we     saw   a     dropping       off of    levels     of
                support    We   should    also  announce        that               said    to  Barbara    Muston
                that  we   thought    it   highly     unlikely     that          this   would     happen   given
                the  nature     of  the  supporters»            but   We  would     note      the   point.

                         3      AGY/kw/81203
                N21/10/
        re



AEE
----. MAY-12-'87 12:86 ID: NMR CORP FIN TEL NO:@1-626 9799 #248 Pa2






FILE NOTE

cc: MIdeRR
PHS
Nigel Higgins
Malcolm Thomson









ee
Barbara Muston rang on the following two matters:
1. The Panel had accepted the point that we made the previous
Friday, namely that David Reig of Tesco should be
reprimanded for making the statement appearing in the
" Western Mail, concerning the likely fall in the share |
of Hillards if the bid Failed. price
County Bank had been told
by the Panel that David Reid had to be very careful as to
what he said in the future,

2. Barbara Muston was particularly concerned about statements
made by Peter Hartley Which were in the Yorkshire
+ Post on Saturday, 9th May, as well as comments he made in
the BBC programme Nortp: on 8th May. This relates to
Of The
unsubstantiated levels Yorkshire Post
article mentioned continuing support from who
had not written in and On the pac programme rc' erence was
made to institutions indicating their
Barbara Muston said that this was support.
contrary - ote 2 of
| Rule 20 of the Code and the Panel took serious exception to
@
a. the statements. They that a press
be sent out today clarifYing the level of support,
including the level of institutional support. Muston
. further went on to say that if peren Hartley, or anyone at
Hillards or its advisers. made any further statements
ut Liat Vaguc, MES
and unsubstantiated by COnFirmations, then the Panel, if
asked by Tesco, would be Prepared to extend the closin"
\ date of the bid. The Pane] Went on to say that befors
further statements are made concerning levels of supper
they would have to be cl@areg through them first.
Clearly the Panel are very concerned about this and we must
ensure that no further statements are inade which are not
capable of being substantiat®4. the panel did make one further
point and that was if we saw a dropping off of levels of
support We should also announce that said to Barbara Muston
that we thought it highly unlikely that this would happen given
the nature of the supporters» but We would note the point.

3 AGY/kw/81203
N21/10/
re



AEE

Read by machine, contrast corrected

——--.  MAY-12-'87 12:86  ID:  NMR CORP FIN  TEL NO:@1-626 9799    #248 Pa2






    FILE NOTE

    cc:   MIdeRR
          PHS
          Nigel Higgins
          Malcolm Thomson









        ee
        Barbara Muston rang on the following two matters:
        1. The Panel had accepted the point that we made the previous
        Friday, namely that David Reig of Tesco should be
        reprimanded for making the statement appearing in the
       “             Western      Mail,   concerning            the  likely      fall     in  the   share     |
                     of  Hillards     if    the bid         Failed.                                        price
                                                                          County      Bank    had   been  told
                     by  the     Panel  that    David       Reid     had     to  be   very    careful     as to
                     what     he  said  in  the   future,

                2.   Barbara      Muston   was  particularly              concerned          about  statements
                     made     by  Peter        Hartley  Which     were                in     the   Yorkshire
   +                 Post     on  Saturday,        9th  May,     as    well     as   comments      he made   in
                     the     BBC  programme                 Nortp:     on     8th    May.     This    relates to
                                                            Of                   The
                     unsubstantiated        levels                                    Yorkshire       Post
                     article      mentioned     continuing      support            from                      who
                     had    not  written in     and         On    the  pac    programme       rc’  erence    was
                     made     to  institutions        indicating          their
                     Barbara      Muston   said   that          this   was                          support.
                                                                           contrary          —   ote    2 of
           |         Rule     20  of  the  Code   and       the      Panel    took    serious     exception   to
           @
   a.                the   statements.        They                          that   a  press
                     be    sent   out  today    clarifYing      the        level      of   support,
        including the level of institutional support. Muston
  .                  further     went   on  to  say         that    if     peren   Hartley,      or   anyone  at
        Hillards or its advisers. made any further statements
                                                      ut                  Liat            Vaguc,      MES
        and unsubstantiated by COnFirmations, then the Panel, if
                     asked    by   Tesco,   would       be        Prepared    to   extend     the   closin”
  \                  date    of  the  bid.     The      Pane]     Went     on    to   say  that     befors
        further statements are made concerning levels of supper
                     they   would     have  to  be      cl@areg     through          them  first.
                     Clearly     the Panel     are very         concerned          about   this     and  we must
                ensure    that   no    further  statements      are        inade     which     are    not
                capable    of   being   substantiat®4.          the        panel     did   make     one  further
                point   and   that   was   if  we     saw   a     dropping       off of    levels     of
                support    We   should    also  announce        that               said    to  Barbara    Muston
                that  we   thought    it   highly     unlikely     that          this   would     happen   given
                the  nature     of  the  supporters»            but   We  would     note      the   point.

                         3      AGY/kw/81203
                N21/10/
        re



AEE
----. MAY-12-'87 12:86 ID: NMR CORP FIN TEL NO:@1-626 9799 #248 Pa2






FILE NOTE

cc: MIdeRR
PHS
Nigel Higgins
Malcolm Thomson









ee
Barbara Muston rang on the following two matters:
1. The Panel had accepted the point that we made the previous
Friday, namely that David Reig of Tesco should be
reprimanded for making the statement appearing in the
" Western Mail, concerning the likely fall in the share |
of Hillards if the bid Failed. price
County Bank had been told
by the Panel that David Reid had to be very careful as to
what he said in the future,

2. Barbara Muston was particularly concerned about statements
made by Peter Hartley Which were in the Yorkshire
+ Post on Saturday, 9th May, as well as comments he made in
the BBC programme Nortp: on 8th May. This relates to
Of The
unsubstantiated levels Yorkshire Post
article mentioned continuing support from who
had not written in and On the pac programme rc' erence was
made to institutions indicating their
Barbara Muston said that this was support.
contrary - ote 2 of
| Rule 20 of the Code and the Panel took serious exception to
@
a. the statements. They that a press
be sent out today clarifYing the level of support,
including the level of institutional support. Muston
. further went on to say that if peren Hartley, or anyone at
Hillards or its advisers. made any further statements
ut Liat Vaguc, MES
and unsubstantiated by COnFirmations, then the Panel, if
asked by Tesco, would be Prepared to extend the closin"
\ date of the bid. The Pane] Went on to say that befors
further statements are made concerning levels of supper
they would have to be cl@areg through them first.
Clearly the Panel are very concerned about this and we must
ensure that no further statements are inade which are not
capable of being substantiat®4. the panel did make one further
point and that was if we saw a dropping off of levels of
support We should also announce that said to Barbara Muston
that we thought it highly unlikely that this would happen given
the nature of the supporters» but We would note the point.

3 AGY/kw/81203
N21/10/
re



AEE